View more on these topics

Leader: MAS has finally been read its last rites – so what next?

Natalie Holt, journalist with Money Marketing Photo by Michael Walter/Troika

After years of criticism, and almost £400m of advisers’ and other levy payers’ money, the death knell for the Money Advice Service has finally sounded.

Money Marketing has long been a challenger of MAS in a bid to drive accountability about how it spends the phenomenal sums of money it receives courtesy of the financial services industry.

At best, we have been accused by the organisation of holding grudges, and, at worst, pursuing a kind of vendetta or crusade against the service.

While no one can argue with the stated aim of improving financial capability, the execution has been poor from the outset.

The litany of its failures is endless: the use of the word “advice” in its branding (something the Treasury has only now admitted was a fatal mistake); the chief executive that earned £350,000; another chief executive who dared to question adviser ethics; the notorious “breath of fresh air” ad campaign; consumer research that showed a third of consumers did not remember using the  service; and the final slap in the face, the Government spurning MAS in having a meaningful role in the delivery of Pension Wise.

A lot of this happened early on in MAS’s existence, but the past ultimately proved too difficult to shake off.

Advisers are well versed in MAS’s sordid history. But I come back to the reason MAS was set up in the first place – improving financial capability to help consumers take control of their money.

As Moneysavingexpert founder Martin Lewis writes for us this week, MAS had just about turned a corner. It had started to identify a clearer role for itself that removed the duplication of other services, with a focus on boosting understanding around finance and debt.

So what next? In the Budget, the Government has set out plans to restructure the organisations behind guidance, and set up a single pensions guidance body for savers whenever they need it, rather than just at retirement.

The separate but related work on the Financial Advice Market Review has delivered a raft of proposals designed at boosting access to advice, but offers little in the way of concrete solutions.

Any new organisation needs to correct the failures of the past by having a clear direction from  the very beginning. A MAS successor that works better with advisers and actively signposts to advice would not go amiss either.

Natalie Holt is editor of Money Marketing. Follow her on Twitter: @Natalie_Holt_MM



MAS destruction: The £400m cost of failed quango

George Osborne’s decision to close the Money Advice Service brings to an end a sorry six years during which hundreds of millions of pounds of cash has been wasted on the failed body. The Chancellor revealed in the Budget the MAS will be axed as part of a restructure of financial guidance that will see […]


Martin Lewis: ‘Abominable’ MAS deserved stay of execution

Chancellor George Osborne was wrong to axe the Money Advice Service despite it being guilty of an “abominable” waste of advisers’ money, according to Moneysavingexpert founder Martin Lewis. Lewis, who has been scathing of the MAS in the past and once described the service as “crap” to the Treasury select committee, says recent reforms had […]

Money Advice Service

Treasury admits MAS branding ‘misleading’ as service is scrapped

The Government has admitted that the Money Advice Service brand is “misleading” to consumers because it does not offer regulated advice. Under proposals now under consultation, MAS will be closed, with its pension guidance remit going to a new provider, while a second body with a responsibility for money guidance will also be launched. In […]


MAS urged to ditch ‘unnecessary’ lobbying and focus on cost-cutting

The Money Advice Service is under pressure to ditch “unnecessary” lobbying activity as part of a drive to cut costs and reduce advisers’ levy bills. In its response to MAS’ consultation on its 2016/17 business plan, Apfa attacks the organisation’s proposal to measure its success in meeting its objectives through “demonstration of influence in regulatory, […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There are 3 comments at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. When the CEO of an organisation publicly “bad mouths” the very people who contibute to the funding of their organisation (and still no explanation or apology other than the claim her comments were misrepresented) then the writing is clearly on the wall and closure became a real possibility.

    Of course we may live to regret the demise of MAS for the simple reason that the parasites in the Treasury will presumably demand higher levy fees from us for the new super duper “guidance” provider.

    Sorry Natalie but asking them to “signpost” to advice just gives them an excuse to levy us rather than paying for this service from the public purse

  2. Nobody is against financial capability but advisers are already squeezed for funds to finance other ‘do good’ projects such as FSCS and FOS. The last thing we need is another industry-funded quango which throws money around because, of course, there is a seemingly limitless supply.

    The Roxburgh’s, McDermotts and other theorists need to recall the story of the golden goose. They might also give pause to the year 1917.

  3. Oh Nick –
    How true. So MAS is dead. There will have to be another Quango – otherwise where will the chosen few have another sinecure that will pay them a six figure salary for doing b-gger all.

Leave a comment


Why register with Money Marketing ?

Providing trusted insight for professional advisers. Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

Money Marketing Events
Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

Research and insight
Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

Have your say
Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

Register now

Having problems?

Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm