View more on these topics

List opportunities

Investors choosing funds without advice are always taking a bigger risk than necessary, especially as the marketing literature of providers often leaves a lot to be desired. So Hargreaves Lansdown has published a list of the 150 funds it believes investors should consider at the exclusion of the other 1,650 funds in the market.

Some of the boutiques have given their deep-pocketed rivals a bloody nose. Artemis, for instance, has seven funds on the list, one more than the mighty Fidelity and several more than groups the size of M&G and Threadneedle.

In fact, both of the latter have just two funds present despite M&G&#39s stable of around 40 funds and Threadneedle&#39s position as the UK&#39s second-biggest fund manager.

To put this further in perspective, Aberdeen Asset Management, which sold the bulk of its quality retail funds to New Star earlier this year, has the same number.

M&G and Threadneedle are fairly sanguine about their minor presence on the list, however, with M&G particularly happy to have an equity fund – its recovery portfolio – sitting alongside the more predictable high-yield corporate bond fund. Managing director Phil Wagstaff says: “Am I disappointed? Well, my challenge is to persuade people of our equity case and I am delighted to see the recovery fund there. We probably do not deserve to have many more on the list at the moment but give it time and I think we will get a few more on there.”

Wagstaff is disappointed, however, about the omission of M&G&#39s flagship corporate bond fund, which has performed well under the stewardship of Anna Griffin. But as Richard Woolnough, Old Mutual&#39s former star manager, is taking over the fund next year, Wagstaff says he understands why HL may not be keen to recommend a fund in flux.

Nevertheless, HL is keen to keep a close eye on its performance and expects it to make an appearance in the near future, possibly alongside Woolnough&#39s other fund – the strategic bond fund – which is launching in the first quarter of next year.

Threadneedle believes its relative underperformance on the list is due to the fact that several of its leading funds – such as its UK select growth, mid 250 and limited-issue funds – are recent additions to its range.

Communications director Richard Eats says: “I am surprised that HL has not included the high-yield bond fund as we regard our high-yield team as the best in the market.”

Performance is key but HL&#39s criteria revolve around potential or sustained performance in the long term rather than the immediate benefits.

This is best reflected by the fact that there are huge discrepancies between each sector on the list. The UK growth sector, for instance, is represented by 36 funds while the North America sector has only eight funds. Technology and telecoms, despite recent rallies, has only three. According to HL, this is simply a consequence of its selection criteria, a combination of quant screens and the qualitative preferences of its investment team led by head of research Mark Dampier.

Senior analyst Meera Patel says the integrity of HL&#39s app-roach to the list is further ref-lected by the presence of companies that few people will have heard of. Among these, she includes Thornhill Capital, SVM and Unicorn, which have some outstanding funds but almost no brand to speak of. She is also pleased to see so many boutiques knocking their monolithic rivals off the list.

This is not to sound the death knell for the major groups, however. Boutiques may be snapping at their ankles but the top of HL&#39s list is dominated by the usual suspects. Invesco Perpetual is the big winner with 10 funds, closely shadowed by Jupiter and New Star – no longer a boutique with £4.3bn of retail money under management – with nine funds.

With seven funds, how-ever, Artemis can look down on Fidelity, which has only six – certainly no disgrace but few experts would have thought it could be usurped by a com-pany which is a fraction of its size. Framlington, a mid-sized group widely perceived to be going nowhere fast two years ago, also has seven funds and not just because it now has Nigel Thomas and George Luckraft on board.

But perhaps the best example of a group punching its weight is Liontrust, which has three funds on the list from a total product range of five. The boutiques may not have the sheer numbers to dominate the list in the way Invesco can but on a ratio basis – in terms of performance – they more often than not best their bigger rivals. Without lists such as HL&#39s, however, few direct investors would ever know.

Recommended

Solus streamlines its fund offering

Brown Shipley&#39s fund management arm Solus has seen a reshuffle of funds and management team. The shake-up has been led by new managing director Tony Hurley and chairman David Rough. Hurley, who is also Brown Shipley&#39s head of private banking, has taken over from Graeme Sinclair, who is leaving the company. Brown Shipley&#39s investment policy […]

Out of context

•”I know what you are thinking. What does an Essex man with a Massachusetts accent know about our industry?” – International Financial Data Services chief executive Charles Eppinger speaking to a conference audience. •”We are going to send out 1.7 million pieces of paper with cherubs on, plus only another 700,000 each year, probably on […]

L&G enhances group life assurance for partnerships

Legal & General has improved its partners&#39 group life assurance policy to take advantage of changes to chargeable event rules that have come in as part of the Finance Act 2003. The change means most policies now fall outside these rules, eliminating any potential taxable gain that can arise on the second and subsequent death […]

MP&#39s concern at new breed of structured plan

A Treasury select committee member has raised concerns with the FSA over a new breed of structured product emerging in the marketplace. Liberal Democrat MP Norman Lamb wants the FSA to pay close attention to structured capital at risk products, a high-income bond derivative. He has written to FSA chief executive John Tiner demanding more […]

A modern horror story

Every day a quick scan of the news reveals some new horror that will change the lives of those involved forever – the unlucky accident on the way to work, a tragic illness that cuts a young life short or the holiday accident that leaves more than just a scar to cope with. We barely […]

Newsletter

News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up

Comments

    Leave a comment

    Close

    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm

    Email: customerservices@moneymarketing.com