View more on these topics

Martin Tilley: Can Osborne’s Budget diffuse savings time bomb?

With the Christmas festivities firmly behind us, the industry is counting down the days to the Budget in March and the eagerly awaited announcement that may change the shape of retirement planning forever.

It was from the festive period a lesson was learned, which made me wonder just how far ahead the Government will be looking when it announces the outcomes of its “incentives to save” consultation.

The lesson followed a discussion with an extended family member of mine who has recently changed jobs. He is two years out of university, with student debt, a young family, a banger of a vehicle and a rented two-bedroom box. His new job resulted in a pay rise and almost simultaneous offer of entry to his employer’s automatic enrolment scheme, which he opted out of as he could not afford the reduction in takehome pay.

Now, do not get me wrong, I appreciate the position of this generation and am thankful I am not among them. However, he then went on to explain he was off to the sales the following day as he had his eye on a 50-inch television reduced by 50 per cent to a very attractive £600. This was to be put on finance and paid for “when he can afford it”. The deal was too good he did not want to miss out, he said.

Thinking Christmas gatherings are not a good place to lecture on financial planning I said nothing further. But it was a clear example of short-term thinking. For the record, this chap is not stupid – he has a very good degree in computing – but it is clear  as far as financial nous is concerned he is almost as naïve as his nine-month-old daughter.

This is where I think the Government has really missed a trick.  The first message is clear. In terms of incentivising retirement saving, the younger generation look for the short-term gains. This to me should signal the retention of the exempt-exempt-taxed regime and kill dead the notion of a switch away to a taxed-exempt-exempt environment. The promise of something good now is far more attractive than the promise of something so far in the future it will probably be discounted from the thought process.

The second message is also clear. The education system has failed and is failing the younger generations when it comes to being financially aware. Other than curriculum subjects that include some form of business studies (which themselves focus very little on personal finance) there is nothing in secondary or further education to prepare newly qualified adults for the reality of the early years of working life.

The Government’s attempts at education to date have been of limited success. Figures released at the end of last year suggested each Pension Wise interview has cost around £500. Money hardly well spent. I was also at a loss to identify how a large fluffy monster called Workie related in any way to auto-enrolment or the need to understand the importance of retirement planning.

The whole message of the campaign was simply not to ignore the workplace pension. Perhaps a pensioner wrapped in blankets in a darkened room would better bring home the realities of failure to take advantage of the incentives currently available.

The spring Budget is therefore an opportunity to announce a longer-term view; an investment into the future by way of a curriculum-based educational programme. This state-funded initiative would be money better spent on providing a fundamental understanding of personal finance to the next and future generations.

It is an investment into the future, as better educated individuals would be starting from a higher level of knowledge, meaning less time providing education on the basics by advisers, one would hope a corresponding reduction in need of burdensome regulation and fewer people caught out by scammers who play on financial naivety.

It might also be an opportunity for retired advisers to pass on some of their generic knowledge to the students.

This would be a signal of long-term intent; an attempt to diffuse the slowly ticking time bomb that lack of savings and increasing mortality have set running. This would be a step towards sustainability of a savings culture. My fear, however, is that the short-term need to balance the deficit may prevail and, instead of diffusing it, the countdown clock may be wound forward.

Martin Tilley is director of technical services at Dentons Pension Management



FSCS pays out £320k on Ucis advice firm

The Financial Services Compensation Scheme has paid out over £320,000 to clients recommended unregulated investments almost two years after their advice firm was declared in default. To date, the FSCS has paid out £320,036.90 on 11 claims against discretionary and advice firm Quintillion Asset Management. It is currently reviewing a further four claims against the […]


Paul Lewis: The shocking prospect of a return to commission

Incentivisation. Encouraging a particular action by offering a reward. Kidnapping your daughter. That would work. Do what we want and you will get her back. Just ask Will Montgomery (Nicolas Cage in Stolen, 2012). Bribery is slightly safer. Put the contracts my way and there will be something in it for you. It is still […]

FCA interior 620x430

Industry demands answers on Mifid II deadline delay

The industry is calling for confirmation of whether the deadline for implementation of Mifid II will be delayed, as fears grow that smaller firms are falling behind in their preparations. An FCA roundtable on Mifid II, attended by the regulator and various industry trade bodies, highlighted the confusion in the industry over Mifid II deadlines. […]

Brexit Commentary from Natixis Global Asset Management

By David F Lafferty, CFA, SVP – Chief Market Strategist Thursday’s historic Leave vote in the UK will have both immediate and long-term consequences for the global economy and financial markets. The initial flight-to-quality reaction across asset classes has been exacerbated by the market’s misplaced confidence in a Remain victory leading up to the vote. Stock markets […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There is one comment at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. Why do you assume they want people to save. Everything they do is aimed at encouraging people to spend more. Pension ‘freedoms’, selling annuities, encouraging debt. UK household debt is now over 160% of GDP.

    So where do they want people to save? Cash deposits don’t even cover (real) inflation. Those that don’t save are probably well advised to avoid equities to start with. So what’s left? Premium bonds or the National Lottery perhaps?

    We first need to see some real intentions in this direction, instead of just mealy-mouthed sound bites.

Leave a comment


Why register with Money Marketing ?

Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

Money Marketing Events
Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

Research and insight
Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

Have your say
Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

Register now

Having problems?

Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm