View more on these topics

Malcolm McLean: Pensions under Scottish independence


Although I have a Scottish name and can claim a longstanding Scottish ancestry, as I live in England I do not have a right to vote in the independence referendum to be held in Scotland on 18 September.

If I did have such a right, while not ruling it out, I would almost certainly want a lot more information about the implications of a ‘yes’ vote than currently appears to be available.

When it comes to pensions, both sides of the argument are unclear about what independence means for the retirement prospects of millions of people both in the short term and in the decades to come.

In relation to the state pension, I rather like the idea (assuming it is affordable) of Scotland having a higher single-tier pension of at least £160 a week in 2016, providing more of a buffer with means-tested benefits than the £155 envisaged for the rest of the UK. Commitments to the triple lock for the single-tier pension and possibly freezing later state pension age rises are also welcome.

But other, more basic, questions such as how and where National Insurance contributions will be collated and accounted for in an independent Scotland and who will actually pay the state pension have not been answered.

If existing pensioners are to continue to receive their pensions from the UK side of the operations and Scotland does not secure access to the EU, will annual increases still be paid or will they be treated as being in a foreign country – as with Canada and Australia – and have their pensions frozen? 

For private pensions, there needs to be an agreement between the Scottish and UK governments as to the exact share of pension liabilities to be taken on by the Scottish government, which has repeatedly said no accrued pension rights will be lost. This means there has to be Scottish versions of the Pensions Protection Fund, The Pensions Regulator and, presumably, Nest.

How that will work and what problems it may yet throw up are unclear.

Cross-border pension schemes

The potential problem of cross-border pension schemes cannot be ignored. 

Schemes with members in Scotland could become ‘cross-border’ and under EU law would need to be fully funded at all times, leading to the possible closure of more defined benefit schemes. How will this  be addressed?

While accepting that not every operational and legacy issue can be resolved in advance of the referendum there are a number of areas of uncertainty in the pensions arena, which should have been bottomed out more fully by now.  

The Scottish people will have to decide whether to vote with their hearts or their heads on 18 September. Whichever way they go let us hope they are proved right both in their own interests and for that of the rest of the UK as well.

Malcolm McLean is senior consultant Barnett Waddingham 



Carl Lamb: Advisers are in denial over trail switch-off

In the ever-changing world of the financial adviser, new challenges face us every day – to our workload, manpower and income streams. Darwin was right when he said only the fittest of us would survive.  Probably the greatest challenge on the horizon is the removal of many trail commission payments to IFAs. Advisers have until […]


Bank of England warned over inflation risk

Former Monetary Policy Committee member Andrew Sentance has warned the Bank of England over potential inflation risks, despite the current rate standing just below its 2 per cent target. Writing in the Telegraph, Sentance says economic conditions now are similar to those which led to a period in the 1980s when inflation rose to 10 […]


Govt steps up enforcement actions against CMCs

The Ministry of Justice has reported a sharp increase in the number of enforcement actions it has taken in the second quarter of the year, as it seeks to clamp down on claims management companies. A total of 25 investigations were started between April and June, compared with 35 in the entire year to March […]


Standard Life increases Sipp drawdown charges

Standard Life has made a series of price tweaks to its Sipp wrapper including raising drawdown charges for investors holding off-platform assets such as property and listed securities. The changes, which apply from 1 November, will see ‘pension fund withdrawal’ charges for portfolios containing non-custody assets increase alongside a series of other charges including in-specie […]

Healthcare regulation amalgamation predicted for Gulf states

While Dubai is leading the way in terms of legislating for expat healthcare in the Gulf, Qatar, Abu Dhabi and others are watching and learning – that’s according to Jelf International’s director of international services, Doug Rice. He believes the pace of change in the Gulf states will continue and that some level of unified healthcare system will be introduced across the region.


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm