View more on these topics

It’s cold outside

Afew years ago, I met a veteran of the Spanish civil war who knew a lot about the state second pension – then called the state earnings-related pension scheme.

He told me: “That pension scheme was never meant to have anything to do with personal pensions or money-purchase pensions. It was meant for employers’ schemes.

“I don’t regard personal pensions as pensions at all. They’re just glorified savings schemes. With a proper pension, you don’t just know what you’re putting in. You know what you’re going to get out of it,” he added.

Another octogenarian, who was there at the inception of Serps and contracting out was equally obdurate. “This was the biggest public-private partnership ever undertaken. But it wasn’t meant for defined-contribution schemes. It was Mrs Thatcher who extended it to personal pensions and money-purchase schemes and we were fundamentally opposed. It should never have happened.”

These two had been at each other’s throats for a quarter of a century over industrial relations matters. But now Jack Jones and Barbara Castle were reunited to save what had once been hailed as the crown jewel of Labour’s progressive reforms – the state earnings-related pension scheme.

Was Barbara Castle right to say that contracting out into personal pensions should never have happened?

Right now, contracting out for most policyholders does not add up. The National Insurance rebates paid into policies are meant to be sufficient, on reasonable assumptions about inflation, investment growth and longevity, to replicate the benefits that would have been available had the policyholder stayed in Serps/state second pension. But for years they have been barely enough under the best assumptions. Now investment and mortality assumptions have shifted, most would be better off not contracted out of the state second pension but contracted in.

The only breaks in this consensus are what to do about it. Prudential’s UK chief executive Mark Wood has called on the Government to raise the rebates. Norwich Union has written to policyholders letting them know it is contracting them back into the state second pension unless they object.

Contracting out was first allowed for personal pensions in 1988, as part of Mrs Thatcher’s attempt to engineer a shift to pensions held by individuals, not the state.

Whether or not a rebate-only personal pension – where you only knew what you were putting in – could ever replicate the state second pension – where you knew what you would get out – was always going to depend on assumptions about investment and mortality.

In a defined-benefit scheme, such as Serps, the benefits accrued when you are younger are worth less than those you build up close to retirement, so the rebates should have risen with age. To keep it simple, the then Secretary of State Norman Fowler did not bother with age-related rebates and set a flat rate. That meant the prudent advice was to take the rebate when you were young but contract back in after a certain age when the rebate was no longer enough to have even a chance of replicating Serps’ benefits.

What a mess. In the Pensions Act 1995 they tried to clean it up by introducing age-related rebates that did rise with age. But with changing investment and mortality assumptions, the rebates and the cost to the Government just kept on rising.

Since 1988, contracting out into personal pensions has been dogged by hideous arithmetic. Millions are losing out. The ABI wants contracting out to be retained and reformed. That has been tried at least once.

Perhaps for money-purchase schemes and personal pensions, all those contracted out should be contracted back in – and a ghastly chapter in Britain’s financial history could be brought to a close.


Berkeley offers MPPI holiday waiver to young borrowers

Berkeley Alexander is cutting the cost of mortgage payment protection insurance for younger people in a new product offering a three-month payment waiver. Mortgage Lifeline introduces age-banding and an initial three-month payment holiday, reducing premiums for young policyholders. Berkeley Alexander claims that 85 per cent of people taking out an mortgage payment protection insurance policy […]

Mortgage Trading Exchange now available to all introducers

Mortgage Trading Exchange is now available to all introducers in the UK following a roll-out of MTE stand-alone.Every mortgage introducer will now be able to use the MTE regardless of what sourcing orpoint of sale systems they are currently using.Rather than using various lender websites, each of which work in different ways and may require […]

Property deal in partnership

Ansar Housing is introducing an Islamic house purchase partnership contract. Under the property purchase agreement, which is claimed to be compliant with Sharia law, the company and client jointly purchase the property. Under a separate agreement, the buyer rents the property and, during the tenancy, the client can buy some or all of Ansar’s property […]

People on the move

InvestmentSpike Hughes is to take on overall responsibility for marketing at Skandia Investment Management. The announcement follows David Orr’s announcement that he will leave the company to join Gartmore. The move means Rob Swan, Henderson’s former head of marketing and research, and Frank Blighe, former head of UK marketing at Threadneedle, will take on increased […]

Embrace simplicity!

By Fiona Holmes, proposition communications manager When I first took out critical illness cover, I was overwhelmed. It wasn’t just the form filling, it was finding out about the sheer number of illnesses I was covered for. Did it give me peace of mind that I was covered for neuromyelitis optica or systematic lupus erythematosus? […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm