View more on these topics

Is technology the only medicine for a flagging protection market?

As we approach the end of 2013 most life insurers have released their final results before the year end and they have not made encouraging reading, with most companies reporting new business considerably down on 2012. The EU gender directive, the change to insurance accounting rules and the introduction of the RDR have all been blamed for the drop in new business. But with demand from consumers still in evidence, could new technology revive the flagging protection market, asks Underwriteme’s Martin Werth.


2013 is almost over and probably a year best forgotten, with new business forecast to be down 15 per cent (IFA down 5 per cent and bancassurance down almost 40 per cent).

Of note in 2013 average new premiums are expected to fall, in spite of the one-off market change drivers pushing up premiums.  Amongst the gloom, one or two insurers have done less badly, reflecting the norm that in a mature market the winners are those with the lowest costs who can offer the most competitive prices.

To use a Vince Cable expression, in 2013 the protection market suffered a major heart attack, after a decade of chest pains.

The patient has survived and is in intensive care, needing strong technology medicine to recover. This includes steroids of a fast, easy and more profitable sales process.

In addition, to get the patient stronger there needs to be a change of lifestyle from transactional sales to customer relationships.  It doesn’t need a prophet of doom to foresee that the prognosis of no change will be poor.

The Swiss Re Insurance Report 2013 shows the protection market has significant growth potential, with 42 per cent of adults having life insurance and just 15 per cent with CI and 10 per cent income protection. Reading between the lines, one third of those with life insurance have CI and one quarter have IP.

Life customers are a unique group, as they have overcome the often-sited contra indicators of don’t need it, don’t trust insurers, haven’t got around to it, cant afford it. Yet many have only purchased the most basic protection component and since then may have had lifestyle changes and not reviewed their cover.

A life insurance sale should be the start of an active client relationship that reviews needs and seeks out opportunities to build a more comprehensive protection portfolio. Additional sales could be hugely valuable to advisers, as the first covers the cost of the lead generation and the subsequent, particularly on a level commission basis, could generate recurring revenue.

Whilst this is self-evident, advisers need client centric systems designed to help deepen their customer relationships.  We can learn from the investment market and how technology platforms have transformed this sector.

The Money Marketing  Wrap & Platform Report identified the highest client and adviser platform benefits being simpler administration, improved client proposition, improved client understanding and satisfaction. What if protection advisers and their clients had the equivalent technology benefits of simpler sales processes, improved service and better outcomes?

New protection technology could place advisers in control of their client experience giving them a single protection gateway and a consolidated customer view.  Technology can already provide:  

  • A single sales process that is easy and fast to use, with a full audit trail,
  • An aggregated client view of existing covers, with status updates on cover changes
  • Online client dashboard, including adviser tailored consolidated benefit statements
  • Analytical tools to identify cover gaps, quantify risk impact and cost of protection

It is also possible for customers to update their personal data to reflect changes in their circumstances.  This could include a secure site with their current health status, so that advisers can provide personalised up-sale offers.

Ultimately technology is the enabler for the quality of service and depth of relationship the adviser wants to provide to their clients. For protection specialists this would allow them to secure the first sale and develop on-going relationship designed to suit their individual client profiles. For investment advisers, this extends their client wealth management service to protection. For aggregators, this provides an opportunity for their customers to self-manage their wider protection needs, or be given access to personal advice on more complex covers.

For insurers, this could be a catalyst to stimulate market growth and get off the price treadmill.

In summary, the protection market needs to adapt to survive.  2013 new business is suffering a major trauma, following a decade of declining sales. But with strong technology medicine the prognosis could be really positive.

We need to help our existing customers understand and extend their protection needs, as well as find new customers.  Advisers are best placed to do this, and with the right client centric systems can effectively track and respond to their clients’ changing needs, in the same ways as platforms have transformed wealth management.

This would also appeal to wealth advisers wanting to provide a consistent wealth and protection service.  Looking forwards, 2014 should be seen as a redefining year, where the gain will have been worth the pain.

Martin Werth is chief executive of Underwriteme


Letter: Financial education is already in the classrooms

I read Samuel Dale’s interview with Pfeg chief executive Tracey Bleakley on how financial education finally made it into schools (MM 21 November) with interest. As vice-principal of one of the UK’s leading financial education charities, ifs University College, I must raise several counter points to some of the assertions made within the article. Contrary […]

Mark Carney 7 Feb Speaking

Carney defends interest rate guidance as he heaps praise on UK recovery

Bank of England Governor Mark Carney says the UK has the strongest recovery in the developed world as he launched a robust defence of his forward guidance on monetary policy. Speaking to the Treasury select committee today, Carney came under fire from MPs over major recent changes to unemployment forecasts which affect the threshold for […]


Govt defeated over Labour rules for higher banking standards

The Government has suffered a narrow defeat in the Banking Reform Bill at the hands of a Labour amendment calling for higher professional standards for bankers. In the House of Lords report stage of the Bill today, Labour won the support of the Archbishop of Canterbury Justin Welby and 41 cross-benchers to create a licensing […]


Case study: administration — managing group life schemes

Our client leads the global market in high-tech electronics manufacturing and digital media. The trustees of the company’s final salary pension scheme insure death-in-service lump sum and dependants’ pension death benefits for active employees, as well as dependants’ pension benefits for deferred members (those who have left service).


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm