View more on these topics

MM leader: FSA must act if Sipp charges are manipulated

With the regulator taking a close look at the capital adequacy levels of Sipp providers, you can understand the recent flurry of speculation regarding consolidation in the sector.

The FSA is understood to be concerned about the financial position of a number of providers, adding to a list of previous worries. Earlier this year, the regulator outlined proposed changes to address a lack of charging transparency, particularly around how much of the cash account’s interest is retained by the Sipp firm.

As Sipps become increasingly popular with investors, the FSA is right to raise more than an eyebrow or two at the current capital adequacy requirements and poor disclosure evident in some sections of the market. With regulatory concerns adding to commercial problems driven by current market volatility, many smaller players are facing significant challenges.

There are well over 100 Sipp providers in the market and it is inevitable that this number will reduce due to the regulatory and commercial pressures being exerted.

A report this week from Defaqto unearths other areas the FSA should be keeping a close eye on. Top of the list are the “pay to play” panel fees levied on discretionary fund managers.

Defaqto is concerned Sipp providers are reducing their AMCs to appear as competitive as possible to the end investor but are increasingly being subsidised by alternative sources of revenue. This could end up hitting the unsuspecting investor who may get a lower AMC but could end up paying for the extra charges that the Sipp levies on the DFM.

There is always the danger that needless regulations end up hitting investors’ pockets without offering them any tangible benefits.

However, if current charging structures are being manipulated by certain providers to try and make their propositions appear cheaper than they really are, the FSA should add this issue to the list of Sipp problems it is looking to address.

Free thinking

The FSA says it is clamping down on misleading financial promotions with a 32 per cent increase in the number of promotions withdrawn following regulatory pressure. Will this tough stance be extended to the Money Advice Service’s recent misleading “free advice” advert? We are not holding our breath.


Aegon appoints new COO

Aegon UK has appointed Tommy Young as its life and pensions business chief operating officer. Young (pictured) replaces Simon Skinner who was appointed Aegon Ireland chief executive on August 8. Young will now join the Aegon leadership team, the insurance executive committee and will lead all aspects of Aegon’s business operations including IT, change and […]


Trade bodies unite to tackle legacy commission issue

Adviser and provider trade bodies are working together to address the FSA’s concerns over legacy commission. Money Marketing understands Aifa, the Association of British Insurers and the Investment Management Association are working on a combined solution to be put to the FSA as part of its legacy commission consultation. The regulator sent a letter to […]

JP Morgan sees growth potential in UK banks

JP Morgan portfolio manager Alex Robins has been adding to UK banks over the past few weeks as market volatility has made valuations attractive. Robins’ £117.7m JP Morgan global financials fund had 51.7 per cent in region-specific banks at the end of July. He says: “We have been adding to UK banks on weakness and […]


Roger Edwards: Help us decide the future for CI cover

Bright Grey and Scottish Provident are holding a critical illness summit meeting in London next month to discuss why CI sales have been falling in recent years and what can be done to ensure more people protect themselves and their families. They are looking for IFAs to attend the meeting, to be held on September […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There are 3 comments at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. It shouldn’t be forgotten that the FSA chose to regulate SIPPs as retail investment products – a mistake in my view. This becomes significant when one starts considering some of the possible regulatory actions suggested in the Defaqto paper – because similar rules would presumably also have to apply to other packaged personal pension products (and GPPs and group SIPPs?). For the FSA to regulate in this area would be like wading through treacle. That said it is right that the FSA continue to push SIPP providers for greater disclosure and transparency and importantly clarity over fees. I think the points that Defaqto make on revenue sharing deals with platforms and subsidies from DFMs are well made. However some of the other areas are much more controversial – for example banning cash rebates would probably destroy several SIPP businesses On fees generally my concern is that there are only a limited number of profitable SIPP providers – and I don’t believe that many are “profiteering” through rebates and the like – although there are exceptions. By all means push for greater clarity and harder disclosure – but don’t throw the baby out with the bath water. There are three quarter of a million SIPP investors and most seem very happy with all the advantages that SIPPs bring.
    John Moret

  2. MoretoSIPPs than meets the eye? Unfortunately I have seen too many cases where the consumer doesn’t know why he/she has a SIPP and had no idea what other options were available when they opened an account, some were told that they had to transfer ALL the pensions into the SIPP, S226 with GAR as well. In a few cases I have seen the trustees refuse to allow UCIS investments, those trustees were often replaced.

    Yes MoretoSIPPs than meets the eye!!!

  3. @Exasperated Me

    You are confusing the suitability of advice with the product selected.

Leave a comment


Why register with Money Marketing ?

Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

Money Marketing Events
Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

Research and insight
Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

Have your say
Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

Register now

Having problems?

Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm