View more on these topics

Lipsey words are gut-wrenching

The article last week headlined, Misleading claims won big payouts, was not the big story since every IFA in my experience has been only too painfully aware of it for years.

On the other hand, what was gut-wrenching was the sentence by Lord David Lipsey, who said that, in his experience, some of those compensated “knew it was in their interest to forget what had happened to them”.

He said this problem increased over time as more people got payouts and advised others on the correct thing to say to ensure they were compensated despite not having a valid case.

I urge Money Marketing to use its own considerable expertise to investigate under the Freedom of Information Act exactly when and how Lord Lipsey, as a PIA director and member of the regulator’s pension review committee (which monitored the review and advised the FSA on the issue when it formed) and his regulatory colleagues learned that advisers have wrongly paid out millions of pounds in fraudulently claimed compensation as a result of the review he was running.

Lord Lipsey’s statement may imply that not only have IFAs been subject to a reversal of the usual law of innocent until proven guilty but may confirm that the regulator was aware at the time that it was forcing IFAs (and in fact the whole industry) to pay out on a high proportion of fraudulent claims because the normal rules of evidence and reasonable doubt were specifically suspended to facilitate this travesty of justice.

If this is the case, would it not be reasonable for professional indemnity insurers and IFAs to reclaim a substantial amount from the regulator for these far from insignificant amounts?

Michael Both
Michael Philips
Chesham,
Buckinghamshire

Recommended

Fidelity targets DC market with lifestyle funds

Fidelity is looking to strengthen its foothold in the defined-contribution pension market and develop a range of actively managed lifestyle funds.The fund firm hopes to launch a number of products next year based on its existing target funds but with a longer time horizon.Fidelity says it will consider putting forward a target fund for inclusion […]

‘Industry must pay towards generic advice’

The financial industry must contribute to the funding of generic advice and the Government is looking at moving towards matching industry contributions, says Treasury Economic Secretary Kitty Ussher.At an Investment Management Association fringe event at the Labour party conference last week, Ussher said if the concept of generic advice succeeds, then everyone will benefit so […]

Merger to bring fund changes

MitonOptimal says the combined Iimia MitonOptimal group must differentiate the funds in its range as it will have three funds in each of the IMA active, balanced and cautious managed sectors.MitonOptimal favours making changes to the funds where necessary rather than reducing the number of funds because it claims that individual fund managers do not […]

McAteer says public would suffer if Icob is changed

Consumer advocate Mick McAteer says the FSA’s proposed changes to the Icob regime are likely to be detrimental to consumers and the market.In a report commissioned by Unum, McAteer says consumers will be worse off bec-ause the proposal to separate products into simple and complex categories puts income protection products at a disadvantage as it […]

Abe and Modi

Investment ideas to power returns

We believe the most exciting stockmarket opportunities today are in those places where a new generation of leaders are successfully transforming economies and companies in favour of investors. In a new investment guide and website, which is suitable for use with your clients, we set out our views on these reformers. Click here to find […]

Newsletter

News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up

Comments

    Leave a comment