View more on these topics

Malcolm Kerr: Lamborghinis are still on the table

New research shows the majority of retired people live with more wealth than they need

Malcolm_Kerr_EYThe Institute for Fiscal Studies has published some interesting research this month.

Entitled “The use of wealth in retirement”, it suggests that, unless there are large costs at the end of life (it shows for many this is not the case) the majority of wealth among today’s retirees is set to be bequeathed rather than spent in later life. Good news for the children and grandchildren.

The IFS definition of wealth excludes the value of defined benefit pension schemes, but as we know from transfer value illustrations, this “invisible” category of wealth can be very valuable. I suspect DB pension payments are why many of those in retirement are able to leave bequests. For those with defined contribution schemes, the children and grandchildren will not be so lucky.

Indeed, some parents may choose to blow some of the money on a new car. As former pensions minister Steve Webb said, it is “people’s choice whether to buy Italian Lamborghini sports cars”. Of course. Why not?

Rachel Vahey: Pension rules on early retirement due to ill health

Take my fictional friend Freddie. He is 55 years old, his children are all grown up, his mortgage nearly paid and he has a decent income. He has no idea when he will stop working and already has about £400,000 in his Sipp plus a bit of DB pension from a previous employer.

To say Freddie is a petrol head is an understatement. His current car is a relatively sensible BMW M4 convertible, but he has just seen his dream car in HR Owen.

He told me all about it. “It’s a 2006 Lamborghini Gallardo Spyder with 19-inch five-spoke alloy wheels and a Grigio roof. This means you listen to that 5.2-litre V10 with the hood down. Being able to hear it clearly intensifies the thrill. I must buy it!”

I told him that of course he could buy it, provided he was prepared to make some sacrifices such as going without his regular Americano from Starbucks on his way to work and back. He looked at me as if I was mad. I suggested we do some sums.

The dream car was for sale for £89,950. He reckoned he could get £30,000 for his BMW, so he needed to raise £60,000. I told him he could take it out of his Sipp.

Reducing his Sipp by £60,000 would mean that, in a 4 per cent drawdown model, his retirement income could be reduced by £2,400 a year. After tax, that would be about £1,500, which is about £125 per month – say £4 a day. Exactly the cost of the two Americanos.

Clearly, this is a tongue-in-cheek example and I would obviously have told my fictional friend to talk to his financial adviser. But the point is that Webb’s analogy remains pertinent in a world of single-digit returns. And, who knows? The classic Lamborghini might appreciate over time. It will certainly provide more fun.

Innovation falling on deaf ears

On a more serious note, I was invited to deliver a presentation on retirement income at Money Marketing’s recent Retirement Summit. One component focused on why new retirement propositions – particularly those with some form of risk mitigation – had so far failed to gain traction with advisers.

Andrew Tully: Planning strategies to beat the lifetime allowance

Responses included: “Too expensive”, “too complicated”, “not enough time to look at them” and “we don’t need new propositions”. To be honest, I wasn’t at all surprised.

To start the talk, we had a short quiz on the words behind the acronyms. All hands went up for RDR, FAMR and, needless to say, FSCS. Not so many on Mifid II, even less on Priips and only one on CPPI, which stands for constant portfolio protection insurance – the bedrock of some of the new retirement propositions mentioned above.

Again, I was not surprised, but I was a bit disappointed. It is clear any provider aiming to provide a new way of ensuring people do not run out of income in retirement faces a tough challenge – if they want to market through advisers, at least.

Encouraging numbers 

More positively, the June FCA Data Bulletin had very encouraging 2017 numbers, with total advice firms’ revenues up by 22 per cent from £3.2bn in 2016 to £4.5bn. Adviser staff numbers rose by 3 per cent to 26,311.

During the year, about 500,000 new ongoing fee clients signed up and about 130,000 ceased. The total number of clients paying ongoing fees rose to about 2.8 million. That is truly impressive.

Malcolm Kerr: The keys to high standards

Profitability was a mixed picture. Firms with one adviser averaged about £30,000, two to five advisers about £70,000, six to 50 advisers about £145,000 and firms with more than 50 advisers an average loss of £241,000, although apparently due to the performance of one firm.

Interestingly, there are only 35 firms in the UK with more than 50 advisers and the majority are vertically integrated.

One has to wonder if some of them are being subsidised by the revenues from in-house platforms and funds.

As we all know, the potential for this to occur was recognised by the regulator and rules were contained in the RDR to ensure it did not happen.

Will the numbers be different next time around? I am not confident.

Malcolm Kerr is an independent consultant



Steve Bee: Why we need an extra pension system

The problem with the pension system in this country is that our labyrinthine piles upon piles of bewilderingly complex rules and regulations are in place, by and large, to stop a tiny number of people from saving too much money. But the vast majority of the population save far too little for the future. This […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There is one comment at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. How do you know what people ‘need’? That they don’t spend all they have is not a failing, it is simply to ensure they are prepared for all eventualities. Better to be in a decent care home than have to rely on the NHS. If the tricky PMI companies refuse to cover certain treatments self funding becomes an option.

    The very idea of blowing the lot is precisely why the UK is the world champion in personal debt. If this is the type of financial advice that clients are getting it is nothing short of scandalous.

Leave a comment


Why register with Money Marketing ?

Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

Money Marketing Events
Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

Research and insight
Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

Have your say
Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

Register now

Having problems?

Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm