View more on these topics

John Chatfeild-Roberts: What does Italy’s election mean for the rest of the eurozone?

Italy’s recent election can be important for goings on in the rest of the eurozone

The Italian electorate, clearly dissatisfied with the EU and its incumbent political class, has plunged the country into constitutional crisis.

Two months beyond the inconclusive March general election, Italian political parties had been struggling to stitch together a workable coalition which might produce some semblance of a stable, effective government.

The two parties with the biggest share of the vote, Five Star (a left-wing anti-establishment party) and The League (a right-wing, on-off secessionist party from the north), seemed unlikely bedfellows. The only common ground between the two, apart from neither party having ever been in government, is a visceral loathing of the euro and Brussels’ centralisation.

When, in late March, these two announced the proposal of a coalition and a radical economic package – including €250bn of debt relief from the EU, abandoning pension reform and rowing back on austerity economics with a significant spending plan – it was as if a political nuclear device had detonated in Europe.

Brussels, its antennae as blunt as ever, reacted predictably and the Italian president vetoed the appointment of a dyed-in-the-wool left-wing eurosceptic academic as finance minister. As the situation threatened to unravel quickly, further negotiations did secure the president’s approval for prime minister Giuseppe Conte and his ministers. So the politically-inexperienced new government is currently in the process of setting out its stall; whether it eventually succeeds, survives or disintegrates remains an open question.

Fixed income volatility

Italy is the third-largest economy in the eurozone, and only ranks behind Germany for manufacturing, so what happens in Italy matters a great deal. Financial markets’ initial reaction to the crisis was swift, as investors rapidly dumped Italian government bonds and the bonds of Italian companies potentially vulnerable to financial dislocation (especially banks, which in Italy are notoriously wobbly even at the best of times).

Italy’s politically-inexperienced new government is currently in the process of setting out its stall

Investors also sold bonds of other potentially risky eurozone governments, notably Greece, Spain and Portugal, and instead switched to perceived safe-haven German and US bonds. As a result, bond-price volatility was at its greatest since before the global financial crisis and bond markets are likely to remain volatile until the fog lifts. Equity markets reacted too, although less dramatically than the bond market.

In the near-term, we believe these events are unlikely to undermine global economic growth, though much will depend on how central banks react, especially the European Central Bank. It would certainly be significant if Italy were to eventually leave the euro, and it would pose a systemic economic and financial threat if the euro were to collapse as a result. At present, that does not seem a likely outcome, but stranger things have happened.

Further afield

Consistently through the pre-election hustings in 2016, Donald Trump was emphatic: he thought the Iranian nuclear containment treaty, negotiated on his predecessor’s watch, was “a terrible deal” and, when in office, he would have no hesitation withdrawing the US from it. He has since done precisely that in the face of strong opposition from co-signatories to the treaty, notably Nato allies, but also Russia and China. At the same time, he announced the resumption of punitive sanctions on Iran, including an effective embargo on oil exports.

Oil traders responded to the embargo and the price of oil spiked, briefly reaching $80 per barrel, a price not seen since it was going the other way in the 2014 collapse. These are big gyrations in the price of the world’s most important commodity. Happily, compared with a generation ago, the march of technological and economic progress has made the global economy less vulnerable to significant spikes in the price of oil, both in terms of inflation and economic activity. Politically, however, an already unstable Middle East situation has become more febrile; an upcoming OPEC meeting could be a catalyst, as Saudi Arabia (Iran’s implacable foe) and Russia (Iran’s ally in the Syrian war) are each likely to take advantage of Iran’s plight to increase their own oil production.

John Chatfeild-Roberts is head of strategy for the Jupiter Independent Funds Team


TPR suspends trustee after police launch fraud investigation

The Pensions Regulator has suspended a scheme trustee after detectives from an elite crime unit launched a fraud investigation over allegations about his role in a scam. Gordon Craig is the subject of an investigation by Titan, the North West regional organised crime unit, in connection with his role as a trustee of Optimum Retirement […]


Old Mutual Wealth: 60/40 balanced model is ‘dead’

The way investor sentiment and habits have changed in recent years, particularly in the retirement space, means the traditional 60/40 multi-asset split is “probably dead”, Old Mutual Wealth head of investments Anthony Gillham says. He says if you had the traditional equity/fixed income split, investors would have seen a fall in the beginning of this […]


Paul Lewis: Advisers and financial journalists are one and the same

Advisers and financial journalists must support each other more in our different roles. After all, we both exist for the same reason Why do financial journalists exist? I am sure that it is a question many IFAs ask, especially when they read things they think are wrong, dangerous or fail to end with “find a […]

Equitable Life sale to bring windfall for policyholders

Embattled mutual insurer Equitable Life has been bought by Reliance Life, part of the Life Company Consolidation Group. In March reports emerged the firm was preparing to sell. Equitable Life, which has been in run-off since closing to new business in 2000, was still technically owned by its more than 300,000 remaining policyholders, most of […]


A tailored approach to protection

By Ian Smart, Product Architect, Royal London In an ideal world, clients would be able to afford as much protection cover as they wanted, but few would describe current times as anything approaching ideal. But this doesn’t mean that they have to indulge in an either/or decision that results in missing out on some essential […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm