View more on these topics

Nothing ventured nothing gained

With barely £50m scraped between them this year, venture capital trusts are struggling to overcome poor market conditions and huge falls in investors&#39 capital gains tax liability.

Coming after the record 2000/01 tax year in which they pulled in around £430m, VCTs have hit a brick wall, suffering from the sustained market falls which have left a much smaller number of investors needing to roll over their CGT liability.

But while there is little doubt that the stockmarket has played the biggest part in the shrinking of the market – with only two new offerings launched this year – IFAs believe there are additional reasons for the current slump in demand.

Some, for instance, believe that VCTs have to some extent shot themselves in the foot by persisting with marketing campaigns which have left them with nowhere to go once the tax advantage angle is rendered irrelevant by the stockmarket.

Hargreaves Lansdown investment manager Ben Yearsley says: “In the past, VCTs have been marketed on tax breaks and have totally ignored the investment case. Whenever returns have been mentioned, they are always quoted after all tax relief has been taken into account, giving a false impression of performance. What people want to see is the performance of the manager, not some jiggery-pokery.”

Yearsley believes fund managers have begun to catch on to the fact that they need to promote their products on some other basis than tax breaks and have accepted that the CGT liability many investors faced due to the technology boom has gone.

The realisation led last year to a number of fund managers changing tack, making a far bigger play of their VCTs&#39 investment capability and process – something that Yearsley believes will become the norm over the next few years.

However, for some observers, changing the way in which VCTs are presented to investors is simply skimming the surface of a problem that runs far deeper.

Bates Investment believes VCTs are too elitist to ever achieve mainstream popularity and need to find a way to appeal to a wider audience.

Senior investment adviser Kerry Nelson says: “It is people with millions of pounds who have invested in VCTs because they are most effective for those in the 40 per cent tax bracket. But in these market conditions it is diffi-cult to try and attract just one type of investor.

“VCTs need to be more readily available to more people, which could be done by dropping some of the minimum requirements and making them less complex.”

Nelson believes VCTs should be aimed at people earning around £50,000 a year who have used up their Isa allowance but perhaps have an annual bonus to invest.

She says this would boost VCTs&#39 popularity and help them shed the snooty connotations that she believes have acted as a hindrance.

Only 30,000 people have invested in VCTs in the seven years they have been available. Around nine million people hold an Isa or a Pep. It is a discrepancy that fund managers are keen to address.

Octopus Asset Management is launching a VCT next month that will invest in UK smaller companies and is one manager that is trying to close the gap through a combination of edu-cation and marketing.

In a sector that has seen Matrix Money Management&#39s latest VCT, Cornerstone, struggle to raise anything close to £1m since launch more than a month ago, OAM&#39s Phoenix VCT is seeking £15m.

Fund manager Justin Jordan says: “The key is to offer a product that is tailored to the needs of clients of IFAs. If you can create a propo-sition that suits the market as it stands – as a smaller companies funds does at the moment – and market it extensively then I think you can do well.

“But the problem is that if you asked the average person on the street what VCTs are then most would not know or, if they did have some idea, they would probably say they are risky investments.”

To combat this, OAM is embarking on a countrywide marketing blitz designed to persuade hundreds of IFAs that Phoenix represents a solid – and reasonably safe – investment.

One of the angles it is taking is to highlight the changes it has made to improve the failings that IFAs have pinpointed about VCTs in their discussions. One of these relates to the poor decisions that some trusts have made in the past – several invested directly in technology stocks or split caps – and so Phoenix will invest in cash until investment opportunities arise.

Another problem that OAM has sought to address is a lack of liquidity, which Jordan says has forced investors needing to exit quickly to sell at a big discount.

But even with these refinements, Jordan admits that Phoenix&#39s success will hinge on OAM&#39s marketing campaign. He believes the reason that so few people have invested in them is principally because they have been under-marketed.

Phoenix will be competing with around nine or 10 VCTs for what Jordan believes will be roughly £100m in this tax year but of these only one other – Cornerstone – is a new offering. The rest are seeking additional funding.

For this reason, Yearsley believes Phoenix and Corner-stone may struggle to raise as much money as they are hoping, with wary investors sticking to what they know are the established VCTs.

He believes this will continue to be the case for as long as the stockmarket displays the kind of volatility that investors have seen.

Skilled and experienced operators are likely to remain in the market but potential entrants will perhaps decide that for £5m – widely seen as the critical mass required – launching a VCT is not worthwhile. As things stand, no one could blame them.


FSA drops DPS for Aifa&#39s menu system

The FSA is dropping its defined-payment system in favour of Aifa&#39s menu system, leaving IFAs free to be paid commission as long as they offer consumers a payment menu including fees.But the FSA is also propo-sing that for popular products IFAs must give a comparison of the commission they earn with the market average. Some […]

&#39Teps good value even if bonuses are slashed&#39

Self-employed people buy houses nearly a third more expensive than the average, says UCB Home Loans.The average house purchase price for self-certification loan is £152,000 while the average is £111,000.UCB Home Loans&#39 first self-employed report, published this month, reveals that London tops the regional league, with self-employed people paying around £211,000 for a property while […]

Higher-rate tax relief for pensions

I would just like to clarify my position with respect to higher-rate tax relief for pensions.Contrary to the article of October 24 in Money Marketing, I am not proposing scrapping higher rate. It was a comment from the Inland Revenue which apparently talked about this.My proposal is that everyone should get higher incentives for their […]

Park Row new arm aims for non-conform market

Park Row Independent Mortgages is launching into the non-conforming sector through a new sub-prime division.It has created Park Row Specialist Lending in partnership with packager The Mortgage Placement Company to offer loans, including self-certification and right to buy, through its 280 advisers and will pay a procuration fee of 1.75 per cent. It is also […]

US equities: opportunities for short sellers expand

Optimism is as American as baseball and apple pie. And since the financial crisis, being optimistic about US equities has paid off: they have outperformed every other major developed market by a comfortable margin. Yet while there remain plenty of good reasons to be optimistic about US equities, Stephen Moore, manager of the Artemis US […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm