View more on these topics

Lifetime ISAs – International Evidence

By Fiona Tait, Pensions Specialist

Since the announcement in March, the Lifetime ISA (LISA) has attracted controversy. Heralded as a saviour for the self-employed and the young wanting to get on the housing ladder, the new LISA risks adding confusion for savers trying to fully understand the benefits of new workplace pension savings through auto-enrolment.

To better understand how the LISA could work with the current UK pensions system, Royal London sponsored independent research by the Pensions Policy Institute (PPI) to examine the international evidence of how early access savings schemes worked in other countries.

The PPI research examined evidence from five countries – the US, Canada, Australia, New Zealand and Singapore – and compared similar propositions in those countries to the proposed  LISA available in the UK from April 2017.

Royal London fed into the research through a panel debate which included representatives from the Treasury, DWP, ABI and Personal Finance Society, among others, which helped inform the final research Briefing Note,Lifetime ISAs – international evidence’.

The findings raised a number of key issues about the impact of the LISA on long-term savings in the UK that will need to be addressed before they are launched.

  • First, in all of the countries surveyed, early access schemes were integrated into the wider pensions system. Without the need to select a separate product for early access saving, this means that savers do not miss out on valuable employer contributions, the loss of which PPI calculated could reduce LISA savers' pot sizes by up to a third at retirement. This integration extends to being able to secure an income in retirement, the mechanics of which for prospective LISA savers is still not clear.
  • Early access has affected the investment attitudes of long-term international savers. Evidence from the US and New Zealand shows that savers are more conservative, investing in lower-risk, lower-return assets that are highly liquid. Given that over 80 per cent of ISAs are currently held in cash – a trend particularly pronounced among young savers – it is likely  that LISA savers will follow a similarly risk-averse strategy. This is potentially not the best investment strategy for long-term pension saving.
  • One of the stark differences between a LISA and international early access long-term savings regimes is the treatment of first home purchase. Just 1.8 per cent of the 2.5 million New Zealanders using the ‘KiwiSaver’ scheme had withdrawn money for a first home. In Singapore, funds withdrawn to purchase a home must be repaid with interest when the property is sold to mitigate loss of funds.
  • There are also tax restrictions in other countries to encourage phased withdrawals. There is no proposal yet on whether the funds accessed from LISA will require repayment or restrictions on withdrawals to ensure savings are not depleted too early.
  • One of the arguments in favour of LISAs is that they will allow savers to withdraw their money free of any tax charges, if they meet the terms outlined. In Australia, where withdrawals are currently tax-free on Superannuation policies, the most recent Australian budget proposed a retrospective tax of 15 per cent on withdrawals of above A$1.6m. This is a high amount but PPIs flag that this is a way for governments to limit the tax-free savings available and increase revenue. This questions whether LISAs will always be TEE in the long term.
  • LISAs are not framed as workplace pensions and so will not be regulated by The Pensions Regulator. This means that LISA savers are unlikely to benefit from a charge cap, which is currently set at 0.75 per cent, or the provision of free guidance. This could have a significant impact for long-term savings. PPI estimated that if Lifetime ISA funds were charged at 1-1.5 per cent, they could erode the value of a savings pot by 13 per cent by retirement.
  • In other countries, early access is monitored by a combination of providers, employers and government. If LISA providers are responsible for managing early access this will increase the administrative burden, resulting in higher charges for LISA savers.

For more information: The Pensions Policy Institute (PPI) is an educational research charity, which provides non-political, independent comment and analysis on policy on pensions and retirement income provision in the UK. Its aim is to improve the information and understanding about pensions policy and retirement income provision through research and analysis, discussion and publication. Further information on the PPI is available on its website:

The Pensions Policy Institute’s previous briefing note on the LISA, ‘Lifetime ISAs: pension complement or rival’.


To be and not to be – Multi asset investing with conviction

At Pictet Asset Management we believe active management of asset allocation is the most important generator of returns. What is not to be in our portfolio is just as important as what is to be because good performance is determined as much by the assets you avoid as by those you hold. The FP Pictet Multi Asset Portfolio managers are not wedded to any particular […]

Aberdeen Gilbert Martin Gilbert 700x450

Aberdeen sees £1.5bn outflows from property fund

Aberdeen Asset Management has seen £8.9bn of net outflows in the past quarter, including £1.5bn coming out of its property funds. In a trading update, published today, the asset manager saw the largest net outflows from its equities division, with £2.9bn leaving the strategies. Multi-asset followed with £1.7bn of net outflows in the three months to the […]


Govt rejects MPs’ call for ‘urgent’ Lifetime Isa study

The Government will not commission a study into the possible impact of the Lifetime Isa on pensions. The Work and Pensions committee of MPs recommended “urgent research” on how the launch of the Lifetime Isa in April 2017 might hit pensions savings through auto-enrolment. Ex-pensions ministers Ros Altmann and Steve Webb have previously warned the […]


Life companies hit by Capita staff strike

Life companies including Aviva, Prudential and Royal London are being hit by a two-day strike held by Capita staff. A Unite spokeswoman says areas impacted include pensions administration, contract centres, finance and IT projects. The 48-hour strike is part of an ongoing dispute over staff pay – which Unite says is a real terms pay […]

Mothers missing out on millions

By Steve Webb, director of policy and external communications The ninth Royal London Policy Paper discusses how thousands of mothers are missing out on state pension rights when they don’t have to Earlier this month we published the ninth Royal London Policy Paper, entitled ‘Mothers Missing out on Millions’. It focuses on the thousands of mothers […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm