View more on these topics

Neil Liversidge: Why life companies hate advisers’ independence

Neil Liversidge

For all their professed commitment to independent advice, life companies hate advisers’ independence and lust after owning distribution. Continuing with my recap on my experiences of the last 36 years, Hill Samuel taught me that they all have a secret hankering for the days of the direct sales force.

Hill Samuel’s strategy was, on the one hand, to own a supposed independent financial advice firm in Noble Lowndes, while simultaneously propagating a captive direct sales force. The customers’ interests always came as distant second, often in the ways that look scandalous to our eyes today.

Back in the early 1980s so-called “capital conversion schemes” were popular. One involved using a lump sum to buy a five-year capital protected temporary annuity, which would then fund £20 per month into the government’s save-as-you-earn scheme: a regular savings deposit account that promised index linking plus, at the end of five years, a bonus equal to three months’ contributions.

Depending on interest rates, which in those days often fluctuated monthly, the typical cost would be around £1020 for a contract that would fund a total of £1200 into the scheme over five years. That was based on a standard 2 per cent commission rate on temporary annuities as fixed by the old Life Offices Association’s maximum commission agreement.

However, the agreement paid no attention to what groups did internally. Hill Samuel paid Noble Lowndes’ consultants 8 per cent by the simple expedient of shaving 6 per cent off the rate at the client’s expense, typically boosting the cost of the product to around £1080. It does not sound much these days but it was a fair sum back then.

Other products had similar incentives built in to persuade Noble Lowndes’ consultants to keep the business flowing to Hill Samuel Life Assurance Ltd.

Neil Liversidge

Maintaining your independence

After I had crossed over from the insurance company side of the business to the adviser side, Knight Williams showed the vertically integrated model could work well if done properly, as Towry and St James’s Place have proved.

Knight Williams’ Robin Knight Bruce famously described consultants who sold non-Knight Williams products as “compliance nightmares”. The press slated him for it but he had a point. When those doing the selling do not own the business and therefore do not carry the can, some will sell rubbish.

The compliance overhead required to quality-control a large independent adviser force makes the large independent model uneconomic. A restricted model should contain costs. Knight Williams’ sin was to be restricted while pretending to be independent, while simultaneously being more expensive than pretty much everyone else.

The DBS network was independent in the sense panels were compiled objectively. However, the life companies put temptation in the way of members and DBS encouraged them to do it, aggressively soliciting egregious commission deals.

“Knight Williams’ sin was to be restricted while pretending to be independent, while simultaneously being more expensive than pretty much everyone else.”

Did it impact independence? Of course it did. The proportion of investment bonds sold compared with collectives said it all. Sure, DBS members could give up commission to enhance the investment for the client but not many did. It was pretty much down to the ethics of individual member firms and their individual advisers.

Next month, in the final part of this series, I will try and draw some conclusions on the future for independent advice.

Neil Liversidge is managing director of West Riding Personal Financial Solutions 



Neil Liversidge: Fatal flaws of past network models

This third part of my look at the changing face of independence starts with my arrival in the research and technical support department of DBS in 1995. Ken Davy had set up DBS some years before. He was an inspirational leader who genuinely believed in independence. I arrived just as the firm was debating whether […]

Five ways to invest in the connected world

Smart utility metering; fitness trackers; connected cars; smart factories; precision agriculture: the internet of things encompasses myriad applications. But how do you gain exposure – and profit – from this growing trend, asks Neptune fund manager & CTO Ali Unwin. Read more: Important information Investment risks Neptune funds may have a high historic volatility rating […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There are 4 comments at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. Bulls Eye Neil.

  2. Yep the back-to back annuity/endowment
    Such a horrible product but the life company gave us huge browny points for it
    I still feel shame for selling it to a family who put their trust in us- it was a modest sum but not for them! I knew it but monthly targets needed to be met 🙁

  3. I have so enjoyed reading this series of articles. They’ve reminded me of so much I’d forgotten. With this man’s honesty, experience, perspective and incisiveness, why is he not sitting on the FCA’s board?

  4. @Brian Benson
    Because of his honesty, experience, perspective and incisiveness…

Leave a comment


Why register with Money Marketing ?

Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

Money Marketing Events
Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

Research and insight
Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

Have your say
Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

Register now

Having problems?

Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm