View more on these topics

MM Leader: Providers’ direct tactics are misjudged

As we move closer to RDR implementation, the FSA is expecting product providers to have a structure in place to deal with orphan clients created by advisers leaving the industry.

However, the aggressive clientmailing strategies used by certain firms begs the question of whether regulatory obedience is being used as an excuse to lower trail commission bills and take a greater share of direct business from IFAs.

Last week, Money Marketing reported on a mail out from Standard Life offering clients the chance to win an iPad 2 by filling out a form confirming their details plus a tickbox if they no longer deal with their adviser. A tick will lead to any trail commission being cut, although not rebated back to the client.

Advisers also raised concerns about client letters sent out by Friends Life earlier this year.

With tough economic conditions likely to continue, trying to turn off a large percentage of trail commission paid to IFAs and increasing your direct proposition may sound like a sensible plan of action. But such moves risk the loss of a considerable amount of goodwill from a sector that provides these firms with a large share of their profits.

The trail commission may have been paid purely as an alternative to a higher up-front charge with no expectation of ongoing service.

The best defence against such tactics is regular contact with clients and ensuring they are happy with the service provided. The FSA’s new RDR remuneration rules mean trail commission will disappear soon after January 2013 for active investment clients anyway, with any new advice paid for through adviser-charging.

If providers want to remain relevant and successful in the distribution area, they should be working with advisers to ensure first-class long-term client outcomes rather than attempting a land grab to achieve some short term gain.

Why this pursuit?

Aifa is right to demand answers over the way the Financial Services Compensation Scheme is conducting its pursuit of Keydata advisers, particularly smaller firms, where such actions are unlikely to be cost-effective. Also, these firms will not have the resources to defend themselves in court. The blanket pursuit also takes no account of individual circumstances or the advice given. The FSCS must explain itself.



FSA appoints ex-banker as Money Advice Service non-exec director

The FSA has appointed former British Bankers’ Association committee chairman John Spence as a non-executive director of the Money Advice Service. Spence, who joins in January, is currently finance chair at not-for-profit organisation Business in the Community and also holds current non-executive directorships at HM Revenue & Customs, Spicer Haart, and Capital for Enterprise. He […]

Fitch puts Matrix-owned funds on review due to firm’s financial resources

Fitch has placed three institutional money market funds managed by Matrix-owned Prime Rate Capital Management on review due to its financial resources. The ratings agency has placed the prime rate euro liquidity fund, prime rate sterling liquidity fund and US dollar liquidity fund that are rated AAA, on negative rating watch. This means the investment […]


Alan Lakey: Claims chaser fight must be taken to Parliament

My last column highlighted the activities of a claim management company and I have heard that other advisers have suffered problems. This is a significant matter. Instigating claims by telling a consumer that the insurer will pay out is a tried and trusted method for these parasites and it may be that little can be […]

Furness BS launches five-year fix through PMS and Sesame

Furness Building Society has launched a 3.85 per cent five-year fixed rate exclusive for PMS and Sesame members. The product, which is available up to 75 per cent loan-to-value and for a £500 fee, includes a free valuation and free legal service for remortgage customers. The maximum loan is £500,000 and borrowers are allowed to […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There are 3 comments at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. So just how many tens (or possibly hundreds) of thousands of clients does the FSA expect to be orphaned after 2012 and what is the FSA’s threshold in terms of an acceptable number of adviser:client relationship casualties?

  2. I don’t blame the big insurers for this approach. They know that IFA’s are not going to recommend their low quality products and administration any more.

    RDR breaks the link whereby these companies could look after advisers financially and there will be no sound reason to recommend them going forward.

    The big danger is that insurers will use these orphan client banks as a carrot to tempt firms that can no longer call themselves independent into doing tied deals to the detriment of the people they advise.

    The FSA’s silly independence definition will mean that many sound independent firms will no longer be able to use the hard won independent tag. If this is lost it will be hugely tempting to do a deal with a big crappy insurer in return for financial support and a client bank.

    Watch them get their cheque books out. It will be hard to say no.

    Many clients will end up in inferior products as a result and the law of unintended consequences will continue to ravage the poorly thought through rules of RDR.

    FSA – why not work with us for the benefit of clients rather than against us for the benefit of the banks?

  3. There is a strong rumour afoot that a recent Panacea Survey has created a regulatory firestorm. The survey claims to be the first “true” IFA consultation over RDR and the results promise to be a significant embarrassment to the FSA. The survey closes today at 5 pm but you can participate in it still at:

Leave a comment


Why register with Money Marketing ?

Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

Money Marketing Events
Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

Research and insight
Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

Have your say
Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

Register now

Having problems?

Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm