View more on these topics

Robert Reid: Waspi affair is waking people up to pensions


When Ros Altmann was looking into Government instead of looking out, as she is now as pensions minister, life must have been so much simpler. As advisers we are always being warned about conflicts of interest, yet politicians are seemingly exempt.

Pension freedoms released money into the economy just as the access to Lifetime Isas will encourage money to be spent instead of saved. If we made people pay the money accessed back into the Lifetime Isa and charged them interest on that “loan” the product would, in effect, be the fixed interest part of their savings. That to me is far smarter than what has been proposed.

Meanwhile, the Women Against State Pension Inequality campaign rumbles on. The reality is the changes made in 1995 were not announced in a blaze of publicity. As a result, they did not reach those affected, so the communication – for what it was – failed miserably.

And this is not the first time this has happened. When women were given the option of paying less National Insurance back in the late 1960s it resulted in them being tied to their husband’s state pension age instead of theirs. However, a lack of communication made many unaware of the drawbacks of this lower-cost option. Part of the reason for the Waspi revolt is that there remains confusion. A lot of people see the state pension as a form of savings, whereas it is in fact a benefit and subject to change.

But perhaps one positive to come out of the whole sorry affair is more people are becoming engaged in the need to plan for retirement. There is clearly now an acceptance by the younger generation that they may need to work in some way past the age of 65. What would concern me is if that generation were to rely on the state pension as income from a specific date, when it is more than likely they will see their state pension age continue to slip into the horizon.

It is ironic that we seem to be heading backwards and not forwards with regards to state benefits, with automatic enrolment not even remotely contributing to a gap that is getting bigger all the time. It is clear auto-enrolment will need to push up contributions and the fact they are still to be age-related remains a puzzle to me. When you are forcing people to save you need to be very careful the level of contributions you set is going to deliver something of substance.

I cannot really see us getting out of this spiral unless pensions are taken out of the Government’s control. When governments are in place for five years and the problem we are dealing with is over a far longer period, there is a clear conflict that needs to be addressed.

I would like to think Altmann will educate the Treasury in the need to encourage long-term savings where access comes with strings. That way we will not be facing a nation with no option other than to work until they drop.

Robert Reid is director of The Ideas Lab


FCA logo new 3 620x430

FCA slammed by complaints watchdog over handling of whistleblower

The Complaints Commissioner has slated the FCA over its handling of a whistleblower’s report citing admin errors, poor communication between departments and “insufficient rigour”. The FCA must pay the complainant £300 compensation as well as carrying out a proper assessment of the information and evidence the whistleblower has, if they agree to it. The complainant wrote […]


MPs launch inquiry into DB schemes following BHS collapse

MPs are to launch a new inquiry into the sustainability of thousands of defined benefit schemes as the BHS and Tata Steel scandals draws attention to occupational plans. Committee chair Frank Field has branded the DB funding crisis “one of the great problems of this age”. The Work and Pensions Committee has been grilling trustees, […]

2016 Global Survey of Individual Investors: How is investor behaviour rewriting the job description for financial professionals?

Trapped between expectations for near double-digit returns and strong apprehensions about investing in persistently volatile markets, investors worldwide are of the opinion that professional financial advice is worth the fee. But even though they believe individuals who work with a financial professional are more likely to achieve their goals, investors have a clear vision of […]

Platforum head of intermediary research Miranda Seath

Platform focus: White elephants and the future for Standard Life/Elevate

Devotees of financial services and the twittersphere cannot have failed to notice Standard Life is celebrating the 10-year anniversary of its wrap. The recent announcement of the group’s acquisition of Axa Elevate offers an opportunity unprecedented in this decade long history. This week, we look at the implications of the acquisition and what lies ahead […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There are 3 comments at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. Excellent article Robert, sadly both major parties use pensions as a political football, kicking it back, forwards, sideways and even off the pitch at times. The lack of long-term vision does indeed lead to policy making to suit the government of the day, and leads to great uncertainty and often poor decisions get overlaid with even poorer decisions still. Not much to be done about it I am afraid, democracy is great but has it’s downsides.

  2. Robert

    I’m glad that someone with gravitas has addressed the matter of the abysmal savings regime we now have in the UK. Our savings rate is below 4%. (Against that in Germany 17%, France 14% and Spain and Italy above 8%)

    All the proposals and intended solutions are just tickling round the edges and will probably make no difference at all. What I believe is needed is a serious attempt to curb the unfettered spending. We are the most indebted nation in the world – bar none. Our economy is totally reliant on people going shopping. (What an abysmal state of affairs). Therefore the Treasury is not inclined to do anything to curtail the retail industry and indeed actually encourages more and more profligacy.

    Government utterances on savings and investment are therefore just crocodile tears. There doesn’t seem to be any real effort to address the problem – to the contrary.

  3. State Pension is not a Benefit. It is contribution based and dependant on contributions paid in.

Leave a comment