View more on these topics

Do investors really want Osborne’s flexible Isa?

Current rules state if an investor decides to make a withdrawal from their Isa, this has no impact on their overall allowance. If they wish to replace the money, it will count as a new, further subscription, which will eat into any allowance they have remaining.

From next tax year, Isa managers will be able to amend their terms and conditions to allow an investor to replace all or some of the cash they have withdrawn in any year without the replacement counting towards their annual Isa subscription allowance. The withdrawal may be made as a cash lump sum or could be in the form of dividends automatically paid to the investor’s bank account. The new flexibility will not be extended to Junior Isa accounts.

Withdrawals will first be set against current year subscriptions, effectively increasing the investor’s remaining allowance for that tax year. The flexible Isa manager monitors the amount clients can pay in by recording the “net” value of current year’s subscriptions. Net subscription = current year subscriptions – total withdrawals in tax year.

Withdrawals of current year’s subscriptions can be replaced in any Isa. If the amount withdrawn exceeds the amount subscribed to the Isa in the current tax year, the excess is treated as a withdrawal of previous years’ subscriptions. Previous year withdrawals can be replaced but only to the Isa account from which they were withdrawn.

For clarity, if there are no withdrawals within a tax year, the subscription allowance operates in the same way as a non-flexible Isa.

Where the account has been transferred after the withdrawal was made, the right to replace this cash is generally lost.

Case study: Martin

In 2016/17 the subscription limit is £15,240 and Martin decides to:

  • Subscribe £10,000 on 1 May 2016
  • Withdraw £5,000 on 1 October 2016
  • Subscribe £3,000 on 1 November 2016.

The net subscription allowance remaining for 2016/17 is £7,240. This can be made to this or another Isa.

Case study: Alison

In 2016/17 Alison withdraws £11,000 from her Isa account on 1 May 2016. As she has not yet subscribed in this tax year, this counts against previous years’ subscriptions. The £11,000 withdrawn can only be replaced within the same Isa. Alison’s remaining original allowance of £15,240 can be subscribed to this or another Isa.

Case study: Jane

In 2016/17 Jane:

  • Subscribes £10,000 on 1 May 2016
  • Withdraws £15,000 on 1 October 2016.

Of the amount withdrawn, £10,000 is counted against the current year’s subscriptions and the excess £5,000 against previous years’. Jane can only replace the £5,000 withdrawal (relating to previous years’ subscriptions) within the same Isa. She also has a remaining current year allowance of £15,240 to subscribe to this or another Isa.

If Jane subscribes £3,000 on 1 November 2016 she can replace another £2,000 (previous years’ subscriptions withdrawn) within the same Isa. Jane still has her remaining current year allowance of £15,240 to subscribe to this or another Isa.

When a client has withdrawn both current and previous year subscriptions and replaces any subscriptions, the replacement is deemed to replace any previous year’s subscriptions first.

A question of demand

Echoing the question marks surrounding the secondary annuity proposals, demand is a big unknown. HM Revenue & Customs has published potential costs of Isa flexibility to the Exchequer but has also confirmed to us it did not make an explicit assumption about the number of individuals who might withdraw and replace Isa wealth.

The way the rules are drafted may provide a helping hand for those waiting to see how the market develops. If an Isa manager implements flexibility at a date later than 6 April this is effectively backdated to that date, so any withdrawals made by investors earlier in the tax year can be replaced before the tax year-end.

Cash Isa investors seem the obvious group to want to take advantage of the flexibilities, as it may help them to make best use of interest rates on offer. However, with venturing into investment markets widely accepted as a long-term strategy, the same may not be true of stock and shares Isa investors.

Any financial planning clients will no doubt have liquid capital available in the case of unforeseen circumstances, so are these clients also out of the mix?

Cash Isa investors looking to understand the rules may struggle for assistance from their banks. A Which? mystery shopping exercise last year raised concerns over the lack of knowledge of the basic Isa rules among customer services staff, with over half the institutions contacted unable to answer even 50 per cent of the questions correctly.

So we have uncertainty around providers’ ability to help investors and, more importantly, questions over whether investors want or need it. Is this change for change’s sake?

Let’s hope the tinkering associated with pensions does not start to creep its way over to the Isa rules. The last thing we need is yet more fear of complication to undermine the incentive for people to save more.

Charlene Edwards is technical resources consultant at AJ Bell



Chelsea RedZone: £110bn sitting in worst-performing funds

Total assets in the Chelsea RedZone list of the worst-performing funds has grown by £10bn since October 2015. The number of funds in the latest RedZone, which lists the worst funds in each sector over the past three years, has risen from 239 to 259 since October, with assets growing to £110bn. With 50 funds on the […]


ECB chair Draghi defends banking stability

European Central Bank president Mario Draghi has defended the stability of Europe’s banks following a sharp drop in lenders’ share prices last week. Speaking at a hearing of European Parliament’s Economic and Monetary Affairs committee, Draghi said banks are in a “very different” situation to the financial crisis and that regulation has paved the way […]


Zurich UK Life recruits new CFO from Ageas

Zurich has hired a new chief financial officer for its UK life business, recruiting the finance director of fellow insurer Ageas. Helen Pickford will join the business after more than eight years as Ageas’ finance director, succeeding current chief financial officer Neil Evans when he retires on 1 April. Evans departs the firm after 28 […]


IFS: Pensions best investment but flat rate tax relief will undermine saving

The impact of automatic enrolment means pensions remain the most tax-efficient major form of saving, the Institute of Fiscal Studies says. In a report comparing the impact of recent tax changes and charges, matching employer contributions make saving through pensions “much more attractive than almost any other option with the same underlying return”. But it […]

Inheritance tax and estate planning – exemptions and reliefs

By Kim Jarvis, technical manager with Canada Life’s ican Technical Services Team In this article we look at the main exemptions and reliefs that are available on death. Within the article, spouse also means civil partner.   Nil-rate band Under current rules, any part of the estate that falls within the available nil-rate band (NRB), […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There are 2 comments at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. Almost the right headline. Just stop before the apostrophe.

  2. Gypsum Fantastic 15th April 2016 at 4:24 pm

    Stop dem

Leave a comment


Why register with Money Marketing ?

Providing trusted insight for professional advisers. Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and thought leadership.

News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

Money Marketing Events
Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

Research and insight
Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

Have your say
Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

Register now

Having problems?

Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm