View more on these topics

Mark Chilton on Mortgages

Over the past few months, while negotiating the structure of Pure!y with our investors, the word lacuna kept cropping up, meaning a hiatus or gap in the logic of an argument. I think I have found a lacuna in the mortgage market.

Come M-Day, the FSA will place more emphasis than ever on price as an element of best advice. There will be cases where you could justify not using a price-leading lender on grounds of service and some will be able to justify not using the best price where the lender has a reputation for less than straightforward practice, such as erratic treatment of SVRs. But the onus will be on the intermediary to provide the best price for the product.

Now that the FSA has effectively banned panel entry fees and incentives, the whole-of-market model is undoubtedly going to be the winner. This puts even more focus on the diligence that an intermediary can demonstrate in arriving at the best price. Most intermediaries will be forced to use one of the major sourcing engines as the source of best price data but, with advances in underwriting technology, this route may no longer be accurate.

The root of the problem lies in the highly sophisticated credit scores used by an increasing number of lenders. Income multiples are not an accurate filter because these lenders use their own model. A lender with a stated maximum income multiple of 3.75 could lend far higher multiples in certain instances. Yet they may never appear in tables of best buys because you will have filtered them out on the data held within the sourcing systems. To fulfil the best price requirement, the intermediary should carry out full AIPs on a range of lenders, whose models work in this manner.

There is no ready solution. You cannot criticise the lenders, which are producing a more customer-friendly process, or the sourcing engines, which have built their filtration models on relatively solid ground. It is a structural problem in the industry and lack of standardisation of credit scores.

The FSA is seeking to pursue the US model where price is king and brands no longer count. This is the worst possible scenario for the big-brand lenders in the UK. But the lack of a uniform credit score structure for the mass market, that has long been a feature of the US market, makes it apparent that their model is not transferable.

I think I have a solution but if I give it away now I would lose a serious commercial edge. But this structural inefficiency will be another factor leading to the streamlining of distribution channels over the next 18 months.

Mark Chilton is chief executive of Purely Financial


Double talk

John Pardoe makes an impassioned call for advisers to accept that remuneration levels are more than adequate for the time expended, particularly under the new “simplified” sales process – £840 for 36 minutes&#39 work appears excessive but let&#39s look at his double-glazing manager&#39s position again. Based on John&#39s (atypical) £200 a month, the over-generous life […]

Pearl transfer took nearly three months

A Lincolnshire IFA&#39s retired client has had to wait over two months to access a six-figure sum from Pearl which he needs for retirement planning. Riach Independent Financial Advisers proprietor Bob Riach requested a transfer of £257,000 from Pearl&#39s closed with-profits fund to Prudential on May 18 and only received confirmation the fund has been […]

Brown Shipley sets sail in UK

Brown Shipley has introduced the Solus UK Flagship Fund, an Oeic which aims for growth and income by investing in UK companies. The new fund is a replacement for the five smaller Brown Shipley UK funds that were closed last November &#45 income portfolio, growth portfolio, balanced portfolio, UK equity income and UK growth. It […]

Purely Mortgages receives MTA

Purely Mortgages claims to be the first broker in the UK to receive its minded to approve letter from the FSA. Purely Mortgages chief executive officer Mark Chilton says: “As a new company starting up and with &#39M&#39 day looming, it is essential for us to be first off the mark in terms of getting […]

Neptune Global Income: Is Japan the best dividend market in the world?

By George Boyd-Bowman, Fund Manager at Neptune The Neptune Global Income Fund seeks exposure to the very best – and often overlooked – income opportunities from across the world. Unconstrained by benchmarks, the fund currently has 24 per cent invested in Japan, differentiating the high conviction portfolio from many of its peers. Watch Neptune Fund […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm