View more on these topics

Mark Dampier: My concerns about Woodford’s Edinburgh Investment Trust


A little over a week ago it was announced that Neil Woodford is departing Invesco Perpetual after 25 years with the firm.

In my view, Woodford is the finest fund manager of his generation, and his funds are held by thousands of private investors. The implications of the announcement are therefore huge.

The biggest uncertainty currently surrounds Edinburgh Investment Trust, which he and Invesco Perpetual inherited from Fidelity in September 2008.

It is managed along similar lines to his Invesco Perpetual Income and High Income funds, both of which will pass to Mark Barnett, a colleague of Woodford’s for the past 17 years and a successful fund manager in his own right. The future management of Edinburgh Investment Trust, on the other hand, remains uncertain.

Contrary to the beliefs of some, I am not anti-investment trusts. Far from it. I hold them in my own portfolio. I am well aware of their disadvantages though, and they are not as simple as many commentators make out. 

First and foremost they are companies in their own right, listed on the stock market just like Vodafone or Tesco. This means supply and demand, as well as investment performance, will move their share price. With investment trusts it is possible for the share price to rise above the net asset value. This is referred to as a premium. 

Similarly, if the price falls below net asset value, the trust is said to be at a discount to its NAV. A large discount could well indicate a bargain. Many investors would jump at a chance to buy £1 worth of assets for 80p. Conversely, buying £1 of assets for £1.10 should be less attractive. 

Supply and demand for investment trusts can be influenced heavily by news flow. The effect of this was highlighted by Woodford’s resignation, following which Edinburgh Investment Trust’s share price fell 10 per cent. 

The trust had traded on a premium for some time, which is not surprising given Woodford’s strong track record. It highlights the danger of buying on a premium, though. Sooner or later something will happen and the share price will take a hit. 

Furthermore, premiums are often an indication the sector itself is in fashion. As an investor you should really seek the unfashionable, unwanted and unloved funds and sectors to pick up a real bargain. 

Presently, many income-producing assets are in vogue, mainly because interest rates remain at record lows. This has even driven investors towards alternative asset classes. Infrastructure investment trusts in particular are currently trading at large premiums to NAV – far off bargain territory in my view.

As for Edinburgh Investment Trust, it is likely the board will approach Woodford to continue to run the fund. As an independent board, they can do this. My own view is that he is unlikely to accept.

The trust has the aim of growing the dividend in line with inflation, which is more restrictive than he tends to prefer and means there are less growth-focused stocks than in his other funds. In addition, investment trusts involve more meetings and are more time-consuming from the fund manager’s perspective, while Edinburgh Investment Trust has some baggage in the form of expensive debenture debt. 

It will also be intriguing to note what happens with Perpetual Income & Growth Investment Trust and Keystone Investment Trust, both managed by Barnett. He has considerable experience and has done a stellar job on these funds. However, with the additional responsibility of the Invesco Perpetual Income, High Income and UK Equity Pension funds, it is difficult to see how he can retain all his other funds. It should prove fascinating to see what evolves over the next six months.

I hope my comments are construed as constructive.  While investment trusts can be good, they are not necessarily as straightforward as some media commentators make out. 

While there is this uncertainty in the market, I would expect the discount on Edinburgh Investment Trust to widen, potentially producing a bargain buying opportunity in due course.

Mark Dampier is head of research at Hargreaves Lansdown



Feeling safe and being safe are 2 different things

Nic Cicutti writes, and I quote – “The most important is that regulation, while onerous, is there to ensure the consumer feels safe.”  I disagree. Regulation is there to ensure the customer is safe.  There is a difference between being safe and merely feeling safe. The worrying thing is that the regulator does not seem […]


Co-op Bank to cut thousands of jobs in major restructure

The Co-operative Bank is set to cut thousands of jobs and radically shrink in a major restructure under its new ownership. The FT reports the bank will relaunch on Monday and focus on cuts to its corporate lending business which has faced huge losses since the 2009 merger with Britannia Building Society. The Co-op Bank […]


LV= reports dip in life and pensions sales

LV= has reported a 7 per cent fall in life and pension sales for the first nine months of the year but says it is on course to increase profits for 2013.  The provider’s Q3 results show life and pension sales on an APE basis are down from £126m to £117m between January and the end […]

Time to stop the salami slicing on tax relief

Steve Webb  – Director of Policy and External Communications As the Autumn Statement approaches, Steve Webb calls for the Government to stop tinkering with tax relief. Twice a year, in the run-up to the Spring Budget and the Autumn Statement, we face a torrent of speculation as to what changes the Chancellor might make to […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm