View more on these topics

‘Like asking a school child to mark their own homework’: Govt under fire over MAS review response

The Government has come under fire for failing to act following a damning report into the Money Advice Service.

The Farnish report, published earlier today, called for the budget of the body to be slashed, alongside a dramatic restructure.

MAS has responded by promising to evaluate the report before going back to the Government in the Autumn. The Government will then publish its own findings by the end of the year.

A source close to the report describes the plans as “frustrating”.

The source says: “It’s like asking a schoolchild to mark their own homework. That is what the Government is doing here. The chances of MAS being able to mark an impartial and objective assessment of itself are pretty slim. It’s appalling that the Government is now handing the ball back to MAS.”

Apfa director general Chris Hannant says: “The Government has been sitting on the report for the best part of six months, surely it can make up its mind on what it thinks is right or not?

“Why can’t the Government either accept it or reject it? Why does it need MAS to say what it thinks?

“I was caught speeding the other week, and no-one asks me whether I thought it was fair or right, I was just told to pay the fine or take a course.”

Treasury Select Committee chairman Andrew Tyrie adds that while the Farnish report is welcome, the government has still failed to enquire whether MAS should be abolished all together.

“Christine Farnish – the independent reviewer -shares the Committee’s concerns about the high spending by MAS on its website and marketing. She has also expressed concern about the extent to which the MAS may be duplicating the work of private and voluntary sector providers. On the latter, she concludes that the budget for the MAS’s consumer finance education role could be halved,” Tyrie says.

“However, the crucial question of the MAS’s future as a statutory body was excluded from the reviewer’s terms of reference. MAS have now been asked to respond to Ms Farnish’s report in the autumn. When the Government considers that response, it should also consider the MAS’s future as a statutory body.”

Essential IFA founder Peter Herd says the MAS should now focus on financial education and signposting users to regulated financial advice.

He adds: “I think that MAS needs to work with the regulator and with the Government to establish what needs to be done to fill the advice gap.

“We all want to expand but we are not given the support because we are being undermined by this free ‘advice’, when we have regulation that says there is no such thing as free financial advice.”


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There are 4 comments at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. What advice gap is everyone talking about?

    Has anyone bothered to ask the public what they thought before spending over 40 million pounds?

    Close it down tomorrow no one will even notice.

  2. So when the Treasury, FCA, Tax Office, FSCS or any other “Official Body” ask me a question about my compliance / sales process my answer will be…..

    “Let me have the paperwork and I will reply in the Autumn!”……………… yeah right!

  3. Seriously? A 11 recommendation is that “FCA to make rules to require retail firms to promote the MAS website and helpline”

    So we pay for it and promote it?!

    You couldn’t make this stuff up

  4. Given that the government has failed to act on assorted damning reports on the activities of the FCA (merely rebadging the FSA plainly hasn’t yielded any tangible benefits such as greater fiscal prudence, openness, fairness or accountability), what likelihood can there be that it’ll act in the wake of this damning report into the Money Advice Service? The MAS must surely be an embarrassment to the government but, short of scrapping it, a course of action for which I suspect the government doesn’t have the stomach, what can it do? It could, of course, set up a Statutory Independent Regulatory Oversight Committee, as it should do to yank the reins on the FCA but of that it seems there’s little or no chance. So, in practice, the MAS will just be allowed to muddle on whilst the rest of us continue to have to pay for it.

Leave a comment


Why register with Money Marketing ?

Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

Money Marketing Events
Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

Research and insight
Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

Have your say
Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

Register now

Having problems?

Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm