View more on these topics

Danby Bloch: Making sense of Osborne’s CGT cuts

Danby Bloch white

The cuts in capital gains tax for most investments are set to make a major difference to tax and investment planning.

Just to recap, George Osborne announced in his March Budget the rates of CGT would be reduced by 8 per cent after 5 April for the tax year 2016/17. Most gains that have previously been charged at 28 per cent will be subject to the rate of 20 per cent, which will apply to the taxable disposals of higher or additional rate taxpayers.

Other taxpayers and non-taxpayers will only have to pay 10 per cent CGT on their taxable gains – down from 18 per cent. The new rate of CGT for trusts and estates will generally be 20 per cent as well.

Readers with long memories will recall  in the 1980s Nigel Lawson took the view there was no logical reason why the tax on capital gains should not be the same as the tax on income – so he plonked a 40 per cent tax rate on both income and gains. Way back, more elderly readers will be dimly aware capital gains were taxed at the relatively low flat rate of 30 per cent and until the early 1960s they were not taxed at all.

The wheel has now gone (nearly) full circle and Osborne has decided to bring the rates down again, even though most gains are real and hardly at all now boosted by inflation.

Back when CGT rates were nil or at least very low, investors were driven to seek capital gains rather than income. In the 1970s and earlier, income tax rates were stratospheric, so the incentive was even greater. And the drive to focus on capital gains will be bolstered further this year with the new larger differentials opening up between the taxes on income and gains.

Not all capital gains will be accorded the new lower rates of CGT. Capital gains from residential property will continue to be taxed at the old rates of 18 per cent for basic rate, starting rate and zero rate taxpayers and 28 per cent for higher and additional rate taxpayers. It was yet another twist in the knife for buy-to-let investors and the owners of second homes.

But remember, these rate changes are set against the background of a continuing freeze on the annual exempt amount of £11,100.

So what will be the consequences of the changes for investment planning?

In theory at least, the cut in CGT rates should make investors more willing to incur tax bills on their gains to optimise their portfolios. Recommendations to switch and rebalance portfolios once investors have reached their annual exemption often come up against clients’ reluctance to incur tax costs. People naturally weigh the certainty of the tax cost against the imponderability of the further future gains.

Two behavioural finance biases come into play. There is prospect theory – we all hate losses roughly twice as much as we like profits. And there may be variation of this bias in which we dislike the certainty of immediate losses even more than twice as much as we savour the prospect of uncertain future gains.

The other behavioural bias is status quo affect (sic). We like what we already own more than we like assets that we do not yet possess. Both these biases can make it especially painful to pay a tax bill in order to achieve a better designed portfolio.

So it will be interesting to see whether lowering the pain threshold by cutting the tax costs will turn out to make investors more prepared in practice to switch their investments around. Logically it should. In reality, it might not.

One of the side effects of lowering taxes generally is tax wrappers can look less attractive in relative terms.

Someone might argue an Isa is relatively less attractive than it was in comparison with holding funds in a general account, especially with the first £5,000 of dividend income now free of tax.

The £11,100 exempt amount covers most people’s gains and then 10 per cent is not much to pay if the gain exceeds this tax-free limit. And that is true, but it omits some crucial factors.

First and foremost, Isas are still completely free of UK taxes on income and gains, and they do not need to be reported to HMRC. So investors can be confident they won’t have to pay tax on them. It is all a lot simpler. But also potential gains have a habit of a building up and creating unexpected and unwelcome lumpy taxable surprises.

More concerning are the threats to the relative attractions of life assurance bonds. These have the characteristic of eventually turning capital gains into income. So as capital gains have now become even more attractive than income in tax terms, the comparative tax position of bonds for individuals have become less beneficial for capital gains.

Confusingly, in recent years, life assurance bonds have accrued some additional relative advantages for income tax planning.

So as tax becomes even more complicated and confusing, the role of advisers becomes ever more important and valuable. But you have to keep up to date to be able to add value.

Danby Bloch is chairman at Helm Godfrey



Collapsed claims firm misled investors over fundraising

Failed claims management firm Rebus did not disclose the extent of its financial problems to over a hundred new investors just before it entered administration. Rebus collapsed in February, shortly after receiving £816,790 through the Crowdcube crowdfunding website. Investors are likely to have lost their cash permanently. However the Times reports the firm kept the […]

John Lawson: How a pensions dashboard can be delivered by 2019

As expected, the Budget deferred draconian change on pension tax relief to another day and instead gave us a halfway house to the pension Isa called the Lifetime Isa. The Lifetime Isa looks like a good idea for young people saving for their first home and is certainly more flexible than the current Help to Buy Isa. […]


PM admits he owned shares in offshore fund as Panama Papers scandal deepens

Prime Minister David Cameron has admitted holding shares in an offshore fund run by his late father for 13 years. The Prime Minister has been under pressure to disclose his position since his father was implicated in the massive data leak from Panamanian law firm Mossack Fonseca. Until yesterday Number 10 had been prepared only […]


Cameron to defend inheritance tax planning

Prime Minister David Cameron will reportedly set out a robust defence of the right of parents to pass money to children today, after a weekend of pressure over his own finances. Cameron published a statement of his tax affairs since 2010 yesterday, in a bid to draw a line under claims he had profited from […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There is one comment at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. If I remember rightly only about 2% of people ever pay CGT, so even if they they cut CGT to 1% it would make little difference overall – a great marketing exercise that won’t actually cost HMRC very much at all, especially by excluding property!! However there is still a place for using onshore Investment bonds invested in equity-based funds for investors who have used both their CGT and dividend allowances (if they had one) who invest over the longer term. So that would be trustees in particular!!

Leave a comment


Why register with Money Marketing ?

Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

Money Marketing Events
Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

Research and insight
Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

Have your say
Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

Register now

Having problems?

Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm