View more on these topics

Moving goalposts of exemption

Last week, I looked at the important conditions that must be satisfied in securing exemption from tax on redundancy payments. Having finished that analysis, it occurred to me that I really should have preceded it with a consideration of whether a payment was, by its nature, one that could qualify for the special exemptions in respect of redundancy payments as opposed to being one assessable under the general rules of Schedule E. In the latter case, there is no chance that any exemption can apply, so it is a pretty important thing to establish.

While there are a number of relatively complex technical issues to consider in determining the tax treatment of any payment on termination of employment, as there has been a substantial amount of case law and concessions issued on the subject, the fundamental issue is determining whether the payment should be assessable under section 19 ICTA 1988 or under the special provisions of section 148 ICTA 1988.

The main case determining chargeability under the general Schedule E rules is that of Hochstrasser •Mayes 38 TC 673.

In this case, it was determined that it is insufficient for the Inland Revenue to show that the payment would not have been made but for the employee&#39s employment.

The key test is to demonstrate that the payment was derived from the employment and that the terms of the employment required the payment to be made in consideration for the provision of services, either future or past.

This appears to mean that, if it can be shown that a payment made on the termination of an employee&#39s employment is not made in consideration of the provision of services by the employee, no tax charge should arise under section 19 and section 148 ICTA 1988 should apply. It is only when section 148 applies that the particular reliefs available for redundancy payments can be accessed.

There have been a number of further cases on the matter of whether a payment is taxable under the general provisions of Schedule E or as a separate termination payment. It is worth bearing in mind that when a number of these cases were decided, there was no alternative to taxation under general Schedule E provisions.

Until 1961, it was possible to avoid tax altogether if the payment did not fall within the general provisions of Schedule E.

The case of Hunter •Dewhurst 16 TC 605 is authority for the proposition that a payment made genuinely as compensation or consideration for the employee (in this case, a director) foregoing claims that he would otherwise have had – in this case, under the articles of association – is not taxable under the general provisions of Schedule E.

In the case of Shilton •Wilmshurst 64 TC 78, footballer Peter Shilton was asked by Nottingham Forest to transfer to Southampton and received a payment of £75,000 for agreeing to this.

The House of Lords categorised the payment as being made in return for the taxpayer&#39s agreement to act as or become an employee of his new employer, so that it was genuinely taxable as general employment income.

Another significant case was heard in 1993. In Mairs •Haughey STC 569, the employee received a payment to compensate him for the loss of contractual redundancy rights even though employment was continuing.

The House of Lords held that to determine whether a payment was an emolument from employment, it was necessary to identify the nature of the payment in question. A payment made to compensate for the loss of a contingent right to a payment derived its character from the nature of the payment it replaced.

Next week, I will look further at the implications of this case and the Inland Revenue Statement of Practice that was issued shortly afterwards.


M2&#39s target

It is not in my nature to sell myself short. However, I need to clarify that M2 Financial will, in fact, not be looking to purchase “up to a 100 firms…” within the next 12 months as stated in Money Marketing (January 23). M2 is certainly ambitious but operating very much within the realms of […]

TD Waterhouse – Protected Investment Plan

Thursday, 6 February 2003 Type: Capital protected bond Aim: Growth linked to the performance of FTSE 100 index Minimum-maximum investment: £3,000-£1m Term: Five years Guarantee: Capital returned in full regardless of performance in index Return: Up to 75% growth at end of term Closing date: March 18, 2003 Commission: Initial 3% Tel: 0845 6010402

Work to prove our reputation

I was interested to read Derek Forbes&#39 letter in the January 23 edition of Money Marketing in response to my article. The subject is, of course, the fraught question of ethics and I am not sure I would go along with the headline, Ellis is a little too late with a lesson in ethics. Derek […]

Newcastle Building Society – Guaranteed Five Star Bond

Friday, 7 February 2003 Type: Guaranteed equity bond Aim: Growth linked to the performance of Credit Suisse US$ bond, Fidelity Funds European growth, Franklin Templeton mutual beacon, GAM UK diversified, Schroder ISF Japan equity funds Minimum-maximum investment: £1,000-£500,000 Term: Five years Guarantee: Capital returned in full at end of term regardless of performance of funds […]

Who pays inheritance tax and how to declare it

By Kim Jarvis, Canada Life In this article we look at which forms personal representatives (PRs) need to complete and who actually pays inheritance tax (IHT).  To recap, under current rules, any part of the estate that falls within the available nil-rate band (NRB), currently £325,000, is taxed at zero. Anything in excess of the NRB […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm