View more on these topics

Offshore Trusts

Before 19 March 1991 it was possible for UK resident domiciliaries to create offshore trusts, retain an interest in that trust, but escape capital gains tax on capital gains that accrued to the trust until such time as the settlor (or another beneficiary) received a capital payment from the trust. Following changes made in the Finance Act 1998, this regime no longer exists for gains made after 5th April 1999 on such trusts unless the settlor is either non-UK resident or non-UK domiciled.



In a recent case before the Special Commissioners the meaning of &#34capital payment&#34 was examined. The Inland Revenue sought to argue that interest free loans from such an offshore trust to the settlors were in fact capital distributions from the trust rendering them liable to CGT on any accrued gains of the trust that could be attributed to the payment.



The facts of the case were that both taxpayers (Cooper and Fisher) were domiciled and resident in the UK in the relevant tax years. The taxpayer in each appeal settled funds on trustees not resident in the UK before 19 March 1991 on terms that the trust property was held on trust to pay the income to the taxpayer during his lifetime with powers to apply capital for the benefit of the taxpayer.



Each taxpayer was assessed to capital gains tax under on the basis that they had received capital payments within the meaning of s97 of TCGA 1992,.



The taxpayers accepted that the loans were &#39capital payments&#39 within s97(1) of TCGA 1992, and (2), but the Revenue&#39s difficulty was in quantifying the amount that was taxable. In this respect s97(4) of TCGA 1992, provided that in order to be taxable the amount of a capital payment is &#39equal to the value of the benefit conferred by it&#39.



The Revenue accepted that the benefit conferred by these loans on each taxpayer was very little or nil because the loans were repayable on demand, but argued that by allowing the taxpayers free use of the money, the trustees also made capital payments on a continuing basis. This meant that while the loans were outstanding, the benefit to the taxpayers corresponded to the interest which would have been payable to a commercial lender.



The special commissioners said that the words of s97 TCGA 1992 contemplated single identifiable payments made on single identifiable occasions, rather than payments made on a continuing basis. Further, it was difficult to see how the taxpayers as beneficiaries of the settlements could benefit from loans from the trustees when they would themselves have been entitled to any interest payable in respect of the loans.



The appeals by the taxpayers were allowed.




COMMENT



This is important decision that may well go further on appeal. For pre 19 March 1991 trusts that have realised capital gains, it has been common practice for trustees to make interest free loans to beneficiaries with a view to minimising CGT liabilities. Many thought that the interest forgone (compared to a commercial rate) would equal the capital benefit to be attributed to previous capital gains. By judicial calculation the benefit gain could be equal to the current CGT annual exemption. Of course sizeable interest free loans will not possible each year because the previous loans and capital benefit thereon would need to be taken into account.



On the basis of this decision interest free loans can be made without concern as to triggering a CGT charge linked to capital gains realised before 17 March 1998. It will need to be seen whether the Inland Revenue let the position rest there.

Recommended

Norwich Union appoints head of international fixed income

Norwich Union Investment Management has appointed Colin Harte as head of its international fixed income team.Harte joins NU from Gartmore where he was principal and head of bond investment.He has extensive experience in this field having worked for Guardian Royal Exchange, Hill Samuel and Citibank before joining NatWest in 1994. He then moved to Gartmore […]

FTSE International launches global indices

FTSE International has launched a fresh attack on Dow Jones in its continuing war over global domination of world stockmarket indices.To counteract Dow Jones&#39 launch of its Titans index based on the largest 50 companies in the world earlier this year. FTSE International has responded by launching the FTSE Multinationals and FTSE Global 100 indices.The […]

Fleming offers free share exchange

Fleming Investment Trust Management is offering to waive its normal share dealing charge for UK listed companies if the proceeds are re-invested into its Mid Cap Investment Trust.The special offer is available until December 10 and allows investors to save £12.50 when selling their UK shares.Fleming manager Debbie Cash says: &#34The share exchange offer is […]

Industry has vital role to play in long term care market

Royal Commission on long-term care chairman Sir Stewart Sutherland has told the insurance industry it has a vital role to play in ltc provision But he warned the Government that its failure to provide a clear direction could undermine the private sector.It came as health minister John Hutton promised a thorough Government review of the […]

Health - thumbnail

Healthcare predictions for 2015 from Jelf Employee Benefits

The continuing fall-out from the Competition and Markets Authority’s (CMA’s) review, the rise of the private GP and digital engagement will be the primary focuses in the private healthcare industry during 2015, according to Iain Laws, managing director, healthcare and group risk, at Jelf Employee Benefits.

Newsletter

News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up

Comments

    Leave a comment