View more on these topics

Robert Reid: Experts are blind to real advice issues


Research recently published by Citizens Advice on pension freedoms showed that of those who didn’t spend the funds they realised, 29 per cent of them put the proceeds in their bank account.

In addition, 9 per cent of people had unforeseen tax problems such as tax deductions they weren’t expecting, rising to 30 per cent among people who took their whole pension pot in one go. If that wasn’t bad enough one in eight people using pension freedoms face unexpected tax or welfare losses.

Citizens Advice is an acknowledged expert in state benefits. Given that, how did its delivery of Pensions Wise not pick all this up as part of its standard process? Or did it limit its guidance to pensions only?

I make this point as the general public may have assumed it would take state benefits in to account, especially when Citizens Advice is the default go-to with state benefit queries.

Of those who experienced tax or benefit problems after using the pension freedoms, 64 per cent managed to get these resolved and 87 per cent said this was easy to do. So in other words over one-third were unable to resolve matters or in financial services speak, one-third is the potential complaint ratio!

This research underpins my theory that what is proposed under FAMR is more about placating providers than delivering a worthwhile solution to the mass market.

Robo-advice may not be the answer as it simply seeks, in too many deployments, to replicate current process and without the regard for illogical actions/objectives of clients.

It may seem that I am stating the obvious but if we don’t engage people, we can build what we like but they won’t use it in great numbers. To be more specific those who will use it are not those disenfranchised by RDR.

In the film Field of Dreams starring Kevin Costner, it had the recurring mantra of “build it and they will come” I don’t think that will work here as matters are being over-simplified.

Just because people are not high-net-worth doesn’t mean that they have easy issues to decide upon – far from it. When we have all of these “experts” telling them what to do – based on what they would do, we have the retirement advice forum akin to the childhood game “pin a tail on a donkey”. In this case it’s the “experts” that are blindfolded! It’s like using your bike to show your kids how gifted you are then coming a cropper.

FAMR, in its current format, will not sort the problem as those who guided it didn’t have a clue about the lifestyles of those they were asked to help. What I would describe as a “Marie Antoinette” moment.

We have to reach people differently and that means using the FCA sandbox properly and not to hold on to what is not working already.

The first step is education, not of the public, but of the “experts” – please stop telling people what they should do when you have no idea of the pressures they are under today.

The Government needs to stop tinkering and provide a robust framework; the complexity of Isa options being a case in point. The recent issues over Help to Buy Isas just underlines this very point – changing the website now doesn’t absolve you.

The public need to understand consequences with regard to risk both investment and longevity. It is clear that they are taking an extremely short-term view when selecting options, as this CAB research proves. It’s time for considered action not more pontification.



Hoarding cash and benefits hit: The realities of pension freedoms

A worrying number of consumers are using pension freedoms to transfer their pension pot into their bank account, research suggests. Citizens Advice, which provides the face-to-face guidance service through Pension Wise, has published a research report today examining consumers’ experience of pension freedoms. It has based its findings on a survey of 500 savers over […]


Mike Morrison: When is the deadline day for FAMR?

Last week I was invited to sit on the panel for a debate about the Financial Advice Market Review. The panel was an interesting group of eminent industry people – and me (I quipped on Twitter before that I was the only one that I had not heard of.) In the run-up to the event […]

Andrew Bailey BBA Conference 2012 480

Bailey: No conviction that FAMR will work

FCA chief executive Andrew Bailey has told MPs he does not know if the Financial Advice Market Review proposals will close the advice gap – one of the key objectives of the report. Appearing in front of the Treasury Select Committee committee today, Bailey was asked by Labour MP John Mann if consumers can expect to […]

Childcare - thumbnail

Three questions for employers…

The Family and Childcare Trust’s annual survey has been widely reported in the media and the two headline figures were these: the average cost of a nursery place for a child under two has risen by 33 per cent since 2010; and the costs have risen by five per cent in a single year.


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There is one comment at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. I very much agree with Robert Reid here. The less you have the more complicated it becomes, hence the more expensive to find and explain a solution.

Leave a comment


Why register with Money Marketing ?

Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

Money Marketing Events
Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

Research and insight
Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

Have your say
Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

Register now

Having problems?

Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm