View more on these topics

MM leader: Unanswered questions on collective DC


After years of wrangling, it looks like pensions minister Steve Webb’s vision for employers to offer ‘defined ambition’ pensions for their staff is finally coming to fruition.

As Money Marketing went to press, the Queen’s Speech was expected to outline plans to allow employees to contribute to Dutch-style collective defined-contribution schemes, where members’ contributions are pooled and the pension is paid from the collective fund.

But, as is often the case with well-meaning pension reform, there are a lot of unanswered questions about how CDC would work in practice.

Webb has described the CDC schemes, as adopted in the Netherlands, as “some of the best pension schemes in the world”. Yet the Dutch don’t seem all that convinced. At the same time as we are moving to a collective model, Dutch political parties are calling for a move to UK-style individual pensions instead.

Experts have also raised concerns about claims made by the Royal Society of Arts last November, which suggested that over the past 57 years a Dutch CDC saver would have seen 33 per cent better returns than their UK counterpart. The experts argue that far from “pooling the risk”, CDCs promise the earth by virtue of the benefits of scale but may not in fact deliver.

There is also the potential threat of market value reductions to contend with, where exit charges akin to those applied on with-profits funds end up penalising savers who leave the scheme early.

This feeds into the biggest issue of all – how CDC squares with the new pension freedoms set out in the Budget. The Government is giving savers carte blanche to spend or save their pot while simultaneously telling them to lock away their investments for the greater good. A lack of joined-up thinking could be CDC’s downfall before it has even got off the ground.

A message from the new editor

So, you may have noticed the leader page is looking a little different this week. Last week we said goodbye to Paul McMillan, who I think we can all agree has led Money Marketing with huge success over the past five-and-a-half years. It has been a privilege to work alongside such a great journalist.

I hope to continue to deliver the high standards Paul has set in terms of editorial integrity. I aim to go out and talk to as many of our readers as possible over the coming weeks to ensure Money Marketing continues to lead the way with breaking news and in-depth analysis about the issues that matter most to advisers.

Follow Natalie on twitter: @Natalie_Holt_MM 



Mark Hoban: ‘One off retirement guidance session is not enough’

Former Treasury financial secretary Mark Hoban says that only providing a one-off guidance session at retirement will not be enough to make sure people get the best value from their savings. The Chancellor announced in March’s Budget that everyone will receive “free, impartial, face-to-face” guidance when they reach retirement from April next year. The commitment […]


D2C providers: Budget guidance guarantee must be delivered online

The Government’s at-retirement guidance guarantee announced in the Budget will inevitably be delivered online to cope with volumes, D2C providers argue. Last month experts told Money Marketing that the Government was concerned about creating a “robust” system to deliver on Chancellor George Osborne’s guarantee of face-to-face guidance for everyone reaching retirement by April 2015. Stockbroker […]


Alan Higham: A blueprint for pensions guidance

The brouhaha over who is allowed to provide the guidance guarantee for people when they retire misses the point. The key question is: what outcome do we want? Policymakers need to appreciate the low level of understanding in this area. We asked private pension savers near retirement age to rate their own knowledge. Just 28 […]

Allianz Technology Trust – April 2017

Welcome to the latest update for Allianz Technology Trust PLC from the Trust’s portfolio manager, Walter Price. Portfolio review The Trust’s NAV returned 4.3% , outperforming the Dow Jones World Technology Index return of 2.8%. In US dollar terms, the portfolio gained 4.8%. During the month, stock selection contributed to relative performance, and industry allocation […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There is one comment at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. Natalie …

    … on your out and about, drop in on Henry, he should be able to tell you whether CDCs is an equitable life!

Leave a comment