View more on these topics

Malcolm Kerr: Why banks will never be trusted advisers

Malcolm_Kerr_EYBanks are heading back into the world of advice but a culture clash means IFAs should not feel threatened

It is interesting to see how many banks, asset managers and discretionary fund managers are moving into the advice space. Some for the first time. Others, with hope winning over experience, for the second or even third time. It is not hard to understand why.

First, pension freedoms. These have created a new trillion-pound market where advice is an essential component of the proposition for affluent and high-net-worth consumers. I think some of the new players will get this right and, over time, create powerful competitors to owner-managed advice firms.

Secondly – and specifically for the majority of DFMs and asset managers – propositions are under threat from the exponential rise in index-linked funds. They stand very little chance of making money from these price-sensitive vehicles.

Malcolm Kerr: Do the risks outweigh the benefits for the modern adviser?

Vanguard and Blackrock have roughly a 75 per cent market share between them and an oligopoly, or even a monopoly, seems inevitable. Hence the need to move into new areas of the value chain.

Of course, some of the organisations now intending to offer their services directly to clients will be biting the hands that feed them. Without doubt, they will have considered the consequences of this. But, equally, they will be aware that most advisers currently using their services have been reviewing performance through an increasingly short-term lens and they need access via other channels to protect their revenues.

Brewin Dolphin seems to be leading the advice charge at the moment, but many others are pursuing similar strategies: Schroders, Seven IM, LGT Vestra and Rathbones, to name just a few.

Different worlds
Running money and providing advice are very different. The former is an industry; the latter a profession. But there is something perhaps even more important: running money is not usually a client-facing role. It is primarily analytical, and so are most of the people looking at the screens.

Of course, advisers have to be analytic, but they also need other competences such as empathy and ability to gain trust and build strong relationships. To become the trusted adviser.

Which reminds me of a small piece of work I did for a large high street bank attempting to reinvigorate its wealth management proposition ahead of the RDR.

Paul Lewis: Banks must step up efforts on scam prevention

The brief boiled down to “we want to be trusted advisers”.

As usual when doing this sort of work, the first step was defining the people, processes and the technology required for the desired end state, then creating a high-level business case. The problem in this case was the culture, in particular the management.

They seemed to think that if they positioned themselves as trusted advisers, they would somehow become trusted advisers. So we ran a session to try to demonstrate what such a person might look like.

I knew many people I would describe as trusted advisers but had no difficulty deciding exactly who to approach: Prescient Financial Intelligence managing director Chris Woodhams. It was an interesting morning.

Culture clash
Chris kicked off with a description of his business and took us through the numbers. Then he set about trying to explain its culture. I noticed my client was looking puzzled and so did Chris. So he changed tack.

“Perhaps there is a better way to explain how we do things,” he said. “A couple of weeks ago, I had a first meeting with a new client. He was just about to retire, having been a senior executive in a FTSE 100 company after working himself up the ladder over 40 years. What do you think was on his mind? What do you think we spent most of our time discussing?”

Malcolm Kerr: Advisers must act earlier on sequencing risk

It took a few minutes before anyone ventured a guess. “He was worried that his income wouldn’t be sufficient?” That was not his problem, Chris said. He had a final salary pension scheme which would be more than adequate.

“Was he worried about inheritance tax?” A bit but not really, Chris responded. “Did he want advice on his other investments?” Eventually, yes. He had a portfolio but that was not what was on his mind.

After a couple more questions, the client team sat back looking even more puzzled. Chris smiled and said: “The thing that most worried him was being retired. He had never been retired before. He had no idea what he was going to do being underneath his wife’s feet all day.” Chris continued: “We had a good chat. I knew many clients that have retired and we talked about what some of them have done. For example, using tax-free cash to build a home office. Maybe doing some charity work.”

“Yes. But what was the outcome?” asked the client. Chris replied: “He said he would like to meet up again and I agreed it would make sense. He is now a very valuable client.”

My client frowned. “Sorry, but I don’t think that kind of thing would work well for us.” Chris smiled and said: “You are probably right. After all, you are a bank.”

Malcolm Kerr is an independent consultant


Alistair Cunningham

Alistair Cunningham: Chartered status has been cheapened

I was one of the first to be granted chartered financial planner status, but I wonder what the future is for the accolade. The Personal Finance Society does not seem overly concerned about erosion of the title, seemingly allowing its abuse with impunity. There have been high-profile incidents of more than one chartered financial planner […]

Pension transfers see £8.6bn cashed out in Q3

The total value of pension transfers rose slightly from £8.2bn in the second quarter of the year to £8.6bn in the third quarter, the latest figures from the Office for National Statistics show. This is down from a high of £10.6bn in the first quarter, however, with experts predicting long-term decline as advisers exit the […]

‘Flawed’ FCA compensation scheme for Lloyds customers criticised

An official complaint has been filed to the FCA over the compensation scheme it set up with Lloyds over past fraud. The redress package is “defective” and the methodology “flawed, according to the SME Alliance. The pressure group represents small businesses, scores of which were affected when they suffered fraud at the hands of a […]

Welcome to The Brunner Investment Trust PLC

Welcome to the latest update for The Brunner Investment Trust PLC from the trust’s portfolio manager Lucy Macdonald. Market Review Global equities ratcheted higher throughout February, buoyed by optimism about global growth and corporate earnings. All regions advanced, although Japan tended to lag many other markets. In sector terms, healthcare, information technology, consumer staples and […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There are 4 comments at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. Think you mean index-tracking funds?

  2. IMO, part of the issue is that if the IFA proposition is based on repeated contact over the long term at £150+ per hour, then is it going to be appropriate to everyone.

    Many customers have limited assets with no complicated inheritance issues.

    The customers who need an IFA and those needing the services provided by Banks are two distinct groups.

  3. One thing’s for sure ~ this time round, the banks will have to operate a dramatically different business model from their traditional one of flog, forget and move on to the next target. Having to do so will mean a massive change to their overheads. Running an ongoing advice business is about as different as it’s possible to imagine from the target-driven model of flogging boatloads of product. One wonders if the banks have yet realised this and what they’ll do when they finally have done.

  4. I think MIFID ll will put some banks off. Then of course banks are one of the most complained about entities in the financial space. For those unfortunate to have invested in their shares, that also will put them off entrusting their money to these people. (YTD – Lloyds MINUS 23.8%. Barclays MINUS 25.9% RBS Minus 22.1%)
    Others have already remarked on target driven sales – a definite no no in today’s world. But what of the advisers? What qualifications? Anyone who is any good (apoart from at the highest level in banks) would probably be working for an adviser or wealth manager. All in all banks will have a mountain to climb, not only in achieving client trust (without arm twisting) but also making the whole proposition worth the candle.

Leave a comment


Why register with Money Marketing ?

Providing trusted insight for professional advisers. Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and thought leadership.

News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

Money Marketing Events
Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

Research and insight
Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

Have your say
Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

Register now

Having problems?

Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm