View more on these topics

Mike Morrison: 7 years on from A-day, whatever happened to simplification?

Seven years on from A-Day, pensions are still anything but simple, says Mike Morrison, head of platform marketing at AJ Bell


6 April 2013 went very quietly in pension terms. Okay, there were the usual rushes with regard to paying contributions before the end of the tax year and using carry forward provisions, plus there was the last time to get 50 per cent tax relief but, all-in-all, nothing drastic.

From next year, however, we have the proposed reductions to both the lifetime allowance (from £1.5m to £1.25m) and the annual allowance (from £50,000 p.a. to £40,000 p.a.).

Far from the heady days of 2006 (seven years ago), I currently feel like I am suffering from a classic case of the ‘seven year itch’. And I am not sure that it is going to go away.

In 2002 we had the memorable announcement that the pensions system was to be simplified, and the magic date for all our diaries was to be 6 April 2006 – A-Day. The aim was laudable – replacement of the multitude of existing pension regimes with one new simple one.

Well, seven years later, has it worked? Is it simpler? How do I put this? Erm – probably not!

Some of the changes have undoubtedly worked, for example the idea of full concurrency (membership of as many schemes as you wish), one set of tax rules and the removal of the requirement to annuitise at age 75 (even though the original alternatively secured pension has long since gone).

The ideas of a lifetime allowance and an annual allowance came as a bit of a shock, but the figures given were high enough not to concern too many people, and the rate of increase for the next few years was also published (although, as an aside, I still fail to see the need for an LTA when you have an AA).

This might have worked and the world could have been a simpler place, but then the tinkering took over. The £1.5m LTA went up to £1.8m, then back to £1.5m, and now £1.25m is proposed.

The original AA of £225,000 p.a. went up to £255,000, then dropped to £50,000 and is now proposed to fall to £40,000.

This is where the real complexity started to raise its ugly head.

Changes to the lifetime and annual allowances since 2006
How pensions allowances have changed since A-Day  
Year Annual allowance
2006/2007 £215,000.00
2007/2008 £225,000.00
2008/2009 £235,000.00
2009/2010 £245,000.00
2010/2011 £255,000.00
2011/2012 £50,000.00
2012/2013 £50,000.00
2013/2014 £50,000.00
2014/2015 £40,000.00
Year Lifetime allowance
2006/2007 £1.5m
2007/2008 £1.6m
2008/2009 £1.65m
2009/2010 £1.75m
2010/2011 £1.8m
2011/2012 £1.8m
2012/2013 £1.5m
2013/2014 £1.25m

To start with, we had primary protection and enhanced protection, then we had fixed protection and shortly we will have a new fixed protection and another one – personalised protection. Each will protect an individual’s pension fund at a certain level, with different maxima and different restrictions.

The big reduction in the AA brought in the concept of ‘anti forestalling’ to prevent high contributions being put in pending the change in rules.

All of this was confusing with DC pensions and personal pensions, but it is even more complicated when applied to DB. Throw in a few BCEs and pension input periods and we are nowhere near simplification.

One part of simplification that perhaps gets forgotten was the idea of one investment regime. We do actually have this, but the original proposal for esoteric investments – such as residential property – never got off the drawing board. Even without it this U-turn caused a few issues for the pension world in that, if you cannot invest directly in the asset, then why not create a fund that can? (Are unregulated collective schemes a direct result of this decision?)

As I write this, people are starting to ask about the new protection regimes, how they will work and what level of fund will be protected. More and more people in DB schemes are finding themselves on the wrong end of a tax charge as their benefit accrual has exceeded the equation applying to such schemes.

An increasing number of people will also find themselves subject to the LTA and barred from pension contributions. Records will become confused with regard to the percentage of an individual’s LTA that has been vested and, indeed, which protection regime applies and whether it applies just to the fund or to the lump sum as well.

The next few years will see ever more of the baby boomer generation reaching retirement, and they deserve a simpler regime. My bet, however, is that my seven year itch will carry on for a few more years yet.

Mike Morrison is head of platform marketing at AJ Bell


Cofunds chairman Charlie Eppinger steps down as L&G completes acquisition

Cofunds chairman Charlie Eppinger has stepped down from the Cofunds board following the completion of Legal and General’s acquisition of the platform. In March, L&G announced it was acquiring the 75 per cent share capital of Cofunds it did not already own for a cash consideration of £131m. The acquisition valued Cofunds at £175m. A […]


Brian Tora: How do you make the most of the current volatility

There is certainly more volatility in markets these days. Japan has been a particularly tricky place for investors recently, with swings of as much as 10 per cent in a single day of trading. While the Japanese market is still leading the field amongst those of the developed world so far this year, performance like […]


Aegon to shut regional sales offices – 160 jobs at risk

Aegon plans to close all of its regional sales offices as part of a major restructure which could result in 160 job losses, Money Marketing can reveal. Aegon held a meeting with its UK staff at 10am today during which it announced plans to close its six regional sales offices in the UK. In addition, the provider […]

Artemis Monthly Distribution Fund: positioning and outlook

Managers James Foster and Jacob de Tusch-Lec outline the fund’s investment approach and discuss current investment themes and outlook for the bond and equity markets. As James and Jacob confirm, the Artemis Monthly Distribution Fund’s aim is to generate an income from both equities and bonds. They explain their investment approach in each asset class, the sectors where they are […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There are 4 comments at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. Good article.

    Couldnt agree more!

  2. Simplification never happened anyway for members of final salary schemes – if you were a member of a final salary scheme this would most likely still operate under the scheme rules but you now have to take into account the over-riding lifetime and annual allowance issues.

    So instead of one regime per member you now have two regimes to be aware of.

  3. the ainol E-commerce Digital brand franchise stores, e-commerce functions designed to use advanced Internet technology, perfect every endeavor to create a global electronic digital online shopping brand!

  4. Nick White, Pensions Law Limited 4th June 2013 at 11:01 am

    There are lots of things wrong with the post-2006 tax regime, but government policy of reducing the LTA while inflating its way out of debt is particularly pernicious. Worsening the tax treatment of funds already accrued is essentially retrospective taxation.

    I still don’t understand the justification for imposing both an LTA and an AA.

Leave a comment


Why register with Money Marketing ?

Providing trusted insight for professional advisers. Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and thought leadership.

News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

Money Marketing Events
Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

Research and insight
Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

Have your say
Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

Register now

Having problems?

Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm