View more on these topics

Malcolm Kerr: Wearable tech will shake up UK protection market


The way in which the UK insurance industry assesses risk has been slowly evolving from pretty basic pricing models to something a little more sophisticated over the past 20 years. For example, enhanced and impaired annuity rates designed to reflect the life expectancy of specific consumer segments are now commonplace, and term insurance products promising better rates for people with healthy lifestyles have also gained share. But this is certainly evolution, not revolution.

The distribution of the products has not changed that much either. Clearly, more web-based, non-advised transactions are taking place, but even here we see price comparison sites and strong retail brands partnering with traditional distributors in order to access the market. And while new, highly efficient underwriting technology has the potential to reduce costs and improve the adviser and client experience, it is not disrupting existing provider models.

So, is there any possibility we will see actual disruption in the UK individual protection market? And could this lead to a larger market? The answer to both questions is probably yes.

Technology will be the driver and the enabler. A good example of how this can develop can be found in pay-as-you-drive motor insurance, which is gaining considerable traction in the US, Canada, Latin America, France and Norway. This solution, often referred to as telematics, helps insurers identify risk exposures and puts pricing control in the hands of customers, who can decide how much and how well they want to drive. The technology is simple and can take the form of hardware provided by the insurer or an app on the driver’s smartphone.

The key to PAYD is that drivers can receive immediate feedback through apps, emails and provider portals to keep track of their premiums. There is already evidence to show that seeing the close correlation leads to changes in driver behaviour. In the future, this could also improve underwriting and rating methodologies.

But why stop there? How about pay-as-you-live? There are already products that reflect lifestyle but wearable technology can facilitate an entirely different customer experience. Wearable technology or smartphones with similar functionality are already able to track exercise, heart rate, BMI, sleep patterns, calories and training or diet logs, alongside many other indicators, to provide immediate feedback to consumers and potentially to their insurers.

In the not-too distant future, these devices will also be able to monitor blood sugar for diabetics and track food purchases at supermarkets.They will even alert those with a high probability of deep vein thrombosis when it is time to get out of the chair and take a walk.

Evidence suggests the data available from wearable technology provides significant motivation to improve fitness and usage is growing rapidly. In California, the number of people wearing these devices already exceeds the number of people with gym memberships. And in the UK, we are starting to hear people comparing their resting heart rates in the office or even competing for the lowest rate at a dinner party.

According to the most recent forecast from the International Data Corporation, vendors will sell a total of 45.7 million wearable technology units in 2015, up a strong 133.4 per cent from the 19.6 million units sold in 2014. By 2019, total sales volumes are forecasted to reach 126.1 million units, resulting in a five-year compound annual growth rate of 45.1 per cent.

All of this has the potential to benefit consumers, reduce the strain on the NHS and provide insurers with the data to investigate modified pricing models and risk factors. It also has the potential to increase the size of the market as consumers start to connect with institutions that can provide products, services and channels that resonate with them. These might include websites more focused on healthy lifestyles instead of selling products, and giving weekly feedback on how well the policyholder is doing in terms of fitness goals and related premium rates.

PAYL is being actively explored by a number of our global clients, particularly those that already deploy PAYD products. We believe this concept will be a major area of innovation in the UK life and health markets. Furthermore, we think it has the potential to disrupt an industry that has so far remained fairly safe from the kind of disruption seen in areas such as lending, motor insurance and payments.

Malcolm Kerr is senior adviser at EY


FCA logo glass 620x430

‘Maximum assistance, minimum interference’: FCA lays bare Financial Ltd risk failings

Former Financial Ltd boss Charlie Palmer built an advice network that treated advisers as the end customer and failed to heed warnings about potential suitability risks, the FCA says. The regulator has today issued a decision notice against Palmer for failing to ensure appointed representatives gave suitable advice to around 40,000 clients. It also wants […]


Swallowed up: Consolidators under fire over client churn

The FCA has called into question the way consolidator firms approach suitability amid accusations clients are being hit with unnecessary charges and moved into inappropriate investments in the drive to gather assets. Money Marketing revealed last week that the regulator has asked consolidators to provide information on how they treat clients gained through acquisitions, and whether […]

FCA logo new 3 620x430

FCA seeks to ban and fine former Financial Ltd chief £87k

The FCA is seeking to ban and fine Financial Ltd chief executive Charlie Palmer £86,691 over failing to ensure appointed representatives gave suitable advice to around 40,000 clients. Palmer has referred the matter to the Upper Tribunal. The regulator has also fined former Financial risk management director Paivi Grigg £14,807 for failing to ensure the […]


Case study: administration — implementing a management log

Our client is a leading video game and publishing company best known for its console role-playing game franchises. The client provides a number of benefits, at varying levels and cost that attract a P11d liability. With the absence of a management log to track data for benefit movements, enormous administrative and therefore cost implications were occurring each year just to comply with P11d reporting requirements.


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There are 6 comments at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. Wearable tech is predominantly worn by people who don’t exercise but like to think that they do. I attend a popular sports club and have never seen a single one.

    As for comparing resting heart rates at a dinner party, good Lord, you need more interesting friends. I thought house prices were boring enough.

  2. Sounds like it is advocating technology first, think about the privacy implications later.

  3. I dont understand the privacy comment. Surely the person will have given consent for their information to be accessed?

  4. All wearable tech will do is break up the standard rates pool further making the purchasing of life insurance even more complicated. It also might have a credit/debit influence on the loadings for some medical conditions. It isn’t a replacement for conventional risk assessment processes unless you are going to ignore a persons medical history. I dont thinks insurers are that stupid – there again…

  5. Here’s how Malcolm’s idea of disruption could play out:
    Key point is that millions of individuals will soon have enough data to be able to select against the insurer.

  6. You guys have a paranoia complex Chris. You are talking about an industry whose systems dont talk to each other, that doesnt store its medical data in any recoverable format and whose customers dont understand how the products are constructed. Yes that level of data will eventually be collected and analysed but not in my lifetime. And what will it mean in a society where cancer and degenerative disease is the primary cause of death.

    Underwriting is about selecting out pre-existing conditions and predicting cardio vascular risk in the otherwise healthy – it is already good at doing the latter and IMHO will only refine insurers abilities not drastically change them. This use of data will be applied to smaller policies that are purchased by customers that intermediaries have largely abandoned due to the impact of RDR.

    I wish you guys who spout forth in these articles would actually talk to someone whose skill set this is before they go around fantasising on what the future will hold.

Leave a comment


Why register with Money Marketing ?

Providing trusted insight for professional advisers. Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

Money Marketing Events
Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

Research and insight
Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

Have your say
Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

Register now

Having problems?

Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm