View more on these topics

MM leader: Big firms should not be allowed to circumvent RDR

The FSA deserves praise for the strong statement of intent evident in this week’s Dear CEO letter to insurers, networks and IFAs.

The correspondence expressed concern that deals are taking place between large distributors and providers to try and circumvent the regulator’s adviser charging rules.

The FSA highlights a number of areas- provider payments for training or conferences and to assist in the promotion of products or software development – where it believes the new rules could be compromised with payments being made to effectively secure distribution and influence advice.

The regulator will also be looking to clamp down on long-term distribution deals where significant payments have been made pre-RDR. The FSA may consider a portion of the upfront payment needs to be treated as if made post-RDR, potentially a costly unravelling of exercise for some.

Larger distributors are free to use their buying power to drive down costs for their clients. But they should not be allowed to use their size to broker payments from providers which may influence advice selection.

The FSA’s new charging regime would be doomed to failure from the start if it allowed larger players to continue to benefit from deals which breach the spirit of the rules.

Such payments could end up subsidising the costs of advice and putting smaller firms, and larger firms who did not embark on such deals, at a commercial disadvantage.

There is a big danger that certain arrangements, if left unchecked by the FSA, would allow the provider to retain its position as a possible advice influencer.

Such payments are likely to be more prevalent in restricted advice arrangements. Some firms appear to have forgotten the FSA’s intention of ensuring the same principals of adviser charging and removal of provider influence are seen in both the independent and restricted space.

In an interview with this week’s Money Marketing, Nick Poyntz-Wright, the author of the Dear CEO letter, says it is likely regulatory action will be needed to stamp out bad practice.

Certain distributors may warn this action is a threat to the sustainability of their business models, especially given the current economic backdrop and effect of the raft of regulatory change hitting the sector.

In such situations, their sustainability was already on shaky ground if they were relying on payments that were always going to be against the spirit of the FSA’s remuneration rules.


JLT agrees £17m deal for Alexander Forbes’ employee benefits business

Jardine Lloyd Thompson has bought Alexander Forbes’ employee benefits business, Alexander Forbes Consultants & Actuaries, for £17m. The deal, which is subject to regulatory approval, will see AFCA become part of JLT’s employee benefits division. Alexander Forbes chief executive Edward Kieswetter says: “The disposal brings together complementary organisations committed to ongoing positive and impactful client […]

Tony Wickenden: Tax in the headlines is good news for advice

Over the past few years, tax has been big news. It has had to be– the Government has needed to cut the debt and increasing the “revenue line” through increased taxation and tougher anti-avoidance measures have been two “must do” activities. The newspaper headlines have reported a hit to headline rates (notably the 50 per […]


Just Retirement extends fixed-term annuity break clause

Just Retirement has extended the break clause in its fixed-term annuity product to include changes in economic and personal circumstances. The provider launched its Plan Protection fixed-term product, which allows investors to exit mid-contract if their health deteriorates, in May last year. The terms of the plan have now been extended to include additional life […]

Barclays tops investment complaint

Barclays Bank received the most investment complaints in the first half of the year, FSA figures show. Data published by the regulator last week shows Barclays Bank received 2,730 investment complaints in the six months to the end of June. Over the same period, 37 per cent of investment complaints were upheld by the bank. […]

Japan: mid-year review and outlook

By Chris Taylor, Manager of the Neptune Japan Opportunities Fund H1 2014 Economy: after a harsh winter that slowed activity in the economy, the main event of the first half of the year has been the debate over what impact the 1 April VAT hike from five to eight per cent would have; we are […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There are 3 comments at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. I wonder if they will stop the SJP smoke and mirrors proposition?

    £50k invested – no initial charge to the client – adviser receives 3% initial commission, sorry, initial advice fee & 0.5% trail, sorry again – ongoing advice fee.

    TER of over 2%pa – everyone is happy?

    Sort of makes me think that others will follow (Pru, Std Life, L&G et al) and the RDR has been for nothing except to rid the uk of independent advice?

  2. Could not agree more about the comments made about the SJP proposition flying in the face of the spirit and rules of RDR. In my opinion it makes a farce of the whole RDR. I can’t help but think the whole thing smells of hipocracy and favouritism. Can i hear ‘Business as usual boys’ ringing out from Kent.

  3. The problem is that SJP and many others are businessmen and women and the FSA are bureaucrats and civil servants. They don’t understand business and they will always be chasing the clever businesses who can easily outsmart the letter of their rules.

    I’m still at a loss as to why the banks aren’t doing this. If I were CEO of Lloyds I would have a loss making free financial advice division as a ‘customer service’ on one side of my business and an extraordinarily profitable Scottish Widows on the other side!

Leave a comment


Why register with Money Marketing ?

Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

Money Marketing Events
Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

Research and insight
Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

Have your say
Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

Register now

Having problems?

Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm