MPs push British Steel advice firms for answers on fees

Work and pensions select committee chair Frank Field

Work and pensions committee chair Frank Field has written to two witnesses who failed to attend last week’s committee hearing into the British Steel Pension Scheme to find out how they made money from clients.

Two out of six letters published on 19 December by the committee concern the activities of Active Wealth and Celtic Wealth Management, which have stopped giving DB transfer advice following work by the FCA.

Field wants answers to his questions by 8 January next year when parliament returns from recess.

One letter is addressed to Celtic Wealth Management managing director Clive Howells and the other to Active Wealth director Darren Reynolds.

Celtic Wealth Management, while not an adviser firm, is an introducer and has a business relationship with Active Wealth which has been under scrutiny from regulators and lawmakers.

In the letter to Howells, Field asks for a breakdown of the different fees Celtic Wealth Management charged to clients.

He wants to know the highest and average fee the introducer received from customers alongside the proportion of fees either paid directly by clients, independent financial or other companies.

Field also wants to know how many payments Celtic Wealth Management has made to individuals who recommended their services to clients.

In the letter to Active Wealth director Reynolds, Field asks what the highest and average transfer value handled in respect of British Steel customers was.

There are additional questions about what proportion of clients have been charged on a no transfer-no fee contingent basis/conditional basis and what proportion of customers are liable to pay ongoing fees.

Reynolds is also asked to provide information about how the firm assessed risk when providing investment advice to clients and the range of investment vehicles offered to them.

Field says: “Transferring out of a gold plated final salary pension is generally a terrible idea, except in very particular circumstances.

“Firms that are routinely advising people to take this route should be shut out of taking this type of business. I am very interested to hear the ‘particular circumstances’ that justify the advice Active Wealth gave, which they tell us resulted in around 100 members transferring out of the BSPS before they were stopped, and the total fees they have received for this wisdom.”



SJP stops accepting DB transfers from British Steel members

St James’s Place has confirmed it will no long accept new defined benefit pension transfer requests from British Steel members. At a work and pensions select committee hearing this morning, it was estimated that of the 38,000 British Steel members, 12,200 have applied for a transfer value and more than 2,000 transfers have been made […]


FCA reviews clients files over British Steel pension transfers

The FCA has visited 16 advice firms to review their recommendations to transfer out of the British Steel Pension Scheme, the regulator has disclosed. In a letter to work and pensions select committee chair Frank Field, FCA strategy and competition director Chris Woolard confirms the scope of the regulator’s work to date as it continues […]

FCA backs public meeting over British Steel pensions

The FCA, The Pensions Regulator and The Pensions Advisory Service are to attend a public meeting at Port Talbot on Thursday for British Steel Pension Scheme members. The FCA confirmed the meeting was taking place and that executive supervision director investment, wholesale and specialist Megan Butler would represent it there. The meeting is a chance […]


Woodford dropped by another fund house

Architas has fully disinvested from the Woodford Equity Income fund within its six-strong £920m multi-asset fund range as it raises concerns over the manager’s current style, Money Marketing has learned. The firm has reduced the overall asset allocation to UK equities in the range as it decides to focus on fewer more “flexible” fund managers […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There are 8 comments at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. Wonder when Frank Field got his Diploma.

  2. I am certainly not condoning or criticising any transfer out or otherwise however I believe the suggestion that the BSPS is still a Gold Plated final salary scheme is overstating its status. I would respectfully suggest MP’s et all are held to the same standards as advisers in ensuring any statements they make are fair and not misleading.

  3. Given that “Celtic Wealth Management£ acts only as an introducer and doesn’t actually manage wealth for anyone, is it not possible to prosecute under the Trade Description Act?!!!

  4. What is of “interest” and concerning is that ‘Neither Celtic Wealth Management and Financial Planning Limited or any of its divisions are regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority and as such do not offer advice’ as per its website. And that ‘All regulated advice in relation to Pensions and Investments is given by Darren Reynolds, Chartered Financial Planner or his qualified advisors of Active Wealth (UK) Ltd, which is regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority.’ So who what where and how?

  5. dont matter whether chartered or not gone bust

  6. toothless field to late as useaul

Leave a comment