View more on these topics

Tom Baigrie: MAS is a lesson in how not to spend other people’s money

Tom Baigrie

When spending one’s own money we are generally very careful, but few of us can maintain the same standards when spending the money of people we do not even know and who cannot know us.

No one paying for the Money Advice Service ever thought it was good value. I doubt even Otto Thoresen did and it was his report that was tweaked by a Labour Treasury to create the body in the first place.

Pioneers need to be brave and bold and must often waste money, and because it was yours and mine and not theirs or their friends. Those at the MAS were heroically bold and wasted more or less all the vast budgets they were accorded by the FCA from funds you and I paid for.

Those who created the MAS spent it all on action-free web pages, smart offices, great team-building and producing spurious web statistics to pretend success. And all those key commentators who had long called for the ending of advice ordinary people felt they could afford (but the cognoscenti felt was far too expensive) salved their conscience by referring those ordinary people to the dry, dull web pages that sadly ensured no one did very much of anything.

The Government has now sought to end the wastage, and thank goodness that it is the case. But there is a parallel here with current and ongoing wastes of money, and the amazing ability of those with huge budgets, but who cannot be held directly accountable, to waste taxpayers’ money, just like the FCA and Treasury have done with ours.

The hardest challenge left now in relation to the MAS is to find someone who might feel personally responsible for that wasted £400m that has been spent on it since its creation. Who was the mandarin or minister who enacted it all, and what misconduct rules will see them fined like the senior bankers have been?

There was a clear failure to spot or stop the rip-off while it was happening. For a time the politicians behind the MAS have seen their careers flourish, but yet they to continue to live in happy anonymity.

What is more, I am not sure the eminent investigative journalists who should be exposing and highlighting this shambles feel inclined to do so. Perhaps because they were all for seeing advisers’ money being spent on a grand experiment in competing with advisers.

I would love to see an expose of just how the decisions behind the MAS scenes were made that wasted £400m. Is anyone up for writing that book?

Tom Baigrie is chief executive of LifeSearch


Lee Robertson

Lee Robertson: MAS should have been reformed, not abolished

Last week’s Budget contained some big news for advisers, not least the announcement of the demise of the Money Advice Service. After six controversy-filled but rather self-congratulatory years it appears MAS is to be retired by the Chancellor. Those six years have seen runaway spending of over a third of a billion pounds, which beggars […]


Advertising watchdog denies conflict with Govt on ‘misleading’ MAS

The Advertising Standards Agency has denied that the Government declaring the Money Advice Service’s branding “misleading” conflicts with its own verdict on the service. A 2011 advertising campaign sparked 80 complaints to the ASA after the MAS advertised its services as “free, independent advice”. At the time, the ASA ruled customers would understand the campaign […]


Caroline Rookes: Advisers’ money has not been wasted on MAS

The Money Advice Service chief executive Caroline Rookes says Treasury proposals to scrap the organisation do not mean advisers’ money has been wasted and that the “MAS legacy has not been lost”. The Treasury revealed plans to close the MAS as part of a restructure of guidance services, with parts of the organisation folded into […]


Leader: MAS has finally been read its last rites – so what next?

After years of criticism, and almost £400m of advisers’ and other levy payers’ money, the death knell for the Money Advice Service has finally sounded. Money Marketing has long been a challenger of MAS in a bid to drive accountability about how it spends the phenomenal sums of money it receives courtesy of the financial […]

In Focus image

In Focus — May 2015: private medical insurance market in Germany

Welcome to the latest edition of In Focus. In this issue, Jelf examines the private medical insurance market for employers with expatriate workforces in Germany. This includes the common challenges faced in sourcing appropriate coverage, along with a selection of available solutions. This will be of particular interest to HR/reward decision makers with employees based in Germany. It will assess the cultural norms, risks and backdrop that are relevant to organisations with expatriate staff in this location.


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There are 2 comments at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. Time for an FOI request Tom?

    They do throw up some interesting things about spending other peoples money.

    For example the FCA.

    Financial advisers in fee block A013 may be interested to know that for the fee year 2015/16 the latest forecast for FCA regulatory fees to be invoiced was £74.85m.

    So, with this thought in mind, we asked if the regulator could confirm what it actually costs to regulate this group of adviser firms.

    The reply should be the cause of some concern.

  2. Pauline Forbes 1st April 2016 at 6:54 pm

    One for the next update of ‘The Blunders of our Governments’ I reckon. I doubt it will be the only chapter in the making either.

Leave a comment


Why register with Money Marketing ?

Providing trusted insight for professional advisers. Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

Money Marketing Events
Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

Research and insight
Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

Have your say
Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

Register now

Having problems?

Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm