View more on these topics

Malcolm McLean: Govt must review financial services quangos


Predicting what may or may not be in a Chancellor’s Budget is never straightforward. I suspect most of us over the years have more often than not found our predictions to be completely wide of the mark.

I hope I am wrong but looking forward to George Osborne’s forthcoming statement on 8 July I cannot envisage much good news, if any, in it for pensions.

Traditionally, a new government’s first Budget is the time to get the bad stuff out in the open, leaving themselves the four years up to the next election to feed in more crowd pleasing measures and sweeteners.

On this occasion, George Osborne has a particularly difficult task. He is committed to somehow finding an extra £8bn a year for our ailing NHS at the same time as he needs to produce even more substantial funding for major capital projects: the replacement of Trident, high speed rail links, a third London airport and so on.

There is also the promise to stay on track to eliminate the deficit by 2018, for which Osborne is looking to squeeze some £10bn of savings out of Whitehall, requiring, it seems, a further 100,000 job losses across the civil service over the next five years. Some very tough times lie ahead for many departmental budgets.

We can expect pension tax reliefs and allowances to once again come in for close scrutiny, with the scrapping of higher rate tax relief and its replacement by a single standard rate for all of no more than, say, 23 per cent a distinct possibility. The abolition of the tax-free lump sum could also now be more easily justified in the wake of the new pension freedoms and the greater accessibility to cash generally.

State pension ages may be pushed back even further and more rapidly as we move to a new retirement age of perhaps 70 in the space of the next 10 years. Public sector pensions – especially the LGPS – could be subject to further funding restrictions and/or cutbacks as the Government looks to make substantial savings from economies of scale.

Beyond all that, further savings may be forthcoming from a coming together of the tax and National Insurance administrations or even from a merger of the various non-departmental public bodies (or, as more commonly known, quangos). The FCA and The Pensions Regulator, the Financial Ombudsman Service and the Pensions Ombudsman, the Pension Protection Fund and the Financial Services Compensation Service, and the Money Advice Service and The Pensions Advisory Service are all arguably at least in the frame for that purpose.

If, for example, the two regulators were to become one there would be a single board of governors, one chairman, one chief executive and doubtless many more economies of scale lower down. I think many in the industry would actually welcome such a merger making it more transparent about who does what, how and when.

From a public perspective as well, having two organisations apparently operating in the same space can be very confusing. For example, having two ombudsmen (three if you include the Parliamentary Ombudsman) probably does not make a lot of sense to the ordinary scheme member looking for someone to investigate their complaint and grant them redress.

Finally, in relation to the provision of government-backed guidance the same arguments apply. There have already been calls for TPAS to be subsumed within MAS and, provided the former’s status and known expertise was not lost in the process, this is at least a possibility that could be explored. Bringing Citizens Advice into a new merged operation may be more difficult as it is not technically a quango and legally, therefore, may not be achievable.

At this stage, however, anything is possible. The pensions industry, like everyone else, will await Osborne’s Budget with great interest and more than a little trepidation.

Malcolm McLean is senior consultant at Barnett Waddingham                                          



Iress to move Trigold users to Xplan system

Iress is replacing its Trigold Prospector mortgage sourcing system with a new Xplan Mortgage system, Money Marketing can reveal. Australian technology provider Iress bought Trigold as part of its acquisition of Avelo in 2013. An internal document seen by Money Marketing reveals Iress plans to roll out Xplan Mortgage “over the next few months to […]

What does the future hold for the oil market?

The Organisation of the Petroleum Exporting Countries has again held oil production levels at 30 million barrels per day in an attempt to get more market share. The decision was expected by many, but various questions remain unanswered. Is there a risk of a further oil price drop because of oversupply? And is the current […]


Lloyds chief tells bankers to accept oncoming regulation

Antonio Horta-Osorio, the chief executive of Lloyds Banking Group, has called on banks to stop complaining about upcoming regulation on ringfencing of their business. Horta-Osorio says banks need to accept their retail banking and investment banking arms must be separate, as recommended by the Vickers Commission, reports the Guardian. The move stops retail banking money […]


Man jailed for role in £4.3m Ucis fraud

A man has been sentenced to prison for his role in an unauthorised collective investment scheme through three land banking companies. Adam Hawkins was sentenced to six years and nine months in jail at Southwark Crown Court today following the FCA’s Operation Cotton investigation into the scheme in which 110 investors lost £4.3m. Hawkins worked […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There is one comment at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. Julian Stevens 22nd June 2015 at 3:31 pm

    A bonfire of the quangos has been talked about for years but has yet to happen and, as far as those funded from the private sector are concerned, never will. There’s no money to be saved by the public purse and thus no incentive for the government to reform any of them ~ quite the opposite in fact, as consolidation, reform and the slimming down of privately funded quangos would, economically, mean private sector job losses at the very time that the government is keen to boost private sector employment.

Leave a comment