View more on these topics

NAPF says 11-member FTT will cost UK schemes £1bn a year

James-Walsh-700x450.png
Walsh: FTT ‘is going nowhere fast’

The proposed European Financial Transaction Tax would cost UK pension scheme members £1bn a year, according to estimates from the National Association of Pension Funds.

Speaking at the Money Marketing Retirement Planning Summit in Cork last week, NAPF EU policy lead James Walsh warned the FTT would have a dramatic effect on British savers despite the fact the UK is not one of the 11 member states looking to push ahead with the tax. 

The proposed FTT would levy a 0.01 per cent charge on derivatives transactions and 0.1 per cent on the transactions of other investments, including securities, equities, Ucits and foreign exchange trading. 

Eleven member states, including France and Germany, are looking to push ahead with an enhanced co-operation procedure to create the tax on their own, due to resistance from other EU member states.

Walsh warned delegates that UK pension schemes investing or trading in securities issued in any of the 11 states would face the tax on such transactions as well as when dealing with branches of financial firms which have their headquarters in one of the 11 countries. 

Walsh said: “The problem is this proposal would not just affect those member states, France and Germany, it would effect pension schemes in the UK as well. 

“If you are a pension scheme and you transact a security that was issued in one of those 11 member states, the transaction will be deemed to have taken place in that country and the tax will apply. If you deal with the branch with headquarters in one of the 11 countries, the same applies.”

Walsh said one NAPF member had calculated it would have had to pay £35m last year under the proposals, while another reported it would have been charged £5m. Overall, Walsh said it could cost UK schemes £1bn a year, with the costs past down to savers. 

Walsh also highlighted practical problems such as HMRC having to set up a transmission mechanism to pass the tax to the tax authorities of the 11 member states. 

The FTT was set to be introduced at the start of next year but Walsh said this was now highly unlikely due to arguments over detail between the 11 states, for instance Italy wants government bonds excluded form the tax.

The UK has also launched a challenge to the FTT in the European Courts of Justice on the grounds that it will have a significant impact on countries outside the 11. “That looks like a pretty good challenge to me,” said Walsh. 

He added: “This is going nowhere fast. What might happen is that at some point it will be introduced, perhaps first in a narrower form but in future years it might have its remit and the base of the tax expanded to a wider base.”

Recommended

Pensions regulator considers ‘watch list’ in liberation clampdown

The Pensions Regulator is considering introducing a pension liberation “watch list” as part of a clamp-down on fraudulent schemes. TPR is part of a task force comprising the Government, police and other agencies attempting to tackle the rise in the number of people accessing their pension before age 55 using a liberation scheme. A number […]

3

FCA requests data from insurers in annuity market review

The Financial Conduct Authority has requested pricing information from insurance companies as part of its investigation into the annuity market. The regulator launched a thematic review of annuities in January this year in response to concerns people are failing to shop around when they reach retirement. The FCA has now written to pension providers requesting […]

1

Warning over EU regulation ‘mission creep’ as Eiopa targets personal pensions

The National Association of Pensions Funds has warned of potential “mission creep” in European regulation as Eiopa seeks to extend its remit to include personal pensions. European Insurance and Occupational Pensions Authority chairman Gabriel Bernardino told delegates at a seminar in Frankfurt this month there is a good case for EU-wide regulation of personal pensions. […]

HMRC excludes transactional discretionary fees from VAT

HMRC has confirmed that transactional fees for discretionary management services will not need to include VAT, following last year’s landmark European Court of Justice judgment. The case involved Deutsche Bank’s discretionary services and whether VAT should be charged for ongoing services and on annual management fees. The European Court of Justice recommended all elements of […]

Lifetime ISAs – International Evidence

By Fiona Tait, Pensions Specialist Since the announcement in March, the Lifetime ISA (LISA) has attracted controversy. Heralded as a saviour for the self-employed and the young wanting to get on the housing ladder, the new LISA risks adding confusion for savers trying to fully understand the benefits of new workplace pension savings through auto-enrolment. To […]

Newsletter

News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up

Comments

    Leave a comment