View more on these topics

John Lawson: The downfall with default pathways

The FCA’s proposals aim to limit damage from poor choices rather than provide the best solution. This is where advisers come in

In the latest instalment of the Retirement Outcomes Review (CP19/5), published at the end of January, the FCA put forward some sensible remedies. The headline measure of default investment pathways will provide non-advised drawdown customers with clear solutions to match their retirement choices.

The paper also proposed making investment in cash an active choice, at least in part because the FCA found some 33 per cent of non-advised drawdown consumers were holding it alone.

While this may be suitable for those planning to draw down their entire pot over a short period, it is clearly unsuitable for someone planning to do so over a longer timeframe, potentially leading to a lower income in retirement.

To remedy this, the FCA has proposed pension providers must give customers warnings about the likely impact of investing in cash on their long-term income, both when they enter or transfer into drawdown, and on an ongoing basis.

Are default drawdown pathways a good idea? Industry heavyweights weigh in

Charges are another prominent topic. The paper proposed that firms tell customers drawing on their pension how much they have paid in charges over the previous year.

Importantly, this figure would be in pounds and pence, and would also include any transaction costs.

Finally, it was recommended wake-up packs are sent to customers from age 50, rather than six months before a pre-selected retirement age.

This will give people more time to consider their options before they are able to access their savings.

While these proposals are welcome and necessary for non-advised customers accessing their pension, they are not a panacea.

Their ambition appears to be to limit damage from poor choices, rather than provide the best solution for any individual.

For example, default pathways will see savers defaulted into the option most relevant to their intended choice and they may never question it. That pathway may not reflect their personal attitude to risk and it will almost certainly ignore their capacity for loss.

We also know from automatic enrolment that defaults are great for getting people started, but that they tend not to make active choices thereafter.

If a customer says they intend to buy an annuity within the next five years, they will follow one investment path. But what happens if the saver changes their mind?

How likely are they to inform their provider of this and be moved to a new and more appropriate path?

That is why default pathways could create an opportunity for advisers. Savers will need help to understand whether they have defaulted into the right option. They will also need help if their plans change. It may mean advisers need to adapt or create new processes that allow them to maintain a relationship with more mass-market customers in the future, and a process for intervention when needed.

Andrew Tully: Finally, progress on retirement outcomes

The FCA paper also makes it clear that providers will not be offering personalised recommendations, even where they default savers into a pathway. That leaves plenty of space for advisers to fill the demand gap. People still want to be told what they should do and why.

Currently, providers are forced to treat savers the same, regardless of the amount they have saved.

That means someone with a pot worth £5,000 must take part in lengthy conversations about annuities and flexi-access drawdown, neither of which are of any use or relevance to them.

We need a simpler journey for these people; one that focuses on how they can extract their money over a reasonably short period in the most tax-efficient manner.

There is, of course, also the big question of how much people should pay for a default option.

There needs to be a clear focus on value here and not just a race to the bottom when it comes to charges.

Volatility can have a devastating effect on someone who is in retirement when they do not have the years ahead of them to claw back large losses. It is worth paying a little more to reduce that risk.

Overall, I am encouraged by the FCA’s work in this area. The industry has been crying out for a way to give customers some direction when they are approaching retirement.

Default pathways are a good next step, without treading on the toes of the advice sector.

John Lawson is head of financial research at Aviva



Benchmark Capital acquisition process under question over fund flow ‘assumptions’

Questions have been raised over Benchmark Capital’s acquisition process after it appears the group gave a potential acquisition target “assumptions” for flows going onto its platform and in to its funds. A document seen by Money Marketing, was initially given to an advice firm in sale talks with Benchmark Capital. It is a spreadsheet which […]


Budget 2018: Lifetime allowance nudges up as Hammond bucks pension tax reform rumours

The lifetime allowance for pension savings will increase slightly more than expected next year to £1,055,000, according to Budget documents published today. Initially the lifetime allowance was meant to increase in line with September’s figures for the Consumer Price Index to £1,054,800. But the government has rounded up the lifetime allowance slightly more than originally expected. […]

Navigating volatility

The making of any fund can be seen in how it responds to crises and opportunities. In this short video, Head of Multi Asset at Royal London Asset Management Trevor Greetham outlines how the Royal London Global Multi Asset Portfolios or GMAPs navigated through Brexit and the US election cycle. He also highlights the importance […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm