View more on these topics

Malcolm McLean: FCA final report will not be the last word on pension freedoms

Proposals in the Retirement Outcomes Review aim to solve ongoing concerns around consumer detriment

Three years on from the start of pension freedoms, there are still concerns being raised about the workings of the system and what the implications might be for consumers over the longer term. But are these concerns really justified?

Whether you are for or against the freedoms, you have to admit they have proved very popular with the public. On that basis, they are probably here to stay. There are also many in the pensions industry that regularly espouse their virtues. How often have you heard it said that it is the person’s own money and they should be free to spend it as they see fit, not forced to buy a poor value annuity?

That claim is not true in every instance, of course. In a workplace pension arrangement, it is not just the individual’s own money that goes into their pot. Both the employer and the government will have contributed – the former through mandatory minimum contributions and the latter through tax relief. In both cases, this is not simply out of the goodness of their hearts.

Target practice: FCA takes aim at freedoms failures

Although it may not be happening on any large scale, I often wonder how employers feel about seeing the money they have put into their employees’ pension plans over many years used to fund luxury items, world cruises and the like.

And even accepting the argument that annuities do often represent poor value for a lifetime of saving, how is that relevant to a defined benefit pension many members are now giving up on and risking their futures by transferring out to a much less secure defined contribution plan? The lure of cash is clearly a major influencing factor here.

There is no doubt pension freedoms have changed the whole concept of a pension plan, to something more akin to a long-term savings plan with a pot of cash at the end of the track.

Regulatory proposals

The recent FCA Retirement Outcomes Review final report suggests there is more than a little uncertainty as to how well the freedoms are working in practice, and without some further reforms things could still go badly awry.

The main proposal forcing all providers to establish default investment pathways for drawdown seems to imply a return to the concept that, for most people, the end product of a pension plan should be an income stream of some description, not the wholesale withdrawal of a pot of money.

Malcolm McLean: Nothing will fix lifetime allowance issue better than scrapping it

The other significant proposal to send out much simpler wake-up packs from the age of 50 has a similar ring about it. The evidence clearly shows many new retirees are unprepared to deal with the choices they have to make in relation to their pensions and are largely unaware of the risks they are facing.

There are a number of other proposals directed at providing greater safeguards and improving understanding and experience of the freedoms – although rather surprisingly the FCA has stopped short of introducing a charge cap for drawdown investment pathways, suggesting instead that providers use 0.75 per cent on default arrangements in accumulation as a point of reference.

The whole pension concept has changed to being a long-term savings plan with a pot of cash at the end of the track

So, will the FCA’s final report really be the last word on changes to pension freedoms? I doubt it very much. There is much more to say and do about DB to DC transfers, which have been proliferating at an alarming rate.

There is also the risk that, in the years to come, we shall find many older pensioners will have run out of money. Or the reverse may be true and some will have restricted their spending too conservatively.

With this in mind, I would not be surprised to see a lot more tinkering with the rules in the years ahead.

Pension freedom was, and always will be, a controversial policy, with many pros and cons that will only become fully apparent over time.

Malcolm McLean is senior consultant at Barnett Waddingham



Which financial services names have made the Rich List?

Peter Hargreaves has jumped to 42nd position on the Sunday Times Rich List, a climb of nine places from last year, after seeing his wealth grow £849m to £3.2bn. Hargreaves is no longer on the Hargreaves Lansdown board but has kept a 32.2 per cent stake in the company – the value of which has […]

Pension scam ruling puts focus back on scheme duties

A ruling from The Pensions Ombudsman has turned the focus back on schemes and employers over what responsibilities they should bear when savers are scammed. While TPO rulings cannot set precendent, and are decided based on what is fair and reasonable by the particular adjudicator, a judgment in a case involving a police officer who […]

International jurisdictions

By Neil Jones, Canada Life Investing through international providers has grown in popularity over recent years as investors seek out the benefits of gross roll-up and the wider range of investment options that can be available. When considering a recommendation for a lump sum investment, not only does the adviser have to select a suitable tax wrapper […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers. Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and thought leadership.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm