View more on these topics

Make hay while the sun shines

James Hay has introduced Flexi-Sipp, a self-invested personal pension

which can be linked to funds from Aberdeen Asset Managers, Williams de Broe

and Prudential-Bache.

The panel agree that the product fits well into the market. Shaw says:

“These plans have become popular since drawdown became available and it

fits in well.”

Flowers says: “Given the way pensions are being driven by the Government

at the moment, this plan is very well designed to pick up on the profitable

end of the market.”

Briggs says: “Sipp providers are quite numerous but James Hay has an

enviable reputation for service and, in my opinion, is a joy to deal with.

It has teamed up with three respected investment managers to provide a

bespoke service ideal for bigger drawdown cases.”

Humble says: “It fits in extremely well, bearing in mind that most clients

do not require the full Sipp options.”

Turning to the type of client for whom the plan is suitable, Shaw says:

“This could appeal to the more sophisticated investor as it is somewhat

more comprehensive than the insurance company hybrid. It would suit the

case where more flexibility of investment was required on a personal

pension transfer bond, which could be transferred to the Sipp.”

Briggs says: “This is for more sophisticated clients with big pension

funds who are seeking a personalised investment service.”

Humble says: “This is for anyone with funds of £100,000-plus who wants the

benefits of income drawdown but is not interested in the full range of Sipp

investment options.”

Flowers says: “The whole thrust of the plan is designed for those nearing

retirement with substantial pension funds to manage and with an awareness

of the need for asset allocation and risk assessment within their pension


The panel are lukewarm on the types of marketing opportunities provided by

the plan. Humble says: “It gives no new marketing opportunities but it does

provide an interesting alternative to plans already on the market.”

Flowers comments that it is easy to present this as a pension planning

solution to sophisticated clients.

Briggs says: “This would appeal to professional contacts like solicitors

and accountants who deal with high net-worth clients.”

Shaw says: “As a suburban IFA, I doubt whether I would get much call for

such a product. However I would expect that bigger IFAs, say, in central

London, may well find potential clients for this product.”

Turning to the strong points of the plan, Briggs says: “The main useful

features include flexibility, the bespoke investment service, competitive

charges for bigger cases and the portfolio valuation service.”

Humble says: “Two strong points are, first, the appointment of an

investment manager who will carry out rev iews taking into account the

cashflow requirements of the plan and, second, the ability to spread

investments of more than £250,000.”

Flowers says: “Strong points are the transparent charges and one contract

that can encompass, in a designed way, all the main pension planning


When it comes to the drawbacks of the product, the panel offer different

viewpoints. Shaw says: “I cannot see any defects in the plan, apart from

the fact that the contributions will be capped to an earnings&#39 ceiling of

£90,600 in 1999/2000 and £91,800 in 2000/01.”

But Briggs says: “The concept of the product flies in the face of the

rationale for using a Sipp, as investment choices are perhaps restricted by

virtue of the limited choice of investment managers.”

Humble says: “One drawback is that the investment managers will only

review assets held by them. They will not take into account other

investments held within the plan.”

Flowers says: “James Hay insists on using its own deposit accounts and

will only pay out pensions on the last day of the month. The option of only

three investment managers is restrictive.”

Commenting on the range of investment options available, Flowers says:

“James Hay is pushing strongly for pension planholders to invest with its

three fund manager links. It is a clever arrangement but investors at this

level want easier access to more options.”

Shaw says: “The investment range is very good. All the investment managers

are of high standing. Apart from equity-based investment, there is the

possibility of purchasing commercial property, which may or may not be used

for the client&#39s own business.”

Looking at James Hay&#39s reputation, Briggs says: “I use James Hay regularly

for my Sipp business and hold the company in high regard. The service I

receive is exemplary.”

Shaw says James Hay is a leading firm of pension fund trustees with a

respected position in the pension administration field.

Flowers says: “Its reputation is excellent, although not without the

occasional administrative banana skin. But can it keep it up as it grows?”

The panel agree the charges are fair. Shaw says: “The charges are quite

reasonable for a sophisticated scheme, with a set-up fee of £250. Annual

charges are also very much in line with the market.”

Humble says: “The charges are fair and reasonable, provided that the

client is happy with one or more of the three investment managers.”

Briggs says: “The charges look good, especially for bigger cases. The

set-up fee of £250 is the same as a standard Sipp.”

But the panel are less impressed by the commission. Humble says: “Three

per cent plus 0.5 per cent renewal commission as a maximum is quite

sufficient but, in practice, lower commission is likely to be taken for

bigger cases.”

Shaw says: “The commission is average although IFAs may be working on a

fee basis for clients in this field.”

This is echoed by Briggs, who says: “I suspect most IFAs operating in this

market will be charging fees.”

Turning to the product literature, Humble says: “The literature is

informative and easy to read. I was not impressed by the CD-Rom. It did not

tell me much and I wonder if it was worth the expense of production.”

Shaw says: “The literature is excellent,with everything explained in great


Briggs says: “It looks classy – what the high-net-worth client would expect. The application forms should reflect the same design, however.”

Flowers says: “The literature is generally good, well written and easy to

understand. The CD-Rom brought up a nice picture but nothing else.”

Summing up, Shaw says: “This product looks good but the proof of the

pudding will be in the eating.”

Humble says: “The plan recognises that, once benefits have begun under

income drawdown, the plan effectively ceases to be a pension contract and

becomes an investment contract. The principle is very sound but I am not

sure about the choice of investment managers.”

Broker Panel

Mike Humble l Divisional director, Lambert Fenchurch Financial Services,

Colin Shaw l Director, Woodfield Financial Services,

David Flowers l Director, RBC,

Robert Briggs l Principal, Robert Briggs


Housing market cools off, says Halifax

The rate of house price growth is slowing across the UK, according to the Halifax House Price Index for the first quarter of the year.Halifax says the UK housing market remains buoyant with prices rising by 3.2 per cent in the first quarter, though this is down from 3.6 per cent in the final quarter […]

Flying the standard

Few in the industry will not benefit from Skandia&#39s decision to become afull Origo sponsor, putting its money where its mouth is when it comes tosupporting e-commerce in the IFA community.Probably the only losers will be the small group of life offices whichcontinue to fail to contribute their fair share of the costs of Origo&#39swork […]

Brokers show loan optimism

More than half of brokers are optimistic the mortgage market will improvein the next quarter, according to research by the Mortgage Business.Currently, 54 per cent of brokers are optimistic that business willimprove in the next quarter.Brokers have reported significant increases this quarter in sales ofself-employed and flexible mortgages, with 38 per cent having seen anupturn […]

Giving advice on retirement advice is not plain sailing

You were kind enough to publish a comment that I made concerning Sofa andchartered status some time ago, particularly with reference to what isperceived as professionalism in our industry.I was interested to see the retirement income case study for your awardscompetition run in association with Sofa and I think this illustrates thepoint I was trying […]

Finding security in bond markets

Martin Foden, head of credit research at Royal London Asset Management, explores the role of secured bonds, considering the impact of default and the characteristics of secured bonds versus supranationals and highlighting some examples. He also examines the evolution of the credit market and rating agency inefficiencies. Read the article in full: The value of […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm