View more on these topics

Malcolm McLean: Simplify pensions once and for all

Malcolm McLean

For almost the entire 20 years I have worked in pensions people have said the same thing: “Pensions are too complicated. I don’t understand them. They need to be simpler.”

This inevitably leads on to statements like: “I can’t be bothered with paying into a pension. I don’t trust either the pensions industry or the government; they’re out to rip you off. I’ll handle my own money.”

I would like to think that after so many years of us banging on about the problem things would be improving a bit. However, it is probably getting worse.

National Pensions Awareness day came and went back in September, with no apparent impact on people’s understanding of the subject, while the success of auto-enrolment so far seems to depend more on workers’ inertia than any degree of engagement with their pensions.

And it is not just the general pubic. Earlier this year, Bank of England chief economist Andy Haldane said that even he was unable to understand pensions because the system is so complicated. What is more, new pensions minister Richard Harrington pointed out at a recent conference that, prior to taking up his role, he was not sure what he had by way of pension provision and how the various bits all fitted together.

Harrington went on to say that one of his key aims was to make pensions simpler and more easily understandable to the ordinary man and woman in the street.

I wish him well with that but, at the risk of sounding cynical, we have heard it more than once before. And it has not happened. At least not to an extent that would make a material difference.

The problem is we have let the system grow like Topsy, over a long period of time and in a totally uncontrolled way. Take tax as an example. There are hundreds, if not thousands, of pages of tax legislation on pensions that continue to expand at an alarming rate.

And to what end? How many consumers actually fully understand what tax relief is, how it works and how it benefits them in their pension saving? Why is there this apparent obsession on the part of the Treasury with constantly adjusting the allowances with ever more complicated processes for capping and restricting reliefs?

I would like to think that after so many years of us banging on about the problem things would be improving a bit. However, it is probably getting worse.

Coming together

I accept that, to some extent, we are prisoners of our past and simplifying pensions as though we are starting from scratch is not always possible. Bringing in changes often means you have to recognise and give effect to accrued rights that already exist, producing complex transitional arrangements such as those in place for the new “simpler” flat-rate state pension.

But does that mean pensions have to be so convoluted and confusing in all respects? The basic concept of a pensions saving plan is about putting money away during your working life to give yourself an income (or extra income) in your retirement years. It is hardly rocket science. But when you add in the question of tax reliefs and allowances, contribution rates, target date funds, salary sacrifice, default options, lifestyling plans and so on, it probably starts to sound to the consumer a bit like it could be.

Why can’t the industry and the Government work together to find ways of radically simplifying the whole pension system for the benefit of everybody involved? We need simpler legislation, simpler scheme rules and simpler insurance products. But above all we need a desire to think and act in the best interests of the consumer at all times.

Alternatively, this could be given as a discrete task to a new Pension Commission, which could objectively examine the case for more simplification and make practical recommendations as to how it might be achieved.

And while we are at it, let’s have a once-and-for-all purge on the gobbledegook language used. Expressions like “trivial commutation” and “uncrystallised fund pension lump sums” have to be consigned to the dustbin if we are ever going retain any credibility going forward.

Malcolm McLean is senior consultant at Barnett Waddingham


John Moret blog

John Moret: My blueprint for pension tax simplification

One of my New Year’s resolutions was to restart a lobby for pensions tax simplification. I saw the open letter from AJ Bell chief executive Andy Bell to the Treasury financial secretary making seven suggestions on simplifying pension tax rules. Andy always makes very sensible proposals but on this occasion I don’t believe he’s gone […]

Tax year-end planning with the family

From the Technical team at Prudential Let’s face it, many aspects of financial planning involve a lot of technical detail. At our face-to-face events, we’ve had great success bringing these technical topics to life through the use of practical case studies. Meet the family Prudential’s Planning Matters hub brings together a fictional family and explores […]

A tough start for 2017 consensus trades

By Kacper Brzezniak Every year, starting around November, investment banks (and fund managers) begin to drip out their outlooks for currencies, rates, economies, you name it, for the following year. The consensus has been largely wrong for the past four or five years; those multiple rate hikes never came, the bond market is still alive […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There are 2 comments at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. An excellent common sense article. Will it happen? I very much doubt it. Even if it did, would the general public then engage with pensions? Again, I doubt it. They perceive that there are far “sexier” things to spend their hard earned on. And these will be the same people who reach retirement and blame everyone else but themselves for not having enough money to live on.

  2. Someone who can read 16th December 2016 at 4:21 pm

    “And it is not just the general pubic” stopped reading.

Leave a comment


Why register with Money Marketing ?

Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

Money Marketing Events
Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

Research and insight
Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

Have your say
Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

Register now

Having problems?

Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm