View more on these topics

Is Nest trying to solve a problem that does not exist?


The recent consultation on the future evolution of Nest seeks to expand its remit in a number of ways, but principally in providing retirement income products. However, is Nest right when it claims its members lack appropriate choices and that it should step into the breach?

An insight into Nest’s own view of the market – the market it thinks does not serve its members – can be gleaned from its own response to the consultation. Nest says “the wider pensions industry” focuses on “mass affluent savers” with “pot sizes of £100,000 or more”.

Nest’s view is that the pensions industry does not serve mass market savers. These savers are not defined but presumably the “mass market” applies to people with pot sizes less than £100,000. Let us test Nest’s view.

Firstly, annuities. Annuities are widely available on the open market at purchase prices of £10,000 and above. They are available to existing customers of individual insurers at lower purchase prices. Annuity choice is also available to Nest members from £1,500 “at similar market rates to those with larger pots”.

From this brief market review, it is safe to assume the vast majority of mass market savers, including those with the smallest pots, can buy a competitive annuity if that is their preference.

And what about drawdown? Well, that is available to people with just £1 of savings. The drawdown fund can be built up with regular monthly contributions of £100 or less. Or single contributions of £1,000. Or transfer values (say from Nest) of £5,000 or less.

The charges for DIY drawdown are also very competitive with platform and passive funds (just like the passive funds that Nest use) for 50 basis points or less. Therefore, drawdown also serves the bottom of the mass market at very competitive charge levels.

“There is already oodles of choice, at competitive prices, even for those savers with the smallest pension pots. So it is difficult to see the gap in the market that Nest seeks to fill”

It is arguable whether those with the smallest pots actually need complex solutions anyway. Most people with savings of £20,000 or less would probably benefit most by either taking their whole pot as a lump sum or drawing it as smaller lump sums over three or four years to minimise tax.

That leaves mass market customers in the £20,000 to £100,000 bracket.

We can already conclude that at this level customers have a wide choice of annuities and DIY drawdown. But what about those who want some exposure to investment risk and some longevity protection?

Investment-linked annuities are also available from £10,000 purchase price or savers can blend a conventional annuity with drawdown to best suit their needs. Those who want to wait and see are also catered for, either parking their drawdown money in cash or buying a fixed-term annuity.

There is already oodles of choice, at competitive prices, even for those savers with the smallest pension pots. So it is difficult to see the gap in the market that Nest seeks to fill.

If Nest’s members have difficulty negotiating the market then I am sure it could assemble a competitive range of drawdown, investment-linked annuities and fixed-term annuities to add to its existing lifetime annuity panel. It might also persuade Pension Wise to offer bespoke guidance on these carefully selected options.

Nest is in danger of seeking to solve a problem that does not even exist. Whichever option it decides to take, it is clear market failure is not an issue.

John Lawson is head of financial research at Aviva


Otto Thoreson 700.jpg

Nest chair responds to concerns over expansion plans

Nest chair Otto Thoresen responds to concerns over the Government’s proposals for expanding Nest. Other providers are saying this is an example of mission creep, is this fair? No. Nest was set up in a world where most of our members were compelled to annuitize and we had a retirement journey in place which reflected […]


Bloated: Is the Govt’s plan for Nest a step too far?

Radical Government proposals for the future of Nest could redraw the UK’s pension landscape. Under the plans – which Money Marketing can reveal now has cross-party support – the state-backed provider would expand both into the post-retirement product market and open as a personal pension firm targeting individuals. The wider industry warns without a sign […]

Otto Thoreson 700.jpg

Nest loan rockets to £460m as rivals warn of ‘mission creep’

Nest’s loan from the Department for Work and Pensions has rocketed to £460m, a 19 per cent increase on last year. The Government-backed auto-enrolment scheme’s annual reports – published today – show the loan has grown from £387.1m at March 2015, to £459.6m at the same point this year. Nest says the loan is to […]

IHT: What were you doing in 2009?

One of the best sources of new business is your existing clients and, if they are estate planning clients, regular reviews are needed because people’s inheritance tax (IHT) problems tend to only get worse. Now, not a lot of things remain at the same rate as in 2009. If we turn the clock back, it […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers. Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm