View more on these topics

Leader: Too much freedom isn’t always a good thing

Natalie Holt, journalist with Money Marketing Photo by Michael Walter/Troika

The Government likes change, apparently. That is probably because they are not the ones that have to deliver it.

This week Money Marketing reveals the next pensions evolution being eyed up by the Government. So far we have had pension freedoms themselves, the spin- off changes to taxation of death benefits, and the planned creation of the secondary annuity market.

Lately, the Chancellor has focused its attention at the other end of the savings spectrum with the introduction of the Lifetime Isa. Not content with that daunting package of reforms, policymakers have now set their sights on shaking up auto-enrolment.

The Government is understood to be floating an idea with the pensions industry that would allow employees to choose their own auto-enrolment scheme, thus completing the “freedom and choice” savings cycle George Osborne is so keen to engender.

By extending pension freedoms to the workplace, the argument is this would go some way to alleviating the small pots problem. An employee would be able to keep paying into the same pension regardless of job moves, and would have the freedom to choose which scheme is best for them. The ultimate hope would be it brings in an added layer of competition into the auto enrolment market.

Yet although there is some rationale to these arguments, the question that is more difficult to answer is, “why now”? Is the current market environment really the right time for this particular kite-flying exercise, when pension freedoms have already opened up a Pandora’s box of challenges as it is? The reforms have undoubtedly boosted engagement among savers, but the long-standing issues of insistent clients, unauthorised firms and the ever-present danger of scams all are yet to be addressed.

It strikes me there is a parallel here with the work being carried out by the new guardians for workplace pensions – the independent governance committees.

These are made up of expert members of the pensions industry who take the lofty position of holding providers to account on value for money and punitive exit penalties. These bodies have begun to move the market, and, despite efforts to get at the numbers, one has to assume they are paid handsomely for the privilege.

So is it right we would hand over these same responsibilities of deciding what a good scheme looks like to those that have to be compelled to save in the first place?

Too much freedom and choice is not always a good thing.

Natalie Holt is editor of Money Marketing. Follow her on Twitter here



Govt eyes pension freedoms for auto-enrolment

Radical plans to let employees overrule their employers on workplace pensions risk tearing up the rules around automatic enrolment, Money Marketing can reveal. The Government is exploring reforms that will see staff pick their own auto-enrolment scheme, with the aim of drastically reducing the number of small pension pots and at the same time boosting engagement among […]


Sean McSweeney: End of auto-enrol commission bigger than RDR

The end of pension commission has arrived and the world for corporate advisers has fundamentally changed forever. This will have a more profound effect on corporate advisers than RDR or sunset clause has on their private wealth peers. Acting as a “broker” to distribute other people’s products is not a sustainable business model. Corporate advisers […]

Is Workie working? TPR figures cast doubt on £44m auto-enrol comms campaign

Experts have questioned the effectiveness of the Government’s £44m auto-enrolment ‘Workie’ communications campaign after figures from The Pensions Regulator revealed less than a quarter of employers have been encouraged to act by the adverts. The Workie campaign was unveiled by the Department for Work and Pensions in October. Although the DWP initially said it would […]

Mark Page: why my biggest overweight stock is a discount Spanish retailer

Artemis European Opportunities Fund manager Mark Page is questioned about the merits of investing in Spanish supermarket group, Dia. Dia is a 7,000-store Spanish discount supermarket chain. But with cheaper food prices coming on to the market and an improving Spanish economy, journalist Alexis Xydias questions Mark about its inclusion in the Artemis European Opportunities […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There are 2 comments at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. You are so right. This argument should have been applied to the forthcoming referendum as well. It should never have been offered ion the first place and it is only because Cameron can’t control his own party that we are having it at all. No other party would have even countenanced it.

  2. What do you expect from politicians, or those that seek positions of power? They nearly always act in their own best interests and frankly even the so called experts such as Ros Altmann, know vastly less than people suggest they do and more to the point, they simply don’t understand the ramifications of their agenda’s…

Leave a comment


Why register with Money Marketing ?

Providing trusted insight for professional advisers. Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and thought leadership.

News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

Money Marketing Events
Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

Research and insight
Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

Have your say
Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

Register now

Having problems?

Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm