View more on these topics

Mispricing row after Arch-cru funds fall by £140m

Cru founder Jon Maguire claims mispricing errors are to blame for the £140m losses on the Arch-cru range.

Earlier this week, Capita published estimates for the net asset values of the underlying cells, which showed a loss of £140m between March 13, 2009, when the range was suspended, and September 30, 2009. Individual funds lost between 20 per cent and 40 per cent over this period.

The £363m fund range was suspended by Capita in March due to liquidity concerns because of the size of redemption requests.

Maguire says he is “staggered” by the losses and believes it “increasingly likely” that Capita mispriced the funds. He says Capita relied on valuations of share prices by independent market-maker Winterfloods, which in turn relied on NAVs calculated by Arch administrators Bordeaux Services and inf-ormation provided by fund manager Arch.

He says: “The finance fund is something we will focus on in particular as it was £50m in November 2008 and was still taking money in February and March, holding around £10m in cash with no redemption history, yet it has managed to fall 33 per cent. They have been completely mispriced and it is the price that creates the performance track record which attracts the IFAs.”

Earlier this week, Capita revealed it will begin the distribution of the suspended CF Arch cru fund assets which will take between three to five years.

A spokeswoman for Capita says: “The fall in the value of the funds reflects a fall in the value of the cells. We are in the process of scrutinising carefully the circumstances of, and reasons for, the fall in the value of the cells. We have asked both Arch and the cells themselves for an explanation of the decline in value.”

Last month, Capita warned its shareholders it could face costs as a result of the suspension of the range. It is setting up a fund to assist investors suffering genuine financial hardship.

The directors of the cells have announced that independent investment company Spear-point has replaced Arch as investment manager of the cells.

An IFA action group has been set up to investigate whether any blame should be laid at the door of the administrators, fund managers or promoters of the funds, with complaints likely to mount now the estimated losses have been established.

Regulatory Legal partner Gareth Fatchett is leading the group. He says it has 50 members representing 75 per cent of assets. He says: “Capita and Arch held the money belonging to the IFAs’ clients and they had a duty of care to handle that money properly. We will be looking to see if they have breached that.”

Skerritt Consultants head of investments Andy Merrick says: “The lesson of the last decade is to steer clear of opaque products that tie your money in. It is easier to get out of a bad marriage than some of these bad structured products.” founder Justin Modray says: “No one has done well out of this debacle but the important thing to note is that the responsibility should rest with the fund manager and the promoter.”


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There are 9 comments at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. As an investor in the Finance fund with all the promises that were made it appears more like fraud than mismanagement

  2. Why have spearpoint been appointed to run the fund down? Does this reflect in some way on Arch’s capability to do the job or on how they have done it so far.

    Also what is the additional cost associated with spearpoint, It has been suggested they are on a 15% bonus contract for the disposal.

    How is this justified!!

  3. In reply to Justin Modray’s comments, my financial advisor did pretty well out of the investments I made.

  4. who is helping investors? has anybody organised a group/blog or anything where investors can get in touch with each other to share any information, because at the minute I feel like the proverbial mushroom, kept in the dark etc.
    it would be good to speak to people in the same situation as me.

  5. why were spearpoint appointed? do they have the resources and experience to manage these assets? well, er, it appears not as they have now taken on the entire Arch management team and are charging more or less the same fees, just under a different name. So Arch now effectively earn a fee for recovering their own losses?

  6. I have set up a page on a blog if anyone wishes to share information.

    We’ll post any updates people can find and work out the best way of proceeding. There must be some way of sorting this mess out that doesn’t leave hard working investors out of pocket, whilst dishonest financial promoters walk away with their bags of cash!

  7. ADRIAN GILLHAM 1st March 2010 at 3:33 pm


  8. Outrage

    Just waived goodbye to my hard earned £7k invested in an ISA in Oct 2008 now valued at £161.00 in March 2010
    This is what Jon Maguire had to say in an interview in the Scotsman (Fund in Focus) in September 2007…. read on with complete dismay!
    Jon Maguire, chief executive of Cru Investment Management, said: “It’s safe enough for your granny to invest in. We’ve certainly managed to achieve the main aim of the fund, which is to return at least 4 per cent above base. This is not something you can definitely do by…

    It’s safe enough for your granny to invest in….. Thanks Maguire, give us our money back!

Leave a comment


Why register with Money Marketing ?

Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

Money Marketing Events
Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

Research and insight
Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

Have your say
Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

Register now

Having problems?

Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm