View more on these topics

MPs say Philip Green has ‘moral duty’ to save BHS pensions


Former BHS owner Sir Philip Green has a “moral duty” to repair the firm’s £571m pensions deficit, according to a damning Government report on the retailer’s collapse.

A joint report from the Work and Pensions and Business, Innovation and Skills Committees says Green must to act now to help the BHS pensioners.

It adds this will “undoubtedly require him to make a large financial contribution”.

It says: “He has a moral duty to act, a duty which he acknowledges. We still do not doubt that Sir Philip has heartfelt affection for BHS. To an extent it created him; it could also bring him down.”

The report adds: “Sir Philip’s failure until now to resolve the pension fund’s problems contributed substantially to the demise of BHS, along with chronic under-investment and the systematic extraction of hundreds of millions of pounds from the increasingly ailing company.”

The document says when Green bought BHS the firm’s pension schemes had a surplus.

However, under Green’s watch these slid into “substantial and unsustainable deficit”, with Green and his board ignoring trustees’ demands for higher contributions.

The report says: “Such contributions were not charitable donations: they were the means of the employer meeting its obligations for deferred pay.

“We reject any assertion that Sir Philip was not aware of the growth of the deficit: he had a responsibility to be aware and he was aware. That there is a massive deficit is ultimately Sir Philip Green’s responsibility.”

Screen Shot 2016-07-25 at 08.18.07

The scheme says the 23-year recovery period for the pension scheme was “extraordinary”.

It says: “The annual payments of £10m, which were calculated with no apparent regard to the sustainability of the scheme, were presented to the trustees as a non-negotiable offer. The payments were wholly inadequate and the deficit continued to grow.”

BHS directors drew up a plan, ‘Project Thor’, to save the BHS pension schemes.

But MPs say the board then interrupted the running of the plan without good reason.

The report says: “The Arcadia board cited a variety of explanations for pausing Project Thor, ranging from Christmas to the Scottish independence referendum and instability in Ukraine.

“In fact, the primary reason was Sir Philip Green’s resistance to The Pension Regulator’s moral hazard requests. He did not wish to respond to requests for information regarding historic dividends, management charges, sale and leaseback arrangements, inter-company loans and the use of BHS shares or assets as collateral for company purchases. At best this demonstrated a lack of willingness to act to secure the pension fund’s future.”

Royal London director of policy Steve Webb says: “Whether Sir Philip Green has a legal duty to top up the BHS pension scheme will be decided by The Pensions Regulator. But this report shows that he has a clear moral duty to do so.

“The very BHS workers whose efforts produced the profits for BHS’s owners in the good years are the same people whose pensions are now at risk of being cut. Sir Philip Green has no excuse for being so apparently unaware of his responsibilities towards the company pension scheme and it is now time for action to deal with the problem.”

Hargreaves Lansdown head of retirement policy Tom McPhail says: “The report is a comprehensive and damning analysis of what went wrong at BHS. Almost no one emerges from the affair untainted.

“The report exposes the tensions between shareholder and pension scheme member interests, and poses some important questions about how we manage these tensions for the thousands of other schemes which continue to operate under the shadow of substantial deficits.”

McPhail adds the future holds “significant threats” for pension schemes.

He says: “The possibility of an economic slowdown and increasing inflation could exacerbate an already unsustainable mismatch between the promises made to some scheme members and the ability of sponsoring employers ever to pay for those promises.

“There is an urgent need to take a step back and look at how best to meet the competing demands of all the parties involved. This should be an urgent priority for the new Pensions Minister.”

Green’s knighthood is reported to be under review.



DB lifeboat fund in £4bn surplus despite BHS collapse

The Pension Protection Fund has a surplus of £4.1bn, a funding ratio of 116.3 per cent, its annual report shows. The defined benefit lifeboat fund, which is funded by a levy on schemes, had to take on the pension assets and liabilities of failed retailer BHS, which collapsed in the spring. BHS as the largest […]


Green blocked Pensions Regulator talks ahead of BHS sale

Sir Philip Green refused a request from the eventual buyer of failed retailer BHS to speak to the Pensions Regulator over concerns about its pension scheme, the Sunday Times reports. The firm entered administration earlier this month with a defined benefit pension deficit estimated at around half a billion pounds. Green sold BHS to Dominic […]


MPs to demand Phillip Green pays £600m into BHS pension scheme

MPs holding an inquiry into the collapse of retailer BHS are set to ask former owner Sir Phillip Green to pay up to £600m to help close the pension scheme deficit. According to the FT, Work and Pensions committee chair Frank Field said MPs would “laugh” if Green offered to pay anything less. Field estimates […]

State of the markets: global growth

In conversation with journalist Alexis Xydias, Artemis Global Growth Fund manager Peter Saacke discusses the state of global markets and how he is positioning his fund. Peter gives his views on the growth potential of US, Europe and emerging markets, each of which is on a different stage of the road to recovery. And with a […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There are 7 comments at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. This does not surprise me way back far as 1992 people have been saying DB schemes are unsustainable current format.

  2. Don’t you just love the way MPs go on about “moral duty”! In pensions more than almost anything else they have certainly lost sight of that moral duty to the population! They look after their own pensions but God help the rest of us with a private sector pension hopefully supplemented by a less than penurious state pension. The two tier state pension they have endorsed that will last for the next 60 or 70 years for those who retired pre-or post-April 6 is a travesty of “moral duty”.

  3. Poppycock. It was a private company. He SOLD It. If anyone had the duty is was the numptie purchasers. It was their company and their responsibility.

  4. David Cathcart 25th July 2016 at 4:23 pm

    Does this moral duty extend to the schemes actuaries to refund their not insignificant fees. The funding position is the responsibility of the schemes trustees, who correct me if I am wrong, are also personally liable for any decisions made on behalf of the scheme, what part did they play in appointing the actuaries and investment managers, who job it is to ensure scheme solvency !!

  5. Julian Stevens 25th July 2016 at 5:19 pm

    It sounds very much like Green just gutted the company financially then threw it away like a broken toy, claiming that he’d known nothing about the pension scheme or its huge deficit. Not a nice man. At all.

  6. The substantial dividends taken by Mr Green were also taken between 2002 and 2004.

    Not sure if the MP’s missed that point.

    At that. Stage the scheme was solvent.

    It would also be interesting know the impact of removing Dividend Tax Relief.

  7. Moral Duty, means nothing to an unpleasant individual with not a moral bone in his body.

Leave a comment


Why register with Money Marketing ?

Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

Money Marketing Events
Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

Research and insight
Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

Have your say
Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

Register now

Having problems?

Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm