View more on these topics

Clear as mud: FOS’ problem with the new advice definition


So the Treasury is consulting the industry about its proposal to change the definition of advising on investments as stated in article 53 of the Regulated Activities Order 2001. The proposed new definition would be based on the one in Mifid. The object of the exercise is to provide clarity so firms would know with greater certainty when they are offering advice that is regulated and when simply offering guidance, which would not be regulated by the FCA.

There are several difficulties with the proposal. First, I doubt very much whether the change would provide the clarity everybody seeks. The proposed definition would be different and would include concepts absent from the current one and vice versa. In the end an adviser would still have to decide whether what he was offering to a client was, or was not, within the definition.  He would still have to struggle with the meaning of the words and would likely be as unsure as he is now as to whether the new definition applied or not.

The consultation paper sets out the broad differences between the definitions.  In essence, the current definition says that for the advice on investments to be regulated it must:

  • Relate to a relevant investment, which includes contracts of insurance
  • Be given to a person in his or her capacity as an investor or potential investor (or as agent for such an investor), and
  • Relate to the merits of buying, selling, subscribing for or underwriting the investment (or exercising rights to buy, sell, subscribe for or underwrite such an investment).

The Mifid definition of investment advice involves the provision of personal recommendations to a customer, either upon the customer’s request or on the firm’s initiative. It comprises three main elements:

  • There must be a recommendation that is made to a person in his or her capacity as an investor or potential investor (or as agent for such an investor)
  • The recommendation must be presented as suitable for the person to whom it is made or based on the investor’s circumstances
  • The recommendation must relate to taking certain steps in respect of a particular investment which is a Mifid financial instrument, namely to buy, sell, subscribe for, exchange, redeem, hold or underwrite a particular financial instrument (or exercise a right to buy, sell, subscribe for, exchange, or redeem a financial instrument).

Those definitions are different but both are complex. And complexity is unlikely to result in clarity.

Second, and in any event, all financial advisers are responsible for what they say to clients, whether or not that amounts to, or includes, regulated advice.  Further, if what is said to a client does include regulated advice, any other related advice is likely to be regarded by a court, or the Financial Ombudsman Service, as part of the regulated advice.

Some years ago, in the context of the definition of investment advice in the Financial Services Act 1986 (which was broadly similar to the current definition), Mr Justice Jonathan Parker said:

“Advice as to the ‘merits’ of buying or surrendering an ‘investment’ cannot sensibly be treated as confined to a consideration of the advantages or disadvantages of a particular ‘investment’ as a product, without reference to the wider financial context in which the advice is tendered.  … [A]nd, as one would expect, any advice as to the merits of purchasing or surrendering an ‘investment’ is designed to be based on as full an examination of the client’s personal circumstances as the client is prepared to allow.  … [I]t seems to me that it must follow that the concept of ‘investment advice’ will comprehend all financial advice given to a prospective client with a view to or in connection with the purchase, sale or surrender of an ‘investment’, including advice as to any associated or ancillary transaction notwithstanding that such transaction may not fall within [the scope of any regulated business].”

Thus, no matter how clear the definition is to a particular adviser, and no matter how limited the advice is intended to be, a court or the FOS is likely to include and to look at everything that passed between the adviser and the client, and make up its mind whether the advice was, or was not, regulated and compliant based on that full picture. Even if it is not regulated but is negligent and has caused the client loss, the adviser would be liable.

So the change is unlikely to meet its objective. It might be better for those who feel insecure about the meaning of the current definition to put more effort into getting to grips with the existing rules and designing their methods of working to fit in with what they are seeking to achieve.
Peter Hamilton is a barrister specialising in financial services at 4 Pump Court and co-founder of 



Robert Reid: Let’s make advice terms clearer for consumers

I always wondered when phone recording would become the default. It reminds me of the police interviews on television where the twin cassettes enable the defence to get a copy of the recording too. I am keen on the requirement being taken further to video recording, as are the professional indemnity insurers. Of course, some […]


Treasury challenged over new advice definition

Firms have raised concerns the Treasury’s proposed definition of advice does not address the lack of clarity between advice and guidance and risks taking the sector back to pre-RDR days of product-centric advice. The consultation was recommended in the Financial Advice Market Review and proposes amending the definition of advice so that consumers only receive […]


Govt launches consultation on definition of advice

The Treasury has launched its consultation on amending the definition of advice so that consumers only receive regulated advice when they are offered a personal recommendation for a specific product. In the consultation paper the Treasury says there are currently two ways of defining advice. The UK defines regulated advice as “advising on investments”, as set […]

Trusts: Easier than you think?

Protection providers often extol the benefits of placing plans in trust. The advantages for clients are widely recognised and numerous – inheritance tax mitigation, avoiding probate delay, controlling claim proceeds, and so the long, familiar list continues. Yet, dismissed as unnecessary form-filling, or simply viewed as irrelevant in the context of a mortgage sale, less […]

Europe: Domestic backdrop & China impact

By Rob Burnett, Head of European Equities In recent weeks equities have been buffeted by two shocks occurring at the same time: China’s devaluation of the renminbi and the prospect of the US Federal Reserve (Fed) raising interest rates. The market is not comfortable with the Fed raising rates at the same time that China […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There are 2 comments at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. Thank you very much for this Peter. Food for thought…..

  2. The reality of the situation is such that anyone who is an “adviser” would be wise to treat everything they do and say as advice and apply that standard to it

Leave a comment


Why register with Money Marketing ?

Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

Money Marketing Events
Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

Research and insight
Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

Have your say
Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

Register now

Having problems?

Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm