View more on these topics

Martin Lewis: ‘Abominable’ MAS deserved stay of execution


Chancellor George Osborne was wrong to axe the Money Advice Service despite it being guilty of an “abominable” waste of advisers’ money, according to Moneysavingexpert founder Martin Lewis.

Lewis, who has been scathing of the MAS in the past and once described the service as “crap” to the Treasury select committee, says recent reforms had given it new direction.

Since the Farnish report was revealed in March last year, MAS chief executive Caroline Rookes had sought to dramatically slash the service’s budget and refocused its offering on debt support.

Lewis says: “What the MAS has done in the past has been awful. It spent years being a brand-building, rent-seeking exercise, duplicating services already in existence.

“For the adviser community there is no doubt there has been an abominable and disgusting waste of their money that has been spent on this.”

However, Lewis maintains the MAS was in the process of being turned around and needed more time before its success could be judged.

He says: “If I were going to scrap the Money Advice Service, the time to do it was three years ago. We have finally got to a position where we know what the MAS should be, and at last it was moving in the right direction.

“I still do not think the MAS moved quickly enough to turn things around, and things like the adverts and sponsored tweets should have been curtailed immediately.

“But we need some of that financial capability support, and this plan was moving the MAS towards that.

“I would have previously said I would not blink if given the chance to get rid of MAS, but if I were in charge now I would give it 18 months because it is finally pointing in the right direction.”

The plans to scrap the MAS come as part of a consultation on a broader redrawing of Government-backed guidance services revealed yesterday.

The Treasury will consult until June on plans to introduce a new, single pension guidance organisation comprised of The Pensions Advisory Service, Pension Wise, and parts of the MAS.

In addition, the Government suggests a new money guidance service designed to study gaps in current provision, commissioning other providers to help fill needs.

A formal response to the consultation will be issued in the autumn, with a new structure hoped to be in place by April 2018.



MAS destruction: The £400m cost of failed quango

George Osborne’s decision to close the Money Advice Service brings to an end a sorry six years during which hundreds of millions of pounds of cash has been wasted on the failed body. The Chancellor revealed in the Budget the MAS will be axed as part of a restructure of financial guidance that will see […]

Money Advice Service

Treasury admits MAS branding ‘misleading’ as service is scrapped

The Government has admitted that the Money Advice Service brand is “misleading” to consumers because it does not offer regulated advice. Under proposals now under consultation, MAS will be closed, with its pension guidance remit going to a new provider, while a second body with a responsibility for money guidance will also be launched. In […]

FCA logo new 3 620x430

FAMR: Mass market advice held back by misunderstanding of RDR rules

Advice firms are reluctant to develop mass market advice models because they are misinterpreting cross-subsidisation rules introduced by the RDR, the Financial Advice Market Review says. The RDR introduced requirements to stop vertically integrated firms using advice as a loss-leader to sell their own products. Its guidance states that the relationship between advice and product […]


MAS urged to ditch ‘unnecessary’ lobbying and focus on cost-cutting

The Money Advice Service is under pressure to ditch “unnecessary” lobbying activity as part of a drive to cut costs and reduce advisers’ levy bills. In its response to MAS’ consultation on its 2016/17 business plan, Apfa attacks the organisation’s proposal to measure its success in meeting its objectives through “demonstration of influence in regulatory, […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There are 9 comments at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. Put your money where your mouth is then Martin !

    If you were given the opportunity to fund it for the next 18 months what would you do ? ……….. run a mile, I wager !

  2. WTF does he know… he ‘s not even authorised..

  3. I’m a little more inclined to agree with Mr Lewis on this. In the same way as VW didn’t scrap the Skoda brand when they took it over, I wonder if thorough root and branch reform with sensible development into a useful body that actually works with the industry rather than going it’s own “sweet” way, wouldn’t be better. After all, HMG has said “new bodys” will be set up…and pesonally I’m not convinced that history tells us that simply scrapping the old and starting again is always the best way to go.

  4. just another chance to get your name in the headlines Martin, I’ll take as much note of this as I do your other proclamations

  5. Isn’t this the chap who told the nation to deposit their money in Northern Rock a few weeks before the bank collapsed, and never once mentioned the compensation scheme limit of £35k?

    • Only client I ever had to defend a complaint over had £450k on deposit before it’s collapse and afetr I had saved her from this, she complained that her investment had gone down less than 5%… you can’t please everybody nor educate pork.

  6. Right decision to axe it

  7. No it didnt Martin !

Leave a comment


Why register with Money Marketing ?

Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

Money Marketing Events
Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

Research and insight
Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

Have your say
Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

Register now

Having problems?

Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm