View more on these topics

No more beating about the Bush

While Rome burns – or at least the future of UK pensions continues to do so – the Bush administration has come up with a radical simplification of the strategy for lifetime savings.

The White House, viewed from outside the US, appears to be focused entirely on Iraq, but the administration has been focused on the pension and savings gap.

Announcing his budget package, President Bush said: “Americans can help secure their own future by saving. Government must support policies that promote and protect saving. Saving is the path to independence for Americans in all phases of life and we must encourage more Americans to take that path.”

In the case of the US, we seem to be getting action and not merely more consultation. The UK Government&#39s Pensions Green Paper will not end its consultative stage until Easter. The likelihood of legislation in 2004/05 seems remote.

So what does the US budget package contain? The first proposal creates a lifetime savings account. To be fair to the UK authorities, many of the characteristics of this proposal are contained within the Isa.

The new LSA will be a tax-favoured account which can be used for any purpose – education saving, healthcare and so on. The really imaginative thing is that it allows any individual, regardless of income or age, to contribute $7,500 a year and make as many withdrawals as desired tax-free.

This is an important milestone in savings policy which the UK Government should consider carefully as part of the Sandler review of savings and the development of cradle-to-grave concepts such as the proposed child trust fund.

The ability of an individual, regardless of age, to invest in a single account for saving is a significant step. The other interesting feature is that the contribution limits will be indexed, allowing real growth in savings potential, freed of the constraints of inflationary pressure.

This is something that the Pep and Isa Managers&#39 Association has long been lobbying for in the UK.

Bush&#39s assistant treasury secretary Pam Olson believes the LSA will encourage more low and middle-income families to save. Certainly, the UK experience with Isas has shown this but the LSA builds on the Isa structure in a way which we ought to consider in terms of savings design in the UK.

However, perhaps the more important milestone is the creation of retirement savings accounts and employer retirement savings accounts.

In one move, the Bush administration is sweeping away around five or six differing pension regimes and replacing them with one personal or employer-based option.

Under RSAs, individuals will be able to roll up income for pension use completely tax-free. After 58 – or, importantly, after death or disability – tax-free distributions can be taken. In terms of holistic tax and benefit planning, this is a significant step in the right direction.

According to the US treasury&#39s document: “There are currently multiple tax-preferred employer-based accounts all with similar goals but differing rules regulating eligibility, contribution limits, tax treatment and withdrawal restrictions.”

Anyone reading those lines might have thought they were attending one of Steve Bee&#39s Scottish Life pension roadshows or reading a Stewart Ritchie pension policy briefing from Aegon.

In one clean sweep, Bush is making retirement saving less complicated, which should prove to be extremely popular for financial consumers. He intends to get rid of 401(k) plans, thrift plans, 403b schemes and governmental 457 plans. The aim is to provide the same basic structure as an RSA but within the framework of work.

In the US, only about 50 per cent of employees take up their company pension. The US treasury hopes this package will increase coverage and participation because firms are put off providing retirement savings options for employees due to the complexity and cost.

The US treasury says: “The reduction in red tape will remove a barrier that discourages small business owners from offering this benefit to their employees.”

These plans are designed to come into effect on January 1, 2004. I think this is a significant step in the right direction.

The Bush package goes a long way towards coming up with innovative and workable solutions to encourage cradle-to-grave saving and improving the attractiveness of employer-based retirement savings.

The UK Government would do well to cast an eye over these proposals and look to incorporate their best elements into any future legislation here.

We should not continue to fiddle while Rome is on fire. Perhaps a trip across the pond for Treasury ministers and officials might help to dampen the flames that are engulfing pensions and savings in the UK.

Iain Anderson is director and chief corporate counsel at Cicero Consulting


Smee in call for test runs of FSA&#39s key facts regime

The FSA should test its proposed disclosure document in a series of pilot schemes to ensure that consumers will take to it before forcing the industry to embark on the costly exercise of implementing it, says Aifa director general Paul Smee.Speaking at Money Mark-eting&#39s Top 100 Summit in Croydon last week, Smee said he did […]

E-developments will overtake seller&#39s packs

I was interested to read the article, Seller&#39s packs widely welcomed in survey (Money Marketing, January 16).Any initiative which aims to improve the housebuying process can only be a good thing, particularly as England has one of the slowest homebuying and selling processes in Europe.However, seller&#39s packs are by no means the panacea to solving […]

Pru survey shows average pensioner&#39s income is £13.7k

Britain&#39s 10 million pensioners have a total annual income of £142.88bn, averaging £13,765, according to new research from Prudential.But only 3 per cent have £40,000 a year or more and one in three pensioners survive on annual income of £10,000 or less in the survey of 1,200 retired people carried out last December.Retired people in […]

AITC says scrap VAT on trusts to boost savings

The AITC is urging the Government to abolish VAT on the management services supplied to investment trusts, arguing that it reduces their competitiveness compared with Oeics and unit trusts.In its response to the Government&#39s consultation on the way that VAT is levied on pension and investment funds, AITC technical director Ian Sayers says scrapping the […]

Globe - thumbnail

Considerations for overseas workers in Germany

With Germany’s strong economic growth leading the eurozone’s recovery, many UK businesses are keen to be part of the success story: recent data shows that there are currently more than 280,000* employees working for a UK-controlled company in the country.


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm