View more on these topics

Michael Both

Stakeholder is almost a kitemarked product which is so simple and straightforward that it sells itself, aided by easy-to-use decision trees which answer almost all the questions any eligible investor might dream up. Dream on, more like.

Because stakeholder does not replace an older product, the complexity facing potential purchasers has increased. Not only must they come to grips with stakeholder but also the alternatives that are available, such as Isas, venture capital trusts, enterprise investment schemes and even “ordinary” stockmarket-based investments using their annual capital gains tax allowances.

Like other pensions, stakeholder offers attractive tax relief on contributions, NIC savings on employer contributions, tax-privileged growth and the possibility of tax-free cash although the benefit of the latter two looks like being reduced over time.

Unlike an American 401(k) plan, access to your own money is impossible until at least age 50 (if the Government doesn&#39t raise it to 55). You must draw your fund by 75 (which could also change – for the better) by buying some form of annuity, which remains something of a lottery given the uncertainty surrounding interest rates and possible euro membership.

Shares from an approved employee share scheme can, within the contribution limits, be put into stakeholder and attract tax relief. But you must make clients aware of the magnification of risk inherent in having their job and pension dependent on the same company. Stakeholder may also accept pension-splitting awards on divorce.

Waiver of premium cannot be added to stakeholder schemes and the allowable life insurance contribution, at 10 per cent of stakeholder premiums, is designed for maximum aggravation. Why not link it to the length of nasal hair and have done?

With the Government&#39s new minimum income guarantee, stakeholder is effectively another sneaky euphemism for 100 per cent income tax because, apparently, the Mig benefit will be lost or gained pound for pound depending on the income produced by the pensioner&#39s stakeholder although, to be fair, any other savings could have the same effect.

The removal of the ability to carry forward unused pension relief is a blow to many people who used spare cash in a well remunerated year to make good the deficiencies in their savings during the previous seven. Because the link between earnings and permitted stakeholder contribution levels is not as direct as with personal pensions and retirement annuity contracts, stakeholder helps to an extent, becoming certificated for five years at a time and always paid net of basic-rate tax. Contributions can continue until 75, even after retirement, initially based on final certificated earnings for five years before dropping to £3,600.

Provided the qualifying requirements are met, £3,600 can be contributed to stakeholder even if also in a “deemed defined-benefit scheme” (basically, any non-defined-contribution scheme) which can have an AVC. Otherwise, concurrency is restricted to members of DC schemes. This could sound the death knell for AVCs and, especially, the much-maligned FSAVC, neither of which allow tax-free cash. Many investors will prefer stakeholder but their enthusiasm may need to be tempered if the AVC is a good subsidised one.

Some industry wags are celebrating the fact that parents could contribute £3,600 a year to stakeholder plans as a tax-efficient way of saving for their children. Gee, thanks dad, that&#39ll come in handy when I want my first Zimmer frame in only 50 years time.

Michael Both is a partner at Michael Phillips


&#39National IFAs first to multi-tie&#39

National IFAs will be first to become multi-tied if the proposed changes to polarisation are implemented, according to Misys IFA Services managing director Patrick Gale. Speaking at the annual conference of Misys network Countrywide last week, Gale predicted that national IFAs will be first to set up multitie salesforces because they are likely to be […]

Consumer credit up 9 per cent

Total consumer credit outstanding increased 9 per cent to £128bn in 2000 from £115bn in 1999, equating to an average debt of £2,810 per adult in the UK, according to research published by Datamonitor.The biggest increase was in credit card debt, which increased 46 per cent to £38bn in 2000 from £26bn in 1999. The […]

Axa&#39s world of opportunities

Daly says: “I do feel that this product will attract a niche market. It will suit clients and advisers who have an income strategy in mind. It does not detract from Axa&#39s multi manager concept, which offers a multi manager portfolio management service outside of Axa&#39s own funds. This makes good use of Axa/Sun Life&#39s […]

Prime time for Royal & Sun Alliance

Royal & Sun Alliance has put the focus on individual stock selection with the introduction of the UK prime fund. This Oeic aims to deliver capital growth by investing in a portfolio of around 30 stocks. Investors who want to draw income from the fund can make cash withdrawals under a facility called selector which […]

Greece: the sideshow continues

Artemis managers James Foster, Mark Page and Laurent Millet comment on the Greek deal, describing it as “just another fudge” getting in the way of bigger developments in China, the UK and the US. To read the full article click here.


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers. Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm