View more on these topics

Lifetime Isa charges still ‘punitive’ despite bonus changes


Former pensions minister Ros Altmann has joined a growing number of industry voices who are critical over the way the Government plans to apply penalty charges on the Lifetime Isa.

Last week the Government published its Savings (Government Contributions) Bill which sets out in legislation how the Lifetime Isa will work in practice.

It confirms the scheme will be rolled out from April and will allow individuals aged between 18 and 40 to save up to £4,000 a year.

The Government will top up their accounts with a 25 per cent bonus, to a maximum of £1,000.

Yesterday the Treasury clarified the bonus will be paid monthly, rather than at the end of the tax year as first planned. Monthly bonus payments will come into effect from 2018/19.

As with regular Isas the money can be put into either cash accounts or stocks and shares , with savers able to pay into the product until age 50.

Withdrawals can be made to buy a first home or from age 60, or if a saver becomes terminally ill.

Withdrawals for any other purpose will attract a penalty charge.

Treasury documents published alongside the Bill state: “Account holders will be able to make withdrawals at any time for other purposes, but with a 25 per cent Government charge applied to the amount of withdrawal. This returns the Government bonus element (including any interest or growth on that bonus) to the Government with a small additional charge applied.”

Bonuses will be paid on contributions, but unauthorised withdrawals will incur a 25 per cent penalty charge on the whole fund, including any growth.

The Treasury has told Money Marketing individuals who make a loss on their investments, will still have to pay the charge if they make an unauthorised withdrawal.

Former pensions minister Ros Altmann says the exit charge is “punitive”.

She says: “As it is an Isa, savers may think it is straightforward.  I believe it could end up as another huge misselling scandal, when workers are enticed out of their company pension schemes into what looks like a tax-free savings account which they can take money back from if they need it.

“They will then realise they have lost their employer contribution, lost out on higher rate tax relief and end up having to pay big penalties if they do actually withdraw.”

Altmann has previously called for the Lifetime Isa to be scrapped, and still believes it is “a dangerous product”.

Aegon pensions director Steve Cameron says had the Treasury not moved to paying bonuses the penalty charge could have been even worse.

But he says: “While some people might think 25 per cent taken off on exit just cancels out the 25 per cent added on the way in, it goes further than that.

“In today’s low interest rate environment, you’d be lucky to get more than 1 per cent interest on a cash Isa, so the £250 additional penalty could easily wipe out five years of interest.”

AJ Bell senior analyst Tom Selby believes the penalty for those who invest in the stocks and shares Lifetime Isa could be “horrific”.

He says: “People need to be aware of what they are getting into as it is not a product that caters for changing circumstances. If savers want flexibility, it is probably not for them given the severity of the penalty.”

But Hargreaves Lansdown head of retirement policy Tom McPhail says: “I understand why the Government is doing it. What it means for investors is they will have to think quite hard in advance about what their objectives are.”

Informed Choice managing director Martin Bamford says: “Government schemes are pretty lousy when it comes to flexibility.

“The penalty could be quite harsh if savers make an ineligible withdrawal so they should only use the Lifetime Isa for what it is intended for.”



Govt to pay Lifetime Isa bonus monthly

The Treasury has announced the Lifetime Isa government bonus will be paid monthly rather than at the end of the tax year. The Treasury published its Savings (Government Contributions) Bill earlier this month, which sets out in legislation how the Lifetime Isa will work in practice. In a technical update released today, the Treasury says: […]


Govt paves the way for Lifetime Isa launch

The Government is pressing ahead with plans to roll out Lifetime Isas despite criticism over the timing and questions over product features. The Government published its Savings (Government Contributions) Bill yesterday which sets out in legislation how the Lifetime Isa will work in practice. The Bill reiterates that from next April, UK residents aged between […]


Treasury accused of ‘secrecy’ over Lifetime Isa costs

The Treasury has been accused of secrecy over its cost estimates for the Lifetime Isa after it rejected a Freedom of Information request from former pensions minister Steve Webb. The Financial Times reports Webb, now director of policy at Royal London, submitted the FoI to determine how the Government arrived at its £1.9bn cost estimate […]

Global equities: time to de-risk?

While equity valuations have doubled since the financial crisis, Simon Edelsten explains that there are still pockets of value. But not where you might think Macro-economic uncertainty is causing turbulence in equity markets. Artemis Global Select Fund manager Simon Edelsten says his investment themes are taking him in a different direction to some of his peers – away […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm