View more on these topics

Kim North: Where are the TVAS providers?

Kim North

I always enjoy judging the Money Marketing awards, as I learn about leading businesses and meet new contacts. Last week, we discussed with those shortlisted in the paraplanner category what their involvement with pension transfers is.

I was surprised to hear there are so few providers that will offer suitability reports and transfer value analysis with the compliant numbers. In the 1990s, there were dozens of transfer value analysis system providers available to my IFA firm, including most of the big brand personal pension providers. Today, you can count the number of TVAS providers available on one hand.

In order to meet the demand for those wishing to transfer both defined contribution and defined benefit pension funds there needs to be more choice for advisers. This is especially true when it comes to the transfer numbers, particularly the critical yield (the rate at which the plan needs to grow by each year to normal retirement age to purchase an equivalent annuity).

The only big brand pension provider that offers a free TVAS appears to be Prudential. There are two other TVAS providers that are well used by advisers and they are both technology companies. However, some senior commentators claim these companies offer TVAS services that are not fit for purpose.

I normally comment in these pages that there is too much choice for advisers. We are seeing leading firms move to restricted status and I understand the reasons for this, as a restricted range of products may result in the same outcomes for around 95 per cent of clients than if the advisers had remained independent.

Less product choice also makes advisory firms more cost effective, as there are reduced research costs and less time needed to maintain provider to adviser relationships. But pension transfer services is a relevant area with great consumer demand and advisers need more choice when it comes to who they use.

Consultancy CTC estimates the average vesting pension from a DB scheme is £120,000 and from a DC scheme £40,000. There are three million active members of funded DB schemes (nine million if deferred members are included). Currently, everyone with a DB scheme worth over £30,000 needs to take regulated financial advice if they wish to transfer, so the FCA recognises quality advice is crucial. Further regulatory guidance is due soon from the CP15/30 final rules.

According to Apfa, calculating the transfer value and critical yield in every single case is neither necessary nor relevant. It says it is more important to base transfer advice on individual circumstances, including the primary reason a client wants to leave one scheme in favour of another. I agree with this comment because while we have artificially low gilt yields the critical yield can be too high and unrealistic.

As TVASs before pension freedoms took the assumption an annuity was always purchased, this made the numbers easier to produce. With the advent of the freedoms TVASs needed to change to provide drawdown numbers. We have had the freedoms for over a year so why have previous TVAS providers not re-entered the market? If you want to be a respected technical pension provider you should offer a compliant and consumer friendly TVAS.

Kim North is managing director at Technology and Technical 



Are advisers over-reliant on critical yields for pension transfers?

Defined benefit transfer advice processes should be overhauled as too much emphasis is placed on critical yields, advisers argue. Specialist pension transfer advice firm Tideway says it is “deeply concerning” advisers are relying on critical yields – which pinpoint the investment returns needed to match the benefits offered by the existing scheme. Tideway partner James Baxter […]


FOS rules against insistent client pension transfer

The FOS has ruled against advice firm Portal Financial after it transferred the pension of an illiterate insistent client. The client, Mrs W, complained that she wanted to take tax free cash from her pension to pay for new solar panels. She claimed she did not realise Portal had transferred the pension until later. In […]


Martin Tilley: The high cost of Sipp commercial property transfers

Collection of data for the purpose of management information is key to a well-run business, and looking for trends can help allocate resources to meet demand. Monitoring not only numbers of new cases but investments being made, sources of business and so on, can help identify these trends. One that has become increasingly strong lately […]


Scottish Widows transfers business to London

Scottish Widows has transferred its life insurance business away from Edinburgh to London. The Sunday Times reports that billions of pounds in life insurance business at Scottish Widows has been moved to London, marking the end of its 200 years of Scottish registration. The move was effective from the end of 2015. The business will be registered at […]

Cricket - thumbnail

England vs Australia: pensions

Well, the cricket season is here, and England and Australia are stepping up to the wicket. Although we compete with each other in the sporting world, when it comes to pensions, Australia’s pension programme is held up as a model for our auto-enrolment initiative. Auto-enrolment was introduced because people weren’t saving enough into their pensions, and it is still early days but signs are positive. However, in Australia, saving into a pension is compulsory, and in fact employers are the ones who have to pay in. Employees in Australia can make additional contributions into their pensions, but they don’t have to. Should the onus be on the employer or employee to save? Well in the UK we think it’s both, but to get ‘adequate’ savings for retirement it’s the employee who has to pay more in.


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There are 2 comments at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. You should check your sources, both Scottish Widows and Axa also offer free TVAS

  2. Old mutual wealth also offer free tvas

Leave a comment


Why register with Money Marketing ?

Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

Money Marketing Events
Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

Research and insight
Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

Have your say
Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

Register now

Having problems?

Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm