View more on these topics

‘Last-chance saloon’ for the cowboy claim firms

The Claims Standards Council has given hope to IFAs buckling under the weight of endowment complaints by promising to launch a “nuclear” attack on rogue claim management firms.<

Antipathy towards ambulance-chasers has reached fever pitch as endowment complaints have rocketed and IFAs have been forced to pay higher levies for the Financial Services Compensation Scheme.

Pressure has also increased on the Government to regulate claim management firms. The CSC is a voluntary watchdog which is expected to installed as regulator of the sector with the passing of the Compensation Bill. It says it has uncovered a series of scandals in the sector, including a case of a firm accused of dispatching bailiffs to recover their slice of compensation from late-paying customers.Policy director Andy Wigmore says the CSC has so far uncovered 10 rogue firms and has 57 complaints on file against claim management firms. He says sending round bailiffs to sort out customers is hardly common practice and that many complaints centre on marketing techniques used by firms.Wigmore says: “This is the last-chance saloon for firms that engage in scandalous market practices and are fleecing customers. We will go nuclear on these firms and they will be squeezed out of the market when we become regulator.”The CSC has also received a number of complaints about one of its members, endowment claim management firm Brunel Franklin, which has provoked IFA anger by offering its clients a “chequebook” to encourage friends and relatives to make complaints. Each book contains six cheques worth £100 for each referral which results in a successful claim.Brunel Franklin does not feature on the CSC’s list of rogue firms. One of its marketing leaflets says: “There’s no limit to the amount you can receive.”It tells customers receiving its chequebook: “There are six cheques within this booklet, which makes this chequebook worth a potential £600 – so keep this chequebook with you at all times as you’d be amazed at how many people suffer shortfalls.”The Advertising Standards Authority says it has received a complaint about Brunel Franklin for implying in its marketing that everyone holding an endowment policy is entitled to compensation.The CSC is investigating an entirely separate complaint against Brunel Franklin but is not at present following up any complaints about its marketing practices.Personal Finance Society public affairs director John Ellis is in no doubt that these marketing ploys are misleading and unethical. He argues that some claim management firms are implying that suffering an endowment shortfall entitles a customer to compensation automatically.The Analysts compliance officer Tom Kean cites what he perceives as the hypocrisy of claim-chasers using the same high-pressure sales tactics as advisers have been accused of using to sell policies in the first place.But claim management firms defend how their businesses are run. Endowment UK director Marianne Fitzjohn says firms like hers have a clear responsibility to manage policyholders’ expectations and ensure they do not see their endowment shortfall as a winning lottery ticket.Brunel Franklin, which says it carefully vets all its marketing material, highlights its credentials as an active member of the CSC, a long-term campaigner for regulation and a pillar of the claim management community.Claims director Ian Allison says the refer- a-friend idea encompassed by Brunel Franklin’s “chequebook” is a legitimate marketing tool that has been used successfully by the financial sector for many years.Allison says the firm is educating the public about their right to claim for missold endowments, which will be lost by the arbitrary time-barring by life companies.Independent compliance consultant Adam Samuel says these firms would not exist if the industry handled complaints properly.He says: “Everyone talks about these evil firms after their pound of flesh and driving up fraudulent complaints but firms operating on a no-win,no-fee basis will not go after obviously invalid complaints they have no chance of winning.”With the FSA last week fining Guardian Assurance and Guardian Linked Life £750,000 for “serious systemic flaws in mortgage endowment complaint-handling procedures”, there is evidence that customers need claim management firms.Whether firms will be allowed to be so aggressive in pursuing their slice of the compensation pie remains to be seen.


750K endowment fine for Guardian slammed as ‘too lenient’

Aegon-owned Guardian Assurance and Guardian Linked Life Assurance have been fined 750,000 by the FSA after it found serious flaws in their mortgage endowment complaint-handling procedures. The fine is the second- biggest imposed by the FSA over endowment complaints. Abbey was fined 800,000 last May while Allied Dun- bar received a 725,000 fine in March […]

AITC says pension deficits could affect growth prospects

73 per cent of investment trust fund managers say company growth prospects will be affected if companies are forced to pay off their pension deficits over the next ten years. They also have concerns about a lack of consumer spending and rising interest rates according to the AITC’s recent survey of 31 managers from 42 […]

The black hole of final-salary schemes

It seems to me that most people in the financial services industry and the Government fail to see how illogical final-salary pension schemes are in a capitalist society, as the liability is open-ended and, as such, cannot be justified in a prudent economy. Nic Cicutti in his column says that final-salary scheme employees contribute a […]

Standard hits the snail on the head

Nice to see Standard Life’s corporate responsibility manager Andrew Marshall-Roberts getting down and dirty for a good cause. The provider has set up a Treemail scheme which aims to replant a forest in the Scottish Highlands with a 100,000 donation to the Trees for Life charity. Standard has pledged to buy a seedling for each […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There is one comment at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. mfVhJb byfijmyrkeqj, [url=]zxmztuentnpa[/url], [link=]jkntqimotche[/link],

Leave a comment


Why register with Money Marketing ?

Providing trusted insight for professional advisers. Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and thought leadership.

News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

Money Marketing Events
Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

Research and insight
Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

Have your say
Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

Register now

Having problems?

Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm