View more on these topics

John Lawson: Trust-based schemes need more robust regulation

After opt-outs, automatic enrolment will, in my estimation, create six million new pension savers.

The pensions industry is rightly seeing this as a big opportunity but we also inherit a big responsibility too. If we get this wrong, our customers will never forgive us.

At the heart of getting it right is good governance.

Insurance companies have been making steady progress for years, nudged along by our regulator, the FSA, and its good governance initiatives like TCF. Our product design processes, fund governance and complaints handling have all improved markedly.

And, despite what others may say, insurers have made positive changes off their own bat too, such as the new OMO Code of Practice. Insurers’ pension customers are already much more likely to shop around for their pension income than members of trust-based schemes, and this will hopefully improve things further.

Trust-based schemes, on the other hand, are a mixed bag when it comes to governance. Some of the biggest ones like Nest do it very well (although they do spend a lot of taxpayer’s money doing it).

But others, including big schemes, with more than 1,000 members are not exactly shooting the lights out. The Pensions Regulator recently measured trust-based schemes against a benchmark of 21 features that they thought should be present in well-governed schemes. Things like knowledgeable trustees, good administration standards and reviewing the default fund.

Only 8 per cent of large schemes could demonstrate the presence of all 21 features, and only 1 per cent of small schemes. Put another way, 92 out of 100 large trust-based schemes have room for improvement, most of them lots of room for improvement.

And these are the ones that are trying to get it right. The barriers to entry are so low that the trust-based market is now home to pension refunders, taking advantage of the two-year refund rule, and pension liberators.

The Pensions Regulator knows there is a problem. It has already said that it does not want people automatically enrolled into small DC schemes. It also published a new code of practice with a ‘comply or explain’ regime.

Is comply or explain good enough?

That’s not how the FSA and its successors work. The FSA has the power to take regulatory action against failure and frequently exercises this power. The FCA will have even greater power; to immediately stop any practice potentially leading to customer detriment whilst it investigates.

The Pensions Regulator does not have the same resources to get tough with the tens of thousands of under-performing trust-based schemes. That is why they are allowed to self-certify.

The answer to this conundrum is simple, in my view; raise the entry barrier.

This could be done by imposing a good regulation levy on trust-based schemes, giving the regulator the funds to do a proper job. It would also see all those small schemes unable to afford the levy move their members to bigger schemes capable of doing a good job. And it would also allow the regulator to develop a proper registration system to keep refunders and liberators out.

The FSA is raising the entry barriers to the Sipp market at the moment, introducing new capital adequacy and compulsory new business illustrations. And rightly so. The Pensions Regulator should observe its actions with interest.

John Lawson is corporate benefits head of policy at Aviva


FSCS rejects claims from Rockingham ARM investors

Rockingham Independent clients who invested in a troubled Luxembourg-based life settlement vehicle will not receive compensation for their losses from the Financial Services Compensation Scheme. ARM Asset Backed Securities issued bonds based on life settlement policies without the appropriate permissions which were sold to investors in the UK and Europe. Of the 2,000 UK investors […]


FSA writes to Sipps requesting details of Harlequin investments

The FSA has written to Sipp operators requesting information on members who have invested in Harlequin Property. The regulator has contacted Sipp firms asking whether any of their clients have holdings in the overseas property company. Any firm whose members have invested in Harlequin have been given five working days to provide the FSA with […]

Advisers question IMA’s absolute return sector plans

Advisers have questioned whether the Investment Management Association’s decision to rename the absolute return sector as the “targeted absolute return sector” will benefit investors. The IMA has defined the targeted absolute return sector as funds managed with the aim of delivering positive returns in any market conditions, but returns are not guaranteed. Funds in the […]

Henderson’s John Bennett warns fixed income investors are ‘doomed’

Henderson director of European equities John Bennett believes fixed income investors are likely to face a stealth bear market and a possible collapse in bonds. Speaking at the Fund Strategy Investment Summit in Kitzbuhel last week, Bennett said there has been an “outrageous party” in fixed income over the last few years. He said: “Unless […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm