View more on these topics

MM leader: Tackling the tough questions on Scottish independence


In just two months’ time, the future of Scotland and the UK could be irrevocably changed. The referendum on Scottish independence is fast approaching but ahead of the vote on 18 September there are some serious unanswered questions on what a Yes vote would actually mean, particularly for financial services.

There are a number of unavoidable challenges when it comes to how Scottish voters assess the costs and benefits of an independent Scotland, not least the fact that the responses change depending on which side of the campaign the answers come from. 

As an example, Money Marketing was given the figures of 85,000 and 185,000 when enquiring about the number of Scots employed in the financial services sector.  

As it turns out, both figures are correct – based on the respective numbers employed either directly or indirectly within financial services.

An independent Scotland that is a member of the EU would have to have its own UK financial regulator and its own central bank, which clearly would create the risk of duplicating costs for providers, advisers and consumers.

There is also a bigger issue affecting advisers that has yet to be picked up on by the wider media: the impact an independent Scotland would have on the UK platform market. 

Obviously, Isas and Sipps are solely products for UK investors. In the event of an independent Scotland, platforms based north of the border with UK investors will fall foul of EU cross-border rules which prevent administrators of these tax wrappers being based in a “foreign” country. Platforms may be forced to register outside an independent Scotland and move tax-sheltered investments across.

Equally, the impact of a No vote needs to be considered. 

Given the momentum building behind the referendum, even a No vote is likely to mean more devolved powers to Scotland.  

Political parties of all stripes have pledged greater powers for Scotland in future, particularly relating to handing Scotland more control over raising taxes.

What is interesting to note in all of this is how the over-riding uncertainty around the referendum is feeding into conversations between advisers and their clients. 

Anecdotally, this is a theme that is consistently coming up – investors are asking how the Scottish referendum will affect them and whether they should take any action to avoid any negative impact on their financial plans. 

Unfortunately, this is a question to which advisers are unable to provide any clear-cut answers.

Natalie Holt is editor of MoneyMarketing. Follow her on Twitter here


David Shelton: TIP OF THE WEEK: Call in the external experts

We have all probably had experience of listening to speakers who failed to cover the topics we were expecting. You do not want this to happen when you invite clients to a seminar. The following checklist should assist your planning: Provide a written brief for the speaker containing all the details, including what you want […]

Newsbrief megadrop

CPD July Briefing: Markets in Financial Instruments Directive II

The latest edition of Newsbrief counts as 1 hour of structured CPD and covers the regulatory and marketplace changes that took place during June 2014. Visit the Money Marketing CPD Centre to answer 10 multiple choice questions and complete this CPD activity. Just click into your CPD Plan and you’ll find each month’s marketplace changes round-up […]


The Platforum on Zurich: Well-powered model fit for fine-tuning

The Zurich platform was soft-launched to a selection of adviser firms in September 2012 before being rolled out to the wider market later that year. This makes it the newest (and potentially one of the last) ‘provider-led’ adviser platforms to launch. As well as servicing advisers, Zurich is also one of the few groups to […]


High street banks face competition probe

The Competition and Markets Authority wants to see an in-depth investigation into competition in the SME banking and current accounts markets following work it carried out with the FCA. The findings represent the first collaboration between the CMA and the financial regulator. The review found “evidence that competition is not effectively serving the interests of […]

Rayner Spencer Mills: Why we rate the Artemis US Select Fund

Ken Rayner and Graham O¹Neill from RSM explain why they rate the fund, its investment process and how it can be used in a portfolio The Artemis US Select Fund became a RSM ‘rated’ fund earlier this year. In this video, Ken Rayner and Graham O’Neill explain the fund’s investment approach, why they rate it, […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm