View more on these topics

Chris Gilchrist: George Osborne is repeating the mistakes of Gordon Brown

Chris Gilchrist 700

I resented having to listen to a fourth Osborne Budget within 12 months. The mild entertainment gained from an embarrassing switch in the economic weather forecast from sunny to threatening since December was tempered by the realisation that 99 per cent of the population will not have a clue all the big Budget numbers are fiction.

Listening to the Budget speech on 16 March, there was a horrible moment when I realised Osbo has turned into Gordo. Halfway through Osborne’s list of the charities that had each received a few millions from the fines levied on banks for Libor rate fixing, I felt I had re-entered a Brownian nightmare. One thing everyone who had to listen to Gordon Brown’s Budget speeches hated was the seemingly endless and confusing list of tiny announcements that had nothing to do with fiscal policy.

Confirmation came in the form of a “big” Osborne announcement about education policy that likewise had nothing whatever to do with fiscal policy. Lots more irrelevant micro-announcements followed, while big questions about the national finances were skirted or dodged.

Then as I listened to Osborne’s refrain throughout his Budget speech about “the next generation”, I remembered Brown’s drone about “prudence”. Just as that should have been enough to tell us Brown was not really being prudent with the national finances, Osborne’s steamrollering repetition of “the next generation” should warn us he is not really doing anything for the next generation. The Institute of Fiscal Studies confirmed with its Budget analysis the measures mainly benefited higher earners and savers – by definition, these are not the young.

The Budget as a spectacle tempts Chancellors to play to the gallery – and the more they do that the worse policy gets. Last autumn the outlook was rosy, today it is threatening – but the accuracy of forecasts has deteriorated massively since the end of the boom in 2007. You would be justified in thinking basing government policy on such uncertain forecasts is a bit mad. Banking on around £10bn of unspecified spending cuts to make his sums for 2020 add up suggests the Chancellor agrees.

Chancellors love wheezes and Osborne’s is the Lifetime Isa. Like Brown, Osborne has been Chancellor too long and has come to believe you can prompt significant changes to the way people behave through modest financial incentives. History mostly shows you need big, dramatic incentives to effect change.

The only change Osborne announced that is sure to have such effects is the cut in capital gains tax rates. We can expect a raft of schemes transforming income taxable at 40 per cent into gains taxable at 10 per cent – to be followed by anti-avoidance measures and eventually a switch back to more or less equal income and gains tax rates.

The Lifetime Isa is not a pension substitute. It is in fact a turbo-charged version of Help to Buy, which will give a government bonus of up to £32,000 (rather than a mere £3,000) to people saving to buy a first home. I predict a lot of the savings going into the Lifetime Isa will come from parents helping their children pick up the bonus – why wouldn’t you? But you have to question whether that is a good way of deploying the taxes we pay to solve Britain’s housing crisis.

Chris Gilchrist is director of Fiveways Financial Planning 

Recommended

The ongoing fight for pension freedom clarity

Spot the difference between these two questions: How many people have withdrawn more than the 25 per cent tax-free allowance from their pension fund as a lump sum since 2014? How many people have withdrawn lumps sums of more than 25 per cent from their pension savings since the freedoms were introduced in April 2015? Now, […]

John Lawson: How a pensions dashboard can be delivered by 2019

As expected, the Budget deferred draconian change on pension tax relief to another day and instead gave us a halfway house to the pension Isa called the Lifetime Isa. The Lifetime Isa looks like a good idea for young people saving for their first home and is certainly more flexible than the current Help to Buy Isa. […]

Pensions - thumbnail

Another growing blip on the pensions radar…

There is an awful lot going on in the pensions arena at the moment. Indeed, the radar for the next couple of years is jam-packed with actions that employers need to take or be aware of. And as these legislative blips move ever closer to their target date, so employers need to spend more time understanding the issues involved. One such topic is the subject of pension fund automatic transfers, which is targeted to commence in autumn next year.

Newsletter

News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up

Leave a comment